10 ms·
Plutonium is Forever
- amitraman1 16y agoFix problems early and often. I currently work at Japanese company in San Jose, but I don't see this type of behavior. The caveat is that I've only worked for a year here, so I may not be exposed yet. I'd really like to know if Japanese society looks down on people who have embarrassed themselves. The executives must have a reason to prevent embarrassment and risk lives.
- Duff 16y agoNow I'm starting to get worried. This has been up for 2 hours, and typically the "atomic trolls" would have at least 5-6 comments up about how all of this is nothing to worry about. So I guess this is truly bad.
- mchouza 16y agoI'm no "atomic troll" and radioactive contamination at Fukushima is potentially a significant problem. But the detected plutonium levels are almost insignificant compared to the detected Cs-137 contamination (whose half-life is 30 years, not months): http://www.tepco.co.jp/en/press/corp-com/release/betu11_e/images/110328e14.pdf http://www.tepco.co.jp/en/press/corp-com/release/betu11_e/im... (Pu) http://www.mext.go.jp/component/english/__icsFiles/afieldfile/2011/03/28/1304097_2810.pdf http://www.mext.go.jp/component/english/__icsFiles/afieldfil... (Cs-137) The activity of Cs-137 is orders of magnitude greater.
- Duff 16y agoSince day 1, I've been reading things like "Unless something catastrophic and unexpected happens, things are ok." The problem is, catastrophic and unexpected things keep happening. I find the whole thing really depressing, as I think long-term, nuclear power is the best source of energy. But how do you implement it properly? That I don't know.
- rhizome 16y agoThat probably has something to do with why you aren't a nuke plant designer.
- afterburner 16y agoThe plutonium leak confirms a meltdown and containment breach. That is what is significant.
- mchouza 16y agoAre you sure the presence of plutonium indicates a containment breach at a reactor? Remember that the fuel at the reactor 4 SFP is probably damaged and was sprayed with water.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI don't think you should down voted. Even though you're taking a "jocular" attitude, I think you've hit on something. I've been following the pro and anti nuke arguments here and I have found them quite useful. I might not agree with the pro-nuclear arguments but they've given me a better idea of what realistic and unrealistic fears around nukes are. For example, claims that truly minute amount of plutonium can automatically cause cancer seem distinctly over-done. See the wikipedia page. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium On the other hand, I recall the article which talked about how a reactor melt-down couldn't break containment structure because "This structure is designed, built and tested for one single purpose: To contain, indefinitely, a complete core meltdown". Well, given that an escaped-meltdown is currently considered plausible-if-not-likely, it seems there's a difference what something is designed to do and what a human-built artifact is capable of doing. http://mitnse.com/2011/03/13/modified-version-of-original-post/ http://mitnse.com/2011/03/13/modified-version-of-original-po... And point of this is we're at the point that ... some large of folks confidently said we could never get to... Yes, things quieter now but it does seem like there's more reason to worry... Nuclear radiation is "natural" in the sense that's around everywhere. Given that the world's a large place, the reactor won't pollute the entire that much. Now, making significant area around the plant uninhabitable for a long time? That's looking much more likely and that's not a cost that anyone is going to see as small. We have water giving off 1 Seivert(1,000 mSv)/hour at the plant and apparently this water is building up. Look at xkcd chart and see where that rates... http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/
- fady 16y agoWatch this, if you have not already. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5384001427276447319&hl=en# http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5384001427276447319...
- lutorm 16y agoSomething to be aware of: The fact that a radioactive material "is around forever" also implies that it is not very radioactive. You can't make a material that is both intensely radioactive and stays around forever, because it's the radioactivity itself that makes it go away.
- lisper 16y agoPlutonium is indeed not "intensely radioactive." The problem with Pu is that if you ingest it, it stays in your body so you can get enough radiation over time to cause cancer. So you're not going to get radiation sickness from Pu, it's just a very potent carcinogen.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI'm not particularly in favor of nuclear energy. But it seems the danger of plutonium in particular may be exaggerated. I've mostly read the wikipedia article. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium#Toxicity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium#Toxicity Several populations of people who have been exposed to plutonium dust (e.g. people living down-wind of Nevada test sites, Hiroshima survivors, nuclear facility workers, and "terminally ill" patients injected with Pu in 1945–46 to study Pu metabolism) have been carefully followed and analyzed. These studies generally do not show especially high plutonium toxicity or plutonium-induced cancer results.[89] "There were about 25 workers from Los Alamos National Laboratory who inhaled a considerable amount of plutonium dust during the 1940's; according to the hot-particle theory, each of them has a 99.5% chance of being dead from lung cancer by now, but there has not been a single lung cancer among them."[95][96] (etc, it's not something you'd want to ingest mind you). Any counter-references are welcome.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pasbesoin 16y agoIIRC, isn't it also, chemically, extremely toxic?
