3 ms·
You're doing exactly what you're criticizing... Anecdotes are meaningless, yours included, it doesn't matter if it's Idris Elba or the Queen of England, what m
by lm28469 6y ago
You're doing exactly what you're criticizing...
Anecdotes are meaningless, yours included, it doesn't matter if it's Idris Elba or the Queen of England, what matter are stats, and they don't lie, a non negligible percent of people get real sick and will have lasting effects.
Is it a coincidence that the only first world country that failed at containing the epidemic tells everyone that "it's not that bad", "not so many people will die", "there are no side effects", it's a disgrace.
- dustinmoris 6y ago> Anecdotes are meaningless, yours included Agreed, which is why I specifically point out to look at statistical facts and not individual stories. > You're doing exactly what you're criticizing No, because I specifically point out to look at the actual numbers rather than individual stories ;) > Is it a coincidence that the only first world country that failed at containing the epidemic tells everyone that "it's not that bad", "not so many people will die", "there are no side effects", it's a disgrace. Not sure which country you are talking about. I live in the UK and think there's many things we could have done better and many things where we overreacted. I don't think any country has contained the virus, as the virus cannot be contained. We see small outbreaks everywhere, so it's difficult to claim that anyone has contained it. For every country which has done X you'll find another country which hasn't done X and their curves still look incredibly similar. Take Sweden as an example. We haven't heard any news on Sweden for a while, which can only mean that they must be doing well now and looking at their curves they did flatten indeed and their death counts are drastically going down. So I think anyone who is smart enough not wanting to embarrass themselves will know to hold back with any premature clever comparisons until a couple years down the line.
- matwood 6y ago> Take Sweden as an example. We haven't heard any news on Sweden for a while, which can only mean that they must be doing well now and looking at their curves they did flatten indeed and their death counts are drastically going down. There's been a lot of news on Sweden. Last week: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/07/business/sweden-economy-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/07/business/sweden-economy-c... Just a couple of days ago: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sweden-covid-coronavirus-deaths-make-sweden-example-of-how-not-to-deal-with-covid-19/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sweden-covid-coronavirus-deaths... Daily deaths have gone down, but Sweden remains the 5th worse with overall deaths per capita in the world. It will be interesting to see how the Swedish strategy plays out when the summer ends.
- thu2111 6y agowhat matter are stats, and they don't lie Sadly stats do lie, all the time, and especially in this particular event. Just a few days ago it was discovered that Public Health England was defining a "COVID death" as literally any death of anyone who had ever been infected. Under this definition COVID is a terminal disease from which nobody ever recovers. The stats reported for COVID deaths in England have been completely corrupted and nobody seems to know how long this has been going on for. Is the UK really one of the "worst hit" countries given such statistical errors? Maybe, maybe not. Nobody actually knows. The same problems are visible in other countries too. That's why there are so many cases of people reported as COVID deaths yet who actually clearly died of other cases. Governments suspended the usual judgement of pathologists, autopsies etc to find out 'true' cause of death and just assumes COVID+death = COVID death. The case count is even more corrupted. At this point I don't think there are any stats that are reliable except all-cause mortality, and even then, people routinely read things into it that aren't there. For example by assuming all excess deaths must be caused by COVID. Not a valid inference. So some newspaper has come up with some stats saying lots of people have weird, inexplicable yet vague symptoms after apparently recovering. Given how often these outlets have mis-labelled or mis-reported basic statistical data and always to the same end of creating more panic, I'm going to reserve judgement until far more analysis is done and with far more reliable evidence.