6 ms·
So, why exactly is it that color e-ink displays try to make every micro-capsule capable of switching to any of the supported colors; rather than laying (groups
by derefr 6y ago
So, why exactly is it that color e-ink displays try to make every micro-capsule capable of switching to any of the supported colors; rather than laying (groups of) CMYK micro-capsules out in a subpixel-like arrangement, and then wiring them to the substrate such that each of the CMYK "bitplanes" forms an independently-addressed display signal?
Sure, it'd look like badly-registered offset printing, but that only matters for small up-close displays, not large far-away displays. (And you could fix the registration with a precisely-cast diffuser layer, convolving each subpixel-cluster.)
If this was for reading rather than imagery, and you wanted to have true blacks, you could also just step one level forward in e-ink technology, and have the colored micro-capsule groups be just dual-tone (the capsule's color plus black), giving you {C+K, Y+K, M+K, K} bitplanes.
Are e-ink display manufacturers just imprecise in the way they deposit the capsules into the panel, making it impossible to address individual capsules? (If so, that seems like something that could be solved pretty easily with modern photolithography processes, e.g. etching onto the backing electrode a grid of "buckets" for individual micro-capsules to fall into.)
- sparker72678 6y agoYes, modern e-ink capsules are not precise. In fact, they're not intended to be. If you look at an e-ink display under a microscope you'll see that the "pixels" are more like "shards" of variously-shaped cells. https://twitter.com/sqfmi/status/1178018736684580865 https://twitter.com/sqfmi/status/1178018736684580865 The "pixels" are made of the actual addressing grid that creates the currents that attract the pigment in the capsules. This is part of what ends up giving the appearance of a higher-resolution display when rendering text, as you get some softer edges "for free." (And it's what makes the display look 'blurry' for some viewers.) So, to your question, there's currently no attempt with the technology to precisely place the colors on the display. The capsules are just spread all over, and the grid does the work.
- naravara 6y agoThis makes me sad. Based on what you're describing it's sounding like my dream of having eReaders that are anywhere near sharp enough to do visually rich, full color, documents justice (e.g. nature photography, comic books and graphic novels, well illuminated manuscripts) will never come to fruition. Barring some kind of transformative breakthrough, of course.
- justincormack 6y agocolour printing is often made from randomised dot screens, so long as they are small enough its fine.
- ajuc 6y agohttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a6/ConeMosaics.jpg/300px-ConeMosaics.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a6/Co... Rods in eyes aren't on a regular grid anyway, why should it matter how the pixels are distributed as long as they cover the plane and are mostly uniform?
- mumblemumble 6y agoBecause of what was mentioned way up in the original question: The capsules not being precisely arranged means that they can't be individually addressable. Meaning that you can't use the trick that non-epaper screens typically use where each "pixel" is actually a tightly packed cluster of individual red, green and blue sources that are individually controlled. So instead, each cell is capable of displaying any color, and they've got a more complicated refresh mechanism that they use to "write" to them. And the upshot of that is listed in the specifications from the linked page: The refresh time on this display is 15 seconds. Which is far, far away from where it would need to be in order to be a practical option for color e-readers.
- bduerst 6y agoExcept you can do multiple colors, by introducing differently charged pigments inside the capsules: - https://www.eink.com/assets/img/technology/GIF_Cup_E.gif https://www.eink.com/assets/img/technology/GIF_Cup_E.gif - https://www.eink.com/assets/img/technology/GIF_ACeP_E.gif https://www.eink.com/assets/img/technology/GIF_ACeP_E.gif Refresh rate was always an issue, but it is gradually improving. For static reading it's not a problem.
- mycall 6y ago> Meaning that you can't use the trick that non-epaper screens typically use where each "pixel" is actually a tightly packed cluster of individual red, green and blue sources that are individually controlled If there was a way to mix the inks and have them 100% separate by the grid on demand, it could be possible.
- Waterfall 6y agoThe contrast ratio will never make it good for text. I have used the so called high res ones and I would take a 720p LCD any day. They are trash.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bearbin 6y agoAs a reflective display, you want to optimise for the percentage of useful light reflected back to the user. Switching the white (or black) out for another colour will necessarily reduce the contrast ratio of the display, which is of course not ideal when you don't have much light to work with in the first place (as it's a reflective display after all). That's why reflective LCD displays were pretty much a disaster, since the LCDs require a polarisng filter which absorbs a large portion of the light, and reflective colour LCDs more so, because that multiplies with the effect of the colour filters. Of course, you could simply make a matrix of tri-tone capsules, with white, black and colour. Then you have the contrast ratio and the colour space advantages. I don't know why this hasn't been done, I'm not an expert on e-Ink!
- amelius 6y agoAlthough nobody implemented this yet, I'm guessing someone did patent it already ...
- NoodleIncident 6y agoColored e-ink displays are discussed at around 8:00 in this video; there are probably better sources, but this is the one I'm familiar with, so I figured I'd link it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsbiO8EAsGw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsbiO8EAsGw The microcapsules are not individually wired up to anything, so I don't think it's feasible to make each color channel independently addressable. Instead, a grid of wires behind the capsules are either positively or negatively charged, in order to attract or repel the charged colored particles in each capsule. There are only 2 charges, but by using different sizes of particles for different colors, you can finagle it so that the color you want ends up on top. If they could address capsules individually, that would also increase the possible resolution of a black-and-white display; they'd do it if they could. But since the mechanism is about attracting and repelling charged particles, there's probably a pretty hard limit on how much you can increase the resolution before there is interference between neighboring pixels.
- amelius 6y ago> And you could fix the registration with a precisely-cast diffuser layer, convolving each subpixel-cluster. Would that still look like paper, though?