3 ms·
Instead of (or along with) controlling emissions, how about increasing removal? Methane is primarily removed from the atmosphere by reaction with reactive free
by pfdietz 6y ago
Instead of (or along with) controlling emissions, how about increasing removal?
Methane is primarily removed from the atmosphere by reaction with reactive free radicals, like hydroxyl.
We could increase the oxidizing power of the troposphere by releasing low concentrations of chlorine gas. Dilute Cl2 in strong sunlight is rapidly (in about 10 minutes) broken into chlorine radicals, which react very quickly with hydrocarbons, extracting a hydrogen atom to make hydrogen chloride.
The amount of chlorine that would be needed to be released to counter anthropogenic methane emissions would be roughly the amount currently being made by the global chloralkali industry.
I see some issues that would have to be addressed: releasing the chlorine in such a way that it starts dispersed enough that local toxicity isn't a problem, and such that very little makes it to the stratosphere; acidification from the HCl; oxidation of atmospheric Hg(0) to the much more toxic Hg(II)), but at first glance these don't seem to be showstoppers.
The interaction of Cl with other tropospheric chemistry might be an issue. For example, it might reduce production of OH, but doing the release in cooler areas might avoid most of that. And it might also reduce tropospheric ozone and perhaps even destroy nitrous oxide, another powerful persistent greenhouse gas.
Taken to a limit, one might also imagine stripping almost all methane from the troposphere, including natural inputs. This would cause a negative greenhouse forcing. Not enough to counteract increases in CO2, but every little bit helps.
- jeffbee 6y agoReinventing acid rain has a bit of a “modest proposal” vibe.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWe could also burn all our plastics, the toxicity would be manageable if done correctly. But you really need to work on the presentation when bringing these things up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 6y agoI'm envisioning the chlorine being released over remote ocean areas, so the acid rain would fall mainly at sea. The net acidification of the ocean would be zero, since making the chlorine also creates sodium hydroxide.