- iuytghyjuyh 16y agoNo the whole point of radioisoptopes is that they aren't forever. The mercury and cadmium that will be released by all the new coal stations that will replace the nukes is forever. But unlike plutonium which is heavy, insoluble, doesn't spread very far and is only a danger if you breath in the dust - the mercury compounds injected into the atmosphere will still be poisoning life on the planet when the sun goes out. And just for fun - the coal will also release lots of uranium (with a much longer half life) than all the reactors and bombs every built.
- wcoenen 16y agoThe plutonium was only found in trace amounts comparable to the amounts left behind by nearby nuclear weapons tests: http://mitnse.com/2011/03/30/news-updates/ http://mitnse.com/2011/03/30/news-updates/
- lukeschlather 16y agoIn disaster management, you need to go big early. Start getting several projects under way, so if any of them are needed they can jump into effect as soon as the need is clear. Hopefully the contamination is minor, but we already know there's likely to be some significant cesium contamination for a while now, and Japan should have half a dozen task forces starting with the assumption that technology X will deal with the contamination, and figuring out what they need to do to implement it.
- philthy 16y agoThe plant should have been dismantled, flooded, and buried within 24 hours of the emergency generators going down. They knew how bad it was/is, this all could have been prevented.
- iuytghyjuyh 16y agoGood plan Dr Evil - the reason you need the generators is that a shut-down reactor still generates typically a few percent of it's power output for a while. Covering this in concrete is rather like deciding to deal with a burning car by sealing it in a large cast iron box, painting "pipe-bomb" on the side and then putting that in an infant school.
- nickolai 16y agoYou cant dismantle a plant that still generates residual heat while a used fuel pool is on fire nearby. Its just too dangerous a place for humans to be. What should they have done? Sent Asimo?
- Tuna-Fish 16y agoJust note that robots don't work either, because particle radiation has a nasty way of flipping bits stored in memory. In the presence of a strong beta ray source, you can treat sram and dram as good sources of truly random data. :)
- varjag 16y agoThere are of course ways to shield from that (as illustrated by spacecraft and common military electronics), but nuclear station damage control robotics is perhaps too niche application to be implemented.
- joegaudet 16y agoAs I understand it, canadian CANDU reactors use a robotic system to perform online refueling. They also use heavy water as a moderator, and burn unrefined uranium / [can] spent fuel from other reactors pretty impressive machines I think.
- dy 16y agoSome interesting insights into the culture of Japan (and corporations both Japanese and American). Is there a way we could help that would be more amenable to the Japanese culture and way of handling things? Saving face is an important aspect of Asian cultures and if we are truly trying to help them on humanitarian grounds, we should try to become more effective rather than bemoan the fact that they have pride in their culture. It is an interesting test these days to think how would America respond to foreign help/intervention - I didn't follow what happened post-Katrina but it seems like we also downplayed foreign aid and focused on American rescue efforts.
- wisty 16y agoMy understanding of face is, you first have to understand that East Asians are often terrible verbal communicators. Americans say that "actions speak louder than words", but in Japan they mean it (even if they don't say it). I think that if you tell them that rescue teams (or nuclear scientists) are en-route, it's wouldn't be seen as piss-poor communication on your behalf, but a unconditional act of friendship. Asking them if they want help will most likely get a "no". I think you may also need to have already made connections with the right people.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yesbabyyes 16y agoThe US was very slow in asking for help. It officially asked for help one week after the disaster (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_response_to_Hurricane_Katrina http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_response_to_Hurri...). The US also waited over two months to accept any major international help with the Deepwater Horizon disaster (http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/ps/2010/06/143771.htm http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/ps/2010/06/143771.htm). I have a friend working in the Swedish Foreign Ministry, with disaster management. She tells me that another problem, except pride, is that many developed countries aren't well prepared to accept help. Apparently, lots of equipment sent to the US during these two crises was just waiting somewhere along the way, because there were no logistics in place to handle international help. It might be a similar situation with Japan.
- raleec 16y agoI plead ignorance. Why does a nuclear power station need an external power source? Obviously there is a good reason, but my sleep deprived brain can't fathom it.
- lutorm 16y agoBecause when it's shut down, it's not making power anymore... (It needs power even when operating, but that's for regulatory reasons to maintain redundancy, if I understand correctly.)
