15 ms·
Ending at-will employment: a better remedy for cancel culture?
- devit 6y agoThe problem is that people are dependent on employment by a single party and finding a new employer is not automatic, which creates a huge non-diversified risk and creates abusive dynamics. The solution is to make it easy, normal and automatic to either find new jobs, be a contractor for many parties, or be unemployed, living on UBI/rent/self-production and not dependent on finding work. Monogamous relationships have the same problems and the same solutions (easy serial monogamy, non-monogamy, or being content being in a relationship with oneself).
- nickthemagicman 6y agoI think you're more correct than this article. I read the first few sentences of the article and thought .. if employment was not at will,job interviews would be next to impossible.
- theelous3 6y agoFunny, because it's essentially unique to the US, and everywhere else functions perfectly and interviews are the same.
- dgellow 6y agoThe US is the outlier here, every single European country I'm aware of has the level of protection suggested by the article. And job interviews aren't an issue.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoMaybe it's why most businesses come to the U.S. lol
- manicdee 6y agoMaybe it’s why so much business left the US for China and India.
- manicdee 6y agoWhy would job interviews be “impossible” when employment is not easily terminated?
- swiley 6y agoOr just find a decent person to be in a monogamous relationship that doesn’t abuse you by threatening to leave? If you feel the same way about your partner and your boss you need to find someone else.
- devit 6y agoThe implicit possibility of "leaving" is always present because doing something together in a way that is desirable for everyone requires an agreement/meeting of minds/consciousnesses, and without it interaction is not possible, and without any interaction there is effectively no relationship. Since people and organizations are always changing, there is no guarantee that there will be any such agreement and thus any relationship in the future (whether it is of an intimate or professional nature).
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoit IS easy to find jobs or be a contractor, that's what the gig economy is about, that's what McJobs are about. But those are shameful. They are a product of the free market, capitalist system with NO worker protections. This is why people end up working three jobs and still live under the poverty line, this is why people with degrees end up working at Starbucks. Workers do not feel valued because they have been reduced to statistics, and the pandemic has made it blatantly obvious; ten MILLION people have lost their jobs in a span of weeks. The country will go into economic and social decline, while the 1% laughs all the way to the bank because the stock markets are doing just fine.
- grasshopperpurp 6y agoThis is a real solution to a real (maybe exaggerated?) problem, but I'm curious to see how people in general would accept it, because the solution is associated with the Left, and the problem is associated with the Right. It's clever framing, and the benefits would reach far beyond the issue of cancel culture, but I doubt D's or R's as groups would seriously consider it. Hope I'm wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- speeder 6y agoI am a gamedev, and at least to us cancel culture became a really serious issue, it even caused a suicide of a famous indie dev after a Twitter mob made his business partners dump him and disavow him.
- ModernMech 6y agoYou call them a "Twitter mob", the game devs call them their customers and fans. If your customers and fans are telling you they'd rather not buy, use, and support your product if they know it's made in part by a known serial sexual assaulter of women, what would you do? The guy sounded seriously mentally unwell. Maybe if we had better support for mental illness and less stigma around the whole issue, the outcome would have been different. But I find it hard to put blame for his suicide on the people who didn't want to be associated with him after his despicable behavior became known.
- speeder 6y agoIf you read more about it, the people accusing him and calling for the game cancellation are NOT the clients of the gamedev. Since I am in that field more or less I know why the distancing from him was necessary, and had nothing to do with the buyers. The other thing is, the accusation (it was a single one in fact) was flimsy, the accusar have accused a lot of other people over the years and made some weird claims (like claiming she murdered a person in an alleyway) I said twitter mob because it was a twitter mob, literally, outsied twitter he was not that bashed, it was only on twitter that there was a huge storm of people bashing him, mostly people that weren't going to buy his game in first place.
- keiferski 6y agoEnding at-will employment is a legal solution to a cultural problem. Unlikely to work, but more importantly, I’d argue it’s unwise to rely on legal codes to solve non-legal problems. You end up ignoring other forms of education and culture (for example, from the family or local community) in favor of those which are explicitly written down. Instead I think we need to collectively, as a society, be less sensitive to perceived insults and disagreeable opinions. Words are not violence. Disagreement is a natural, healthy consequence of a diverse society.
