5 ms·
I think Keynes was misunderstood massively like Karl Marx. Marx said "I am not a Marxist" when he saw his ideas being put into a something bordering a religiou
by baybal2 6y ago
I think Keynes was misunderstood massively like Karl Marx.
Marx said "I am not a Marxist" when he saw his ideas being put into a something bordering a religious teaching.
And later, I think, Keynes was rather unsettled with how his works been used to legitimise a new maxim "government can print money out of thin air," from an inverse of what dominated US economic thinking before him. It was not his idea at all.
Beyond simply affirming that aggregate demand thing exists, and that a lot things in economy spin around it, he did not produce a religious edict on how to run a government monetary policy.
If he saw Keynesianists today, he would feel rather disappointed.
- zpeti 6y agoIt’s interesting to see that it’s not necessarily that Keynesianism works, it’s just that is helps governments avoid making decisions. And this has made it incredibly popular. I don’t think it can be used forever. It’s a bit like carrying on drinking on a hangover. After a while it’s going to catch up with you and the longer you carry on the worse it will be at the end.
- notahacker 6y ago> it’s not necessarily that Keynesianism works, it’s just that is helps governments avoid making decisions. This is the precise opposite of the usual critique of Keynesianism: the mainstream conservative/neoclassical arguments that [i] Keynesian macroeconomics overestimates the ability of and need for governments to intervene in the economy, and [ii] that macroeconomic stability is better achieved by designing rules for fiscal/monetary policy than giving governments free reign to make decisions
- QuesnayJr 6y agoIt is literally true that the government can print money out of thin air. This is a genuine fact about the world today, so I don't see how Keynes would draw a different conclusion. Keynes did say If the Treasury were to fill old bottles with banknotes, bury them at suitable depths in disused coalmines which are then filled up to the surface with town rubbish, and leave it to private enterprise on well-tried principles of laissez-faire to dig the notes up again… the note-bearing territory), there need be no more unemployment and, with the help of the repercussions, the real income of the community, and its capital wealth also, would probably become a good deal greater than it actually is. It would, indeed, be more sensible to build houses and the like; but if there are political and practical difficulties in the way of this, the above would be better than nothing. which is a more eloquent argument for an expansionary monetary policy than most current economists could produce.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- injb 6y agoI've never understood this. If everyone is doing unproductive "busy work" (digging up money) instead of making useful goods and services, then how could the money be worth anything?
- claudeganon 6y agoIt’s not everyone. It’s those whom the economy had rendered unnecessary for its continued growth and functioning. Keynes’ argument is that it would be better for the economy, in aggregate, to put these people to some end using government spending, ideally a productive one (his example, building homes for people) then remove them from the loop.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ori_b 6y agoSomeone has to make shovels, houses, clothing, etc. The people who find the cash also end up spending it on other things. It doesn't matter that the money isn't initially earned for useful work, as long as it gets spent on useful work. Since it's digging through a mine using drill bits to break up the rocks, you can call the idea "minecoin bitting"
- ultrarunner 6y agoI wouldn’t much like to trade the things that fill my house for shovels and other money-digging items. How many people can the economy afford to allocate to money-digging before the production of other things that support our current quality of life begins to suffer?
- QuesnayJr 6y agoYou are misunderstanding the basic idea. Keynes is writing in a time of massive unemployment and idle resources. If you have massive unemployment and idle resources, then there isn't much of a trade-off. And he even says right there in the quote it would be better to have people do something productive.
- pessimizer 6y agoKeynes explicitly wouldn't have been concerned about government debt, which is just the government's portion of the national debt. The other part of the national debt is held by the population of the country, and there is an identity that if you increase one, you lower the other. Where you decide to balance that is arbitrary, although debt held by individuals makes them individually subject to the demands of the people who hold the debt and government debt is held by the collective, which is better able to defend itself and make demands. What Keynes was concerned about was the balance of payments, and using inflation as a spring to make sure that it would always be pulled towards zero, pulling harder the farther away a nation got. The US suffers from a strong dollar policy intentionally instituted after 70s inflation that demands that the trade deficit be massive forever. A refusal to print money under those circumstances is just pawning off that debt onto individuals, and the opposite of what a "Bancor" based system would enforce (which would be a trade surplus, removing the need for increasing debt.)
