7 ms·
MagiCan
- Gunax 6y ago>Be blind. >Buy can of delicious Coca-Cola. >Crack open that cool crisp refreshing beverage. >Sip from that cool, sweet, BLURGRGH!!!
- totetsu 6y agois that you anonymous?
- binsh 6y ago> "We are winding [the promotion] down early. There is the impression we don't like among our consumers that there is a problem with the promotion." Do they teach this in marketing school or do you pick up this kind of passive, responsibility-avoidance on the job?
- qazpot 6y agoMy all time favorite is "Mistakes were made" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mistakes_were_made https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mistakes_were_made
- Lammy 6y ago"Marc A. Franklin, a professor at Stanford University's law school and an authority on product liability, said that anyone who drank the liquid could make a strong product-liabiity case. ''All he would have to do is hire an attorney, sue the Coca-Cola Company, and he would win,'' said Mr. Franklin, the author of a standard textbook on personal-injury law. ''The only question is how much he would win.''" https://www.nytimes.com/1990/05/24/business/problems-pop-up-in-coke-promotion.html https://www.nytimes.com/1990/05/24/business/problems-pop-up-...
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoAs a company, you NEVER admit to problems; this opens you up to lawsuits, class-action ones that can end up costing hundreds of millions. They leave it up to a court to decide if there was a problem. I think the closest you get to an admission of fault is the language used in recalls, and even in those the language will be carefully chosen and reviewed by lawyers. They will NEVER say anything like "the battery in this product has ballooned up and exploded, grounding planes and burning children". At best they go "There may be an issue with the battery in this product", and that's not even the language they use, just what I vaguely remember.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- noja 6y agoand Kinder Eggs are not allowed?!
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI've done a bit of googling and if I'm reading this correct it was always forbidden (or as long as the US Code has been around) to have products containing "a non-nutritive object", but it was re-emphasized for Kinder Surprises specifically after they investigated some imported ones. This was in 1997, while the MagiCan was 1990. Anyway, reading the text there, I'm fairly sure that this thing would also have been illegal under that code.
- em-bee 6y agomy understanding is that the non-food item may not be enclosed by the food, because someone could try to take a large bite and swallow the non-food item. the coke prize cans don't seem to violate that as the non-food item and the liquid are separate. lucky they didn't outlaw cherries, plums or peaches.
- fyfy18 6y agoIsn't that why kinder eggs have a rather large plastic shell that contains the toy? I haven't seen one in years, but from my memory, even an adult would be unable to consume - or swallow enough to choke on - the plastic shell.
- em-bee 6y agoright, you'd have to wolf it down believing that it must all be edible. it is conceivable that someone takes a large bite that causes the inner container to open up and let small pieces of plastic fall out into the mouth. but the law was not written for kinder eggs. i can imagine much more dangerous products. i believe in germany they approach this with better product testing. instead of blanket rules for what is allowed and what not, individual products are tested for safety, and get regulated based on that.
- 6y ago
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoAt least nobody died, unlike this competing sugar water promotion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pepsi_Number_Fever https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pepsi_Number_Fever
- Lammy 6y agoDon't forget disfiguring Michael Jackson in a pyrotechnic accident while filming a commercial, leading directly to his drug issues and two decades of publically-acceptable body-shaming about his nose and other issues: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/music/artists/pepsi-nearly-killed-michael-jackson-story-behind-controversial/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/music/artists/pepsi-nearly-kille... "Jackson underwent a series of surgeries to fix his burns. The hair on his head reportedly never grew back, forcing him to wear a wig. The accident has been pinpointed as the start of a string of plastic surgeries that would come to define Jackson’s life and image, the medication he took to ease the pain becoming a life-long crutch."
- war1025 6y agoThat's really interesting. I had never heard of that before.