- eganist 6y ago> Instead I think we need to collectively, as a society, be less sensitive to perceived insults and disagreeable opinions. Words are not violence. Disagreement is a natural, healthy consequence of a diverse society. Where do you draw the line between a disagreeable opinion v. something so abhorrent as to warrant cancelling someone's job, e.g. the use of racial slurs in spoken language? Not rhetorical. Genuinely wondering.
- keiferski 6y agoThe concept of civility and politeness once existed, but unfortunately has been almost entirely thrown away. This is easy to see if you look up old debates on YouTube; it was normal and expected for people of diametrically-opposite worldviews to engage and debate with each other in a polite, mostly-calm manner. Compare that to the shouting-match of today’s media landscape and you’ll see what we’ve lost.
- eganist 6y ago> The concept of civility and politeness once existed, but unfortunately has been almost entirely thrown away. This is easy to see if you look up old debates on YouTube; it was normal and expected for people of diametrically-opposite worldviews to engage and debate with each other in a polite, mostly-calm manner. Compare that to the shouting-match of today’s media landscape and you’ll see what we’ve lost. Nobody's cancelling people over political disagreements; they're cancelling people for dehumanizing groups of people, regardless of the tone of voice. People may have had orderly disagreements more often back in the 50s, sure (although the violence against Black as well as Native Americans in the 50s is casually and commonly forgotten - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_Un...). The difference is that in the 50s, people weren't fired for casually employing the n- word against Black people. This is the difference between today v. the past. What you describe still feels like a regression.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kakd 6y agoHere's another solution: don't use social media.
- swiley 6y agoThere are other parts of life besides employment. Universities have expelled or rejected students for publishing things they didn’t like (although this is rare and usually appropriate IMO.)
- badRNG 6y agoThis doesn't seem to cover "cancel culture" more generally, but narrows in on regular workers being terminated for their political beliefs. Is that what cancel culture is? I certainly don't think that's what most folks are referring to when they discuss "cancel culture." Is what's being mentioned here the common act of terminating employees who go on racist rants or act out violently and go viral? The piece preempts the objection of employers protecting employees from hateful conduct (without taking a stab at how exactly one should balance those interests,) which makes me think that these terminated employees are at least a portion of what the author is discussing. I share the author's skepticism for the utility "Right To Work" laws provide workers, but I don't understand how this relates to "cancel culture."
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoCancel culture is calling for firings or other loss of status due to expressing a political view or social view that does not conform to a large in-group with the ability to draw attention to an artifact (often taken out of context, with no due process) that undermines your reputation. The other word for cancelling someone is bullying them.
- manicdee 6y agoCancel culture is right-wing code for “facing the consequences of my actions.” No longer is being fired for being a Nazi facing the consequences of one’s actions, it’s the result of a targeted harassment campaign aka “cancel culture.” Bullying implies the aggressor has a power advantage over the victim.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoYou could just as easily say it is code for people on the left to impose their personal moral view as a Borg-like culture mandate where any dissent whatsoever will lead to having your life ruined through mob justice that considers no facts, context or due process.
- toxicFork 6y ago
- kingkawn 6y agoYou all discussing this like many of these cancelled folks didn’t do abhorrent stuff
- spoopyskelly 6y agoI think you mean "Y'all".
- bjornsing 6y agoI’m in a country with very strong labor rights (Sweden), but we still have serious issues with cancel culture. You may not get fired, but you can be reassigned to a different position or have your career ruined. Also your employer can make your life pretty miserable if they want to get rid of you but can’t fire you. You can also run into problems when applying for a new job. It’s not a great solution IMHO.
- dgellow 6y ago> Also your employer can make your life pretty miserable if they want to get rid of you but can’t fire you Isn’t that illegal?
- orwin 6y agoIt is. You can sue for this, i can think of multiple cases in France.
- bjornsing 6y agoDepends on what you mean by miserable and how sensitive you are I guess. An employer holds a lot of perfectly legal authority over you. It’s hard to say that anything that makes anyone miserable would be illegal.
- rjkennedy98 6y agoHas this author never heard of tenure? All tenure has done is push massive conformity where groups lobby and lobby to make sure only politically correct people get teaching positions.
- dgellow 6y agoThat’s off topic, the author isn’t suggesting tenure.
