5 ms·
Interesting but weird. CEO's aren't failing software engineers, no more than software engineers are failing the cafeteria crew by using too much ketchup. If t
by Spooky23 6y ago
Interesting but weird.
CEO's aren't failing software engineers, no more than software engineers are failing the cafeteria crew by using too much ketchup.
If they are failing, they are failing the business. There's evidence of significant problems in business/management philosophy, as the consensus is that you need to optimize for now, and later is somebody else's problem. That has nothing to do with software engineers.
Technology people sometimes get this worldview that they are the sun, and the universe revolves around them. Hate to break the news, but no.
- acidbaseextract 6y agoThere's evidence of significant problems in business/management philosophy, as the consensus is that you need to optimize for now, and later is somebody else's problem. Dead on. I've seen boards of directors ask for fried ice: Management: We haven't put adequate time into building a sales training program. Board: Focus only on revenue this quarter. It's the only thing that matters! Then next quarter: Board: Why aren't your new sales guys producing?! They need to drive revenue! Management: Uh... you told us not to spend time on training.
- nicoburns 6y agoIndeed. Ultimately it's the (specific incarnation of the) shareholder model of capitalism that's at fault. Shareholders have ultimate control of companies, and their incentives are aligned all wrong (to the short term).
- pdonis 6y ago> Shareholders have ultimate control of companies, and their incentives are aligned all wrong (to the short term). This is actually not true of individual shareholders; most individual shareholders are investing for the long term, because most individual shareholders are investing for a long-term goal, like retirement. The problem is that most shares in most companies are no longer owned by individual shareholders, but mutual funds, and from the standpoint of an individual stock, a mutual fund does have short-term incentives, since if the stock's performance goes down the fund will just sell it and buy something else. The individual investors whose assets are held by the mutual fund, and who have a longer time horizon (most mutual fund accounts are retirement accounts), don't care about which individual stocks the fund holds or how often it trades them. So the longer time horizon of the actual individual investors is masked and only the short term incentives are visible to the individual companies.
- nicoburns 6y agoI agree with basically everything you've said. I'd add: the system is such that mutual funds are able to make greater profits from the system by playing things in this way. This means that over the long-term, capital accumulates in these funds, further skewing the proportion of investment that is driven through these vehicles.
- d0mine 6y agoIt is not obvious why trading more often (quarter-scale) would lead to greater profits long-term. Do any mutual funds ever beat the market? (on the "retirement" decades time scale)
- frenchy 6y agoUltimately, "long-sighted" shareholders should be able to outperform the short-sited ones, as long as they can retain control of the company. I wonder if there's any way to form a sort of shareholders union to maintain the control of an organization by shareholders who plain to keep stock for a long time.
- Jolter 6y agoThe sibling comments by pdonis and nicoburns, about mutual funds, explain pretty well why the short-term investors will increase over time.
- cbhl 6y agoThe two-class stock structure (ala Facebook and Google) is one experiment in this, but being able to establish such a structure depends on investors' appetite for it during IPO-time.
- tehjoker 6y agoSuch an incentive problem is easy to fix. Simply put the people who do the work at the company in charge. Their incentives are aligned to doing the work well, keeping the business stable, and developing a healthy culture.
- ll931110 6y agoNope, not that easy. Look at Scuderia Ferrari F1 team. In 2014 - 2018 the team principal was a business guy (Maurizio Arrivabene), whom was pushed out to make room for a technical guy (Mattia Binotto), whom led the technical work to bring Ferrari challenging the F1 title. And look at what happens now: they went backward from the 2nd best team to shared 5th-6th, burning a budget of $400M for a car that was a lot slower than their own version last year.
- philjohn 6y agoAnd yet when they put a technical guy in charge during the Schumacher years they flourished. I don't think the problem is either Arrivabene or Binotto - it was Marchionne and it's going to take a long time to fix.
- ll931110 6y agoRight, but Ross Brawn was hardly alone. He worked well with Jean Todt whom did the negotiation and business handling. For all the credits to Binotto, he's not a good negotiator.
- csours 6y ago> "Technology people sometimes get this worldview that they are the sun, and the universe revolves around them. Hate to break the news, but no." I've worked construction and at a manufacturing plant, and tech is a genuinely different business, with a different mindset than other businesses. Yes, they are failing the business, but they are failing the business in a new and interesting way, which is what this post is about. Tech is the engine that accelerates business. Acceleration used to be slow. If you don't have an engine that accelerates quickly now, and you don't have a HUGE moat, you won't survive.
- noahl 6y agoCan you give some examples of the mindset of construction and manufacturing businesses? It would be interesting to me, and I think to other people here too.
- csours 6y agoConstruction and manufacturing are very much about following defined instructions and processes and not updating or deviating from them without good reason. (Obviously there's a lot of Get Stuff Done too, where people ignore the above rules). Manufacturing Management is also all about metrics and counting productivity. Trying to apply similar metrics to tech leads to things like counting developers lines of code or defects. --- Edit: another aspect of manufacturing is limiting waste. In Toyota Production system this is called Muda - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muda_(Japanese_term) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muda_(Japanese_term) Waste of overproduction (largest waste) Waste of time on hand (waiting) Waste of transportation Waste of processing itself Waste of excess inventory Waste of movement Waste of making defective products Waste of underutilized workers You can look at the other goals of TPS and see how they may or may not apply to software engineering: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System I'm not saying these are bad ideas or don't apply to software engineering, but I am saying that they don't apply in the same way.
- ci5er 6y agoWell, for one, TPS is attempting to optimize the manufacturing of a fixed design. With software the design-made-code, where software is what in automotive would be considered the design process is 100% of the cost, the shipping of bits is 0%. In automotive, it is more like 5% design vs 95% building the car, goes the other way. When people apply manufacturing methodologies to design practices, it rarely works out. "Design" is messy, but people expect to be able to apply a manufacturing-like "LEAN" process to it. They are mixing goslings and goats.
- jimbokun 6y ago> If they are failing, they are failing the business. And the business includes the employees.