- sercankd 6y agoThat was a wild ride of reading, >"They formed a consumer group, the 349 Alliance, which organized a boycott of Pepsi products, and held rallies outside the offices of PCPPI and the Philippine government. Most protests were peaceful, " .... > "but three PCPPI employees were killed by a grenade thrown into a warehouse in Davao,[13] and a mother and child were killed in Manila on February 13, 1993, by a grenade thrown at a Pepsi truck." What the hell
- c3534l 6y agoI'm not sure I'd want my customers to associate my product with a "foul-smelling liquid."
- drno123 6y agoI never understood why they didn't fill the sealed container with regular coke anyway.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CodeBeater 6y agoProbably because they were using well-circulated currency for their lower prizes ($5, $10, etc...), and they were afraid of contamination as the prize appears to be touching the liquid itself.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoA little extra cocaine wouldn't impact Coke though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 6y agoSince they specifically don't want people to drink it (contamination, perhaps), how would that get them closer to the objective?
- stronglikedan 6y agoWeight. You need to approximate the weight of a full can using less liquid.
- DonHopkins 6y agoTell that to the Coors Brewing Company! Beer and soda cans used to have removable ring-tab openers that people would drop into the can before drinking, so they could accidentally swallow it and slice up their digestive system. If they didn't just drop them on the ground to slice up people's feet. http://westerndigs.org/ring-tab-beer-cans-are-now-officially-historic-artifacts/ http://westerndigs.org/ring-tab-beer-cans-are-now-officially... >The ring-tab design began to be phased out in 1975, after injuries were caused by people swallowing the metal tabs. It was replaced with a new modification called the StaTab, which used a flange of aluminum on the lid as a lever to press down on the sealed opening, a design that’s still in use today. https://boards.straightdope.com/t/why-the-switch-from-pull-tabs-on-soda-to-those-things-that-bend-in/609953 https://boards.straightdope.com/t/why-the-switch-from-pull-t... >They were a litter problem but they also hurt people who would (stupidly) drop them into the can and then choke on them, or drop the on the ground to get stepped on. The sharp edges ehre just asking for trouble. Also they were generally more difficult to open than pop-tops are.
- lukeholder 6y agoCheck out the advert for the MagiCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBCKnhFwE_4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBCKnhFwE_4 "If you see anything other than coke, don't drink it!"
- Animats 6y agoIt was worse than that.[1] One can was opened by cabin staff on an American Airlines flight. They weren't sure what it was, so they assumed the worst, a bomb. The plane made an emergency landing. They'd succeeded in angering a customer who bought millions of cans a year. [1] http://archive.is/gsl4f http://archive.is/gsl4f
- strombofulous 6y agoTo anyone on 1.1.1.1 who can't resolve archive.is, add this line to your hosts file: 151.106.9.30 archive.is
- whitepoplar 6y agoUgh, why can't 1.1.1.1 resolve archive.is?
- strombofulous 6y ago1.1.1.1 doesn't provide EDNS information, and the archive.is admin has decided that dealing with dns queries without this field is difficult/annoying and simply returns an invalid result.
- StavrosK 6y agoThat's not accurate, they use the information to combat abuse. EDIT: Why the downvotes?
- tomalpha 6y agoTo offer an honest answer to an honest question: Coming to this a couple of hours later I don't perceive what you're saying to be any different to the parent. 'Difficult/annoying to deal with' could easily match 'used to combat abuse'. An assume-good-faith reading of both of these looks the same to me. I'd guess you were downvoted for the "That's not accurate" bit.
- 6y ago
- kristopolous 6y agoI bet this is what Donald Norman has in his nightmares
- DonHopkins 6y ago>Pepsi's promotion also suffered from negative publicity when it was discovered that if two specific Cool Cans were stacked in a certain way, the designs appeared to spell out the word "SEX". Makes me wonder why there was never a moral panic around Post Alpha-Bits breakfast cereal or Campbell's Alphabet Soup.
- function_seven 6y agoThe allegation toward Pepsi was that the can design was intentionally done so that—when six-packs were stacked in the grocery store—some portion of them would line up to spell "SEX". There was (still is?) a mini-moral panic around subliminal advertising, and Pepsi trying to do that wasn't well received. You can judge for yourself here: https://i.imgur.com/H1OV1iC.jpg https://i.imgur.com/H1OV1iC.jpg I'm not sure Alpha-Bits or the soup have had labels with naughty words on them.