- InclinedPlane 16y agoWhen the reactor is shut down it's no longer generating power. Specifically, when the control rods have been "scram"ed there is no longer enough power being produced by the reactor to turn the turbines and their generators. However, the shutdown nuclear reactor still requires power to maintain proper cooling. The reactor core itself is at an incredibly high temperature and it continues to generate heat as the fission byproducts undergo radioactive decay. Generally only active cooling is sufficient to maintain a sufficient rate of cooling for used reactor fuel, that requires a continuous flow of coolant which requires a power source.
- chris_j 16y agoVery simply, when a nuclear reactor stops, the fission products in the fuel rods continue to decay and therefore continue to generate heat. A lot of heat. An external power source is needed to take that heat away from the fuel. Failing to keep the reactor cool can potentially be rather catastrophic. There is lots of information online. Why not start here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_safety#Failure_modes_of_nuclear_power_plants http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_safety#Failure_modes_of...
- caf 16y agoSpent fuel rods even continue to generate a nontrivial amount of heat months after they've been removed from the reactor - one of the problems at Fukushima is the spent fuel pools (which are located near the top of the reactor buildings, outside the secondary containment).
- ErrantX 16y agoA meta point: Cringely is one of those bloggers who, previously, I have slated here on HN - I find his insights into technology poor, badly thought out or both. To make a bad joke; he makes me cringe. So I've been (pleasantly) surprised to find his insights into Japan of actual interest and use. His tone is still a little breathy, and he tends to over-react to some items, but there is some real understanding of the culture/technology involved (I guess a fortunate meet up of having worked heavily in the nuclear industry and Japan). Which goes to show; never completely dismiss commentators, one day they might be useful reading.
- pkteison 16y agoIt actually worries me. When I know something about the topic, I find his writing awful and full of problems and obviously dumb. Then, in another area where I know nothing, it seems decent. Is this because it is actually similarly dumb in this other area also, and I just don't know enough to spot it?
- radu_floricica 16y agoIt's because he's a great writer. But this time he _has_ been surprisingly accurate...
- snippyhollow 16y agoDidn't you post this same commentary already? Anyway I agree with you, get my +1; Sry, I mean".".
- pkteison 16y agoNope, I post rarely. And I scanned the comments for something similar that I could just upvote instead. If it's here, I missed it.
- ErrantX 16y agoNo. He has errors in this area too. But within the text there are things of interest. A critical reader can pick these out. It's not perfect, but something of use in there.
- pasbesoin 16y agoThis disaster has caused me to revisit my concerns regarding nuclear energy. # One of the most challenging technologies ever developed, is under the control of politicians and bankers. A recipe in itself for technical disaster. # Public concerns, under this regime, end up being counter-productive. "No new nukes" means extending the life of the oldest, most vulnerable technology. # Human society has demonstrated no stability, sociologically, technologically, nor otherwise, approaching even vaguely the time frames required to safely utilize this technology. It is a huge bet, and burden, on future society -- on the entire planet, actually. # Nuclear resources on this planet are limited, and unique in their performance profile. There may come a time when we need them for better uses, e.g. early space travel. Forgoing e.g. renewable energy resources for the sake of this "quick fix" is, in the long term, squandering an irreplaceable resource. (Call me when someone finally gets fusion to work.)
- InclinedPlane 16y agoOn the other hand it's important to weigh the risks of nuclear power fairly, relative to other power sources. These reactor accidents are novel, noteworthy, and dramatic, but how serious are these accidents in proper context? Jumbo jet crashes are similarly dramatic and noteworthy, yet air travel remains one of the safest forms of transportation available, by a significant margin. Is the same bias for flashy and scary events happening with nuclear power? Fukushima and Chernobyl are notable, but so is the failure of Fujinuma Dam (also due to the Tohoku earthquake), and the failure of Banqiao dam, and the Texas City disaster. So far the record of the non-Soviet civilian nuclear power industry compares favorably with that of other industries and power sources, even including extrapolating some rather severe further evolutions of the Fukushima reactor disaster factored in.
- Tichy 16y ago"yet air travel remains one of the safest forms of transportation available" Doesn't that depend on how you measure it, like accidents per miles or accidents per hours? Even if it would be safest by miles, I don't think it would follow that the safest way to get to work every morning would be by plane. It only works because airplanes go long distances, and accidents most frequently happen during starting or landing. In short, the comparison is not even very useful. The question is also do we have to fly so much/do we need so much energy. If there were no airplanes, would people just travel the same distances by car? I doubt it.
- samgranger 16y agoAll nuclear plants should switch to Thorium to be honest. Much safer and there's so much available, it's crazy. Shame that it didn't get researched that much since it's not so good for making nukes.
- gyom 16y agoThe comment about people who wished that they had written books, in opposition to wishing to actually write one, resonates with me. "But it’s like those people I meet on airplanes who find out what I do for a living and tell me they would really like to write a book: what they mean is that they would like tohave written a book."