4 ms·
We have a pretty solid roadmap to fusion power plants. ITER and DEMO don't have tremendous risks attached to them. But funding has been insufficient for fast pr
by adrianN 6y ago
We have a pretty solid roadmap to fusion power plants. ITER and DEMO don't have tremendous risks attached to them. But funding has been insufficient for fast progress. Funding is also insufficient for fast parallel exploration of non-tokamak designs.
The real question is whether fusion will ever be economically competitive with renewables+storage.
- lambdatronics 6y agoThere's still more risk than you'd be lead to believe. (1) There could always be unknown-unknowns related to stability or confinement with a self-heating plasma. ITER is still a science experiment. (2) The disruption problem hasn't be solved. There's an attitude of "it'll get solved because we need it to get solved." You hit the nail on the head with the economics issue, though.
- hannob 6y ago> We have a pretty solid roadmap to fusion power plants. ITER and DEMO don't have tremendous risks attached to them. The costs of ITER have grown to be more than 4x as much as what was planned (and it is still in early stages so that's probably not the end of the story). I would not call that "solid".
- adrianN 6y agoAlmost all large construction projects overshoot their costs. Things we built for the first time are even more likely to do so.
- chpill 6y ago> The real question is whether fusion will ever be economically competitive with renewables+storage. Could you elaborate on what storage you have in mind? The only effective way we have to store large amounts of electricity right now is [pumped-storage hydroelectricity](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricit...), which is interesting but also very sensitive to the geography.
- adrianN 6y agoI'm by no means an expert, but as far as I know a combination of batteries for fluctuations in the dozens-of-hours range and Power-to-{Methane,Hydrogen,Ammonia} for seasonal variations is what experts think feasible.
- cygx 6y agoThere are some technologies that might be improved to achieve the required efficiency (eg power-to-gas[1] or cryogenic storage). [1] https://www.kit.edu/kit/english/pi_2018_009_power-to-gas-with-high-efficiency.php https://www.kit.edu/kit/english/pi_2018_009_power-to-gas-wit...
- nicoburns 6y agoFusion also isn't possible right now of course.
- asplake 6y agoDo have we actually have a net positive energy generator yet?
- orwin 6y agoThe real question is: Will renewable (without storage) can replace 4% of our energy (not just electricity) production each year from 2019 to 2050? I think 2019 (or was it 2018?)was the first year with more renewable installed than coal plants, if you look at max charge. Good news at least.
- adrianN 6y ago2050 is probably too late (it probably is already too late!), but you're right of course. In any case fusion won't play a role before we decided our climatological fate.