- pubutil 6y agoI’d have to see more of the can design but this looks weak to me. The 'S' and 'E' are each one color. The ‘X’ is both red and blue, and seems to only exist because part of a 'P'(?) intersects the background. But what do I know?
- function_seven 6y agoThen how do you explain the fact that you just bought a case of Pepsi, despite not having done so in years? But yeah, I'm leaning toward this being a coincidence rather than a masterful scheme to juice sales. The 'X' isn't even fully-formed. It is a "P", and the can designer was probably just plonking down random letters from "PEPSI" in the background.
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoSo lets say I was really really thirsty, somewhere on the road in the middle of nowhere... and I stopped at a gas stop, bought myself a really really cold, refreshing coca cola, drive on, 10 minutes later decide to open it.. and a dollar would pop out? So i'd waste my time at the station/store, waste my time at another, all for 1 dollar?
- alias_neo 6y agoThis was my first thought. If you'd stopped for a drink, because you really wanted a drink, you'd be more than a little annoyed to get some small cash prize and no drink when you opened it. One could probably curb their anger if they won 1k-100k. I feel like this was their biggest mistake here, not just putting Coca Cola in the can. EDIT: According to the advert it could be up to $500 in a can.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- koliber 6y agoIn the worst case scenario, you could consider the $1.00 a refund.
- IgorPartola 6y agoExcept in places that charge a tax and $0.05-0.10 can deposit.
- calmworm 6y agoThough a can of coke wasn't $1.00 30 years ago, I might still be annoyed at a $1.00 prize for a $0.50 can. On the other hand, the story itself would be worth more than $0.50.
- variaga 6y agoCorrect - I remember the MagiCan promotion. At the time (1990), a $1 can of Coke would be far above the norm. (Later, in 1993, being charged the princely sum of $0.85 for a can of Coke triggered Michael Douglas' breakdown in the the movie "Falling Down", as it didn't leave enough change from a dollar for him to use the payphone. The past truly is a foreign country.) It was still a dumb promotion. I was packing a can of coke with my lunch pretty much every day at the time, and if I'd opened one at the jobsite and discovered nothing drinkable, just a dollar (and no easy way to spend that dollar to buy a new coke), I'd have had some harsh words for the coca-cola company.
- imtringued 6y agoWhen I buy a can of coke I don't want a stupid MagiCan.
- DonHopkins 6y agoI wouldn't mind! Pre-owned, opened $5 MagiCans are going for $650 - $800 on eBay now. https://www.ebay.com/itm/Ultra-Rare-MagiCans-COCA-COLA-Classic-MAGIC-Summer-1990-Promotional-Can-5-Prize/324142056925 https://www.ebay.com/itm/Ultra-Rare-MagiCans-COCA-COLA-Class... https://www.ebay.com/itm/1990-MagiCan-Promotional-Coke-Can/283354305642 https://www.ebay.com/itm/1990-MagiCan-Promotional-Coke-Can/2... While you can get an opened can of Billy Beer for less than a buck. https://www.ebay.com/itm/Billy-Beer-Billy-Carter-Beer-Can-Pull-Tab-12-Ounce-circa-1976/203048581453?hash=item2f46a3794d:g:wZkAAOSwsJFe8qIB https://www.ebay.com/itm/Billy-Beer-Billy-Carter-Beer-Can-Pu... But you still would have been better off investing that $5 from the MagiCan in Apple stock.
- SifJar 6y agoThey are listed for those prices, but those listings have been around for a while; the $650 one has been listed for at least 2 months, the $800 one for at least 8 months, and neither is sold. It would be more informative to find listings where the can actually got sold, there's no evidence here that people are willing to pay $650-800 for these (in fact, I'd say there is evidence to the contrary)
- kube-system 6y agoYou can filter for recently sold listings on eBay. There are zero relevant results for "coca cola magican" under the "sold" filter. The evidence demonstrates nobody is buying MagiCans on eBay.