- spodek 6y agoI believe greater job security would improve many aspects of society, this argument implies that people with very high job security designed to promote risky speech would promote more viewpoint diversity. Yet tenured faculty seem to be part of cancel culture. Heterodox Academy https://heterodoxacademy.org https://heterodoxacademy.org, its members, and peers are trying to reverse the trend away from diverse views among academics, but they, or as a member I should say we, are a minority in academia and swimming against a strong current. That current undermines this article's argument.
- pjc50 6y agoStep 1 for talking about "cancel culture": define the terms of reference. This seems to have a sensible approach given that it refers to people who are not public figures being subject to misinterpreted incidents caused by outrage spreading on social media, resulting in them being fired by their employer. > While the government is not entitled to punish political dissent, in most parts of America it is perfectly legal for your boss to fire you if they happen to dislike the person you voted for in the last election. Indeed. At-will employment with zero notice periods and no process is ridiculous. That's at-whim employment. > But there are no equivalent federal protections to prevent employees from being disadvantaged because of their political views. This .. is much more fraught. And they know why: > Clearly, for example, no member of an ethnic minority should have to endure racist taunts at their place of work. But this could also be addressed through carefully worded legislation. Seattle already offers exemptions for political conduct that would cause “substantial and material disruption of the property rights of the provider of a place of public accommodation.” Employers also have an affirmative obligation to protect employees from racist harassment.
- afiori 6y ago> Step 1 for talking about "cancel culture": define the terms of reference. Part of the problem is that it is quite hard to do so, or rather it is very error prone. Something similar happens with the right to repair movement, it both cases it is very easy to mischaracterize both the problem and proposed solutions. For me cancel culture is how easily mobs are created online calling for action on inconsistent criteria. But it is quite easy to identify this phenomenon with the propensity of corporation to listen to these mobs.
- 082349872349872 6y agoIANAL (in any jurisdiction, let alone a common law one), but someone fired for upsetting twitter would seem to be a case of "termination at will", while someone fired for harassing their coworkers would seem to be a case of "termination for cause".
- AgentME 6y agoI find it funny the article just brushes aside the issue of whether vocal racists could be fired as if it's not the crux of the issue. (Yeah, there's some cases being labelled "cancel culture" that clearly weren't this, but those tend to not be the cases where the firing is defended by much of anyone. It's really frustrating how "cancel culture" repeatedly becomes a huge talking point when a vocal bigot gets fired, but everyone arguing against cancel culture goes through gymnastics to avoid talking about specific cases and makes arguments in the abstract, or makes arguments about the fringe cases that no one was really defending anyway, at least not for the same reasons that people defend outright influential bigots being fired. It's almost like if pro-life people constantly brought up regular murder cases in their crusade against abortion, and convinced themselves that the pro-choice crowd was supporting those murderers as part of their support of abortion. It's possible to abstract an issue to the point that the opposing sides are no longer in the same discussion any more.)
- lazyjones 6y agoThe bullying/mobbing aspect of Cancel Culture should explicitly be made illegal. I don't understand how people don't recognize it as what it is: idealogical "cleansing" in the same way the Nazis, Mao, Stalinists did it. Simple employer protection as suggested doesn't go far enough, the intent to harm one's career on ideological grounds must be punished.
- madengr 6y agoMaking it a criminal act would go against the 1st amendment, though people certainly open themselves up for civil suits for slander. Anyone who disagrees with BLM (Burn, Loot, Murder) is automatically labeled a racist.
- pjc50 6y ago... are you going to be able to define this at all? Or are you going to make it illegal to report e.g. someone saying the N-word to their employer?
- lazyjones 6y agoPreferably we'll make it illegal to damage someone's career and conspiring to do so. Just like it's illegal to damage someone's property. You have a problem with someone's speech? Let authorities handle it. If the N-word is illegal, tell the police, not the employer. Where's the problem?
- pjc50 6y agoIt's not illegal. That's the point. You're arguing that it should be illegal to ever complain about anyone. Writing "the waiter was rude" in a review shouldn't be a criminal offense.
- lazyjones 6y ago> It's not illegal. That's the point. Then you'll just have to suck it up instead of trying to seek mob justice by harassing employers. > You're arguing that it should be illegal to ever complain about anyone. You can complain but not with the intent to damage property or careers. You can also criticize people but not assault them.