- CyberDildonics 6y agoIn the 70s the US went off of the gold standard after Charles Degaulle started to repatriate his gold back to France, thinking the US did not have the gold reserves to back all their obligations. It was not clear at the time if truly floating the dollar would work at all and severe inflation was a huge systemic risk. In general this is not what I would consider a refusal to print money: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1REAL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1REAL
- baybal2 6y ago> The US suffers from a strong dollar policy intentionally instituted after 70s inflation that demands that the trade deficit be massive forever. A refusal to print money under those circumstances is just pawning off that debt onto individuals, Excuse me, the gigantic trade deficit USA has is a product of T bill, and stacks of dollars under pillows being being a preferred saving medium of rich, and middle class all around the world. It will keep increasing even if US will put Tbills with garbage rates on the market, and print dollars completely not backed by anything. USA needs an enormous shock to shock to change the situation with dollar being overvalued. They key to it is stopping the profligate govt spending.
- throw0101a 6y ago> If he saw Keynesianists today, he would feel rather disappointed. Well, what is the (your) definition of Keynesianism? Here's one TL;DR of it that I've run across: > I would summarize the Keynesian view in terms of four points: > 1. Economies sometimes produce much less than they could, and employ many fewer workers than they should, because there just isn’t enough spending. Such episodes can happen for a variety of reasons; the question is how to respond. > 2. There are normally forces that tend to push the economy back toward full employment. But they work slowly; a hands-off policy toward depressed economies means accepting a long, unnecessary period of pain. > 3. It is often possible to drastically shorten this period of pain and greatly reduce the human and financial losses by “printing money”, using the central bank’s power of currency creation to push interest rates down. > 4. Sometimes, however, monetary policy loses its effectiveness, especially when rates are close to zero. In that case temporary deficit spending can provide a useful boost. And conversely, fiscal austerity in a depressed economy imposes large economic losses. * https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/keynesianism-explained/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/keynesianism-ex...
- qnt 6y agoOne of Keynes' major contributions was to _convince_ that aggregate demand was a strong influence on economic output, and that left to its own devices the private sector would not be willing or able to perform the countercyclical spending necessary to stabilise an economy during a recession (by stabilise I specifically mean increase output back to the long run productive capacity of the economy). GDP = aggregate spending = aggregate incomes. With such a large output gap unable to be restored by the private sector, you end up in a depression. So he convinced governments to expand the federal deficit in order purchase goods & services from the private sector in sufficient quantity to kickstart economic output. So I think to say that he simply affirmed that aggregate demand exists is underselling his contribution - he managed to convince all the important policymakers of the time that it was important enough to overturn their prior thinking about how to use fiscal (not monetary) policy in a countercyclical manner. The scare quotes around money printing don't help progress the dialogue around the mechanics and consequences of government spending either. Today with a fiat currency system, the government can enact countercyclical fiscal policy by simply crediting private sector accounts, and increasing a balancing government liability electronically (note there are _no taxes involved in doing this_). No money is 'printed' (the term conveys unrealistic connotations), private sector demand deposits are simply increased electronically. The increase of these demand deposits is not inflationary unless they are used to purchase goods and services in excess of what can be supplied at a constant price level. So when we find ourselves in a situation where 20% of the workforce is suddenly unemployed due to a shutdown of economic output, the government can spend to help stabilise aggregate incomes without risking inflation, because no-one is buying stuff otherwise (and as a result, no-one would be making any income). It is certainly true that a number of economic schools of thought have tried to use his name to legitimise their ideas, and he'd likely be disappointed with a few of them.