- Aardwolf 6y ago> To make the cans feel and weigh normal, and prevent people from easily finding the prize cans, a sealed area within the cans was filled with a mixture of chlorinated water and a foul-smelling substance to discourage drinking. How does the foul-smelling substance prevent easily finding the prize cans? I don't get it. Did that fluid actually touch the money? If not, why not make that fluid just also cola?
- kevincox 6y agoMy understanding is that this was a separate compartment that existed to provide weight and "slosh" as if there was cola inside. I presume the didn't use Cola because it was a sealed compartment and wasn't expected to be opened, so why waste the resources?
- jagged-chisel 6y agoThe water was used to prevent easily finding cans. Chlorine was added to prevent muck growing in the water. A foul-smelling substance was added to discourage drinking the water.
- mojomark 6y ago> How does the foul-smelling substance prevent easily finding the prize cans? I don't get it. The fluid was used to artificially weight the can so people couldn't easily detect. The foul smell was simply to prevent not-so-bright consumers from trying to drink the fluid. > Did that fluid actually touch the money? If not, why not make that fluid just also cola? The fluid was sealed in the can and segregated from the spring loaded payload (money or certificates). So, two chambers: one with fluid for weight decoy, and a second for the payload prize. As for why they didn't just use cola vice chlorinated water, it could have been a number of reasons (e.g. corossivity of cola on the sealed chamber material, cost at scale), but if I had to guess it was that the magican's we produced in a separate facility using separate tooling than the cola filled cans. I have no idea why I'm spending my time writing this, but I do appreciate the post as I vividly remember being enthralled with the prospect of money popping out of a coke can as a child and wanting to then rip-open the can to see how it worked. Though this never happened for me or any of my friends who were pretty avid coke drinkers back in the day :_(
- wilhil 6y agoSilly question maybe... Why didn't they just put the prize in a sterile packet and fill it with Coke like normal?! Seems like it would solve pretty much all the complaints and issues!
- vidarh 6y agoSounds like it'd be risky. Either it's small enough that it might come out while someone is drinking, posing a potential choking hazard, or it's big enough that people would need to open the can. Want to bet on what the accident rate would be for kids trying to cut open a can?
- gregoriol 6y agoNot sure I'd be happy to find something floating inside a can... Plus how do you get it out? The opening of the can is pretty sharp, could be dangerous especially with children
- notatoad 6y agoi think the US has some laws that forbid non-edible products being embedded in the middle of foodstuffs. IIRC that's the reason kinder surprise eggs are banned.
- mrguyorama 6y agoI'd be surprised. Bags of toys in sugary cereals is a mainstay of the breakfast cereal industry
- RandallBrown 6y agoThat's not inside the food. It's next to the food. I suppose you could argue the same thing for this drink too, but I imagine it was just hard to get the spring loaded mechanism to be sterile and food safe.
- himinlomax 6y agoSoda companies are basically marketing / advertising machines. Their products are mostly worthless, as in, if all Pepsi and Coke disappeared from the world suddenly, nothing whatsoever would be lost. Except, eventually, an untold amount of pounds of fat in the belly of their former customers. So it's no surprise their marketing department go wild with completely ludicrous ideas.
- lamby 6y agoI'll remember this whenever someone waxes lyrical about the subversive 'genius' of their New Coke campaign.
- jccalhoun 6y agoI remember seeing the commercials for this. I never saw one in person though.
- codezero 6y agoThis is funny, I don't remember it at all from my youth, but they mention the Monsters of the Gridiron promo by Coca-Cola, and I remember brute-forcing that number to guess a Super Bowl winner. I never followed through because you need to actually mail in your cap to claim the prize :( The Monsters one was a halloween promo, and I still kind of vaguely remember the haunting vincent price talk track when you call the 800 number, but I'm sure i've constructed that memory :)