- jonahrd 6y agoThis article (and a bunch of comments here) seem to be arguing against a straw man: that there are a bunch of "minority opinions" that are being threatened to be withdrawn from the sphere of discussion by cancel culture, and people who happen to share these opinions are at threat of losing their jobs over it. Cancelling is not simply about disagreeing with someone's opinions. It's about stopping the spread and normalisation of actual sexual violence [1], racial violence [2], or hate speech [3] I think it's hard for American engineers (I am one) to understand this, but there are actually times in which suppressing certain vile speech and acts is good for society. Our profession deals with absolutes most of the time, but we forget that there are actually nuances and shades of grey all around us. In Germany, for example, there are very strict restrictions around Nazi language and symbolism [4], and for good reason. Even in the US, there are towns in the south that have a long history of "cancelling" their local white supremacist chapters. Stores won't do business with certain people, they aren't welcomed as a part of the community [5]. This is to protect the town from damaging people and ideas, and is a perfectly healthy part of growing a community. These vile acts and words are not worth promoting as part of public personalities with high-profile jobs. In many cases, those cancelled don't even face legal consequences for their actions, but are simply removed from the public sphere. With the way we idolise fame, it's a good way to help make sure that kids aren't looking up to rapists and racists as idols in our society. And just to add another point about several cases which I know people will try to rebut my point with (Louis CK, Aziz Ansari, ...) These people were never unanimously cancelled like the others. There were debates even within leftist communities about how bad these acts were. And reality reflects that. Both Aziz and Louis have only had relatively minor hiatuses from the spotlight. Both are back on tour now (I went to see Aziz live last fall). This is not a "threat to our democracy" or a "threat to minority opinions". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvey_Weinstein_sexual_abuse_cases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvey_Weinstein_sexual_abuse_... [2] https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/mark-wahlberg-racist-hate-crimes-wikipedia-history-george-floyd-blm-protests-a9554191.html https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/... [3] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2020/07/11/tucker-carlson-writer-blake-neff-resigns-amid-allegations-racism/5419820002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2020/07/11/tuck... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Germany#Re-unified_Germany_(1990%E2%80%93present) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Germany#Re-unifi... [5] https://abcnews.go.com/US/life-inside-small-north-dakota-town-terrorized-white/story?id=33778885 https://abcnews.go.com/US/life-inside-small-north-dakota-tow...
- ergl 6y agoIndependently of the effect on online mobs, I think ending at-will employment is a no-brainer, especially when healthcare is tied to your employer. In any case, in many european countries we have something similar to Montana: at-will for a fixed period of time (typically 3-6 months), and after that you need a good reason to fire someone.
- 14 6y agoI was actually talking about this yesterday with my dad and we are Canadian so have “protections” and are not able to be fired without cause. However in reality what we discussed is that if they want to fire you they will do so. They will hyper focus on your performance and pick at anything. Small mistakes get written up and if they really want you gone will just lie about some things like claim always tired at work, slacking off, not on time whatever. This won’t happen at big public or government companies but definitely could happen at a smaller privately owned one. An example of this was once my dad cut off the tip off his finger at work. The doctor stitched him up and said you will need 6 weeks off work for this to heal. My dad laughed and said doc I am going to be back to work in less then an hour I can’t get time off work I will be fired. The doctor said “they can’t do that” to which my dad laughed again and explained that’s not how the real world works if they don’t like you they will fire you and just lie. So yes there are protections but they just change the number of steps how you get a person fired.
- throwawaymanbot 6y agoit wont change the fact that Nazis should be cancelled. Other wise, D-Day was just a mistake.. and we know it wasnt.
- kanox 6y agoThis is nonsense: making people harder to fire won't protect them from other forms of vigilante harassment.
- 0xfaded 6y agoEurope has this, and I'm a small employer. The question "what will it cost to let this person go if I need to?" goes through my head even before "is this person qualified?". Stronger worker protections lead to a divide between people who have jobs and those for who there are not enough jobs. Go look at southern Europe or South Africa. What workers need is the security of a viable alternative to their employer. Us techies can change jobs at will and have no need for this type of protection. The best general alternative I'm aware of is a publicly funded unemployment and retraining scheme such as A-kasse in Denmark. Even better would be UBI, but that would require more political will. Society needs private entrepreneurs and corporations, and should work to support them. In turn, society should take what it needs (better put, society should only allow so much to be privatised) as to ensure stability and quality of life for citizens. Business is hard. Don't make it harder in the name of transferring the responsibilities of society as a whole onto the companies.