- pdonis 6y ago> when we find ourselves in a situation where 20% of the workforce is suddenly unemployed due to a shutdown of economic output, the government can spend to help stabilise aggregate incomes without risking inflation The root problem with printing money is not inflation, it's wealth transfer. Printing money, whether it leads to inflation (increase in average price level--note that this usage of the term "inflation" is itself a product of Keynes, its older and more proper use was "increase in the quantity of money") or not, always means a transfer of wealth from whoever does not get some of the printed money to whoever does. In other words, it is a transfer of buying power. In the current situation, where the transfer is spread widely across everyone and has the explicit effect of compensating people for loss of income due to no fault of their own, it is hard to argue that the transfer is a bad thing, and it won't cause much economic distortion or misallocation of resources because the printed money is going to be spent on much the same things as the lost income would have been spent on anyway. So the buying power is being used for much the same things as it was before. However, in most cases of printing money, the transfer is very different. The way the US government has been doing it basically since the Federal Reserve existed, it is a transfer from everyone who is not a financial institution, to financial institutions. This causes serious economic distortion and misallocation of resources, because it significantly changes what the buying power is used for. That is why, for example, we have McMansions galore in the US and newly constructed office space sitting empty for years in many metro areas, while we also have many ordinary citizens having trouble making ends meet, crumbling infrastructure, and underfunded basic services: because printing money and giving it to financial institutions redirects buying power to housing purchased with mortgages and commercial construction funded with loans, instead of what the people whose buying power has been transferred away would have spent it on.
- dgut 6y agoMark supposedly said, according to Engels: "if they are Marxists, then I am not a Marxist", referring to the French socialist movement and his son-in-law, which he thought of as not radical enough, not as a rebuttal of his ideas or because "he saw his ideas being put into a something bordering a religious teaching". Be accurate.
- api 6y agoI've found two key ideas in Keynes: 1. Wealth is a verb, not a noun, at least at macroeconomic scales. The wealth of nations is measured by how much they do more than how much they have. 2. Governments and perhaps other large entities should spend counter-cyclically. This makes sense in terms of dampening cycles but also in terms of getting the most value for that money. If you can spend during a recession, you get a bargain. Keynes did not advocate unlimited money printing and he would be horrified by the sheer amount of debt in modern economies. He was critical of hard gold pegs, but didn't necessarily advocate the perhaps equally insane opposite. Also agree about Marx. His fans misunderstand him as much as his critics. What most people associate with Marx comes more from Lenin and Stalin. I would add Ayn Rand to the list of totally misunderstood thinkers both by her fans and her critics. She was a heretical liberal humanist, not a conservative and definitely not a reactionary. One curious thing I've noticed is that if you have a discussion between Marxists of the classical and less Leninist sort and Randians you will find huge areas of overlap outside economics. These include technology, the notion of progress, science, the importance of education, etc.
- opo 6y ago>... you have a discussion between Marxists of the classical and less Leninist sort and Randians you will find huge areas of overlap outside economics. These include technology, the notion of progress, science, the importance of education, etc. You can see that on a Pournelle chart of political ideology which maps ideology on a 2d graph instead of just a line. >...The x-axis, "Attitude toward the State" (labeled statism), refers to a political philosophy's attitude toward the state and centralized government. The farthest right is "state worship" and the farthest left represents the state as the "ultimate evil", preferring individual freedom. >...The y-axis, "Attitude toward planned social progress" (labeled rationalism), refers to the extent which a political philosophy is compatible with the idea that social problems can be solved by the use of reason. Ayn Rand and various Marxists would likely both score high on the rationalism scale (and be at close to opposite sides of the statism scale). (There might be many other multi-dimensional mappings that work better to map political ideology, but anything is likely better than the common practice of just mapping all ideology on a single line.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pournelle_chart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pournelle_chart