7 ms·
The Fake Cisco
- jtbayly 6y ago“ we identified the full exploit chain that allowed one of the forged products to function: a previously undocumented vulnerability in a security component allowing for the devices Secure Boot restrictions to be bypassed.” I’m not following. Why wouldn’t a forged device function?
- Nextgrid 6y agoIt seems weird that they'd see this as a vulnerability. If it's a counterfeit device then the manufacturer controls the hardware and the secure boot process and there is no vulnerability there, the device is working as intended and is trusting the manufacturer of the counterfeit device. This doesn't mean the genuine device is vulnerable.
- parliament32 6y agoTechnically Secure Boot is the firmware verifying the bootloader -- not related to hardware. You can disable this on manufacturing but if the end user applies a Cisco update in the future that re-flashes the firmware, your changes will be gone.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoThe security platform is vulnerable in that minor modifications to the original device would permit loading of non-genuine boot images; the fact that the counterfeits used the same vulnerability to make it look like they were loading a genuine boot image on counterfeit hardware doesn't change that. The platform is vulnerable because this is a condition that the designers intended to engineer against - it's vulnerable in the sense that Sony's PS2 platform turned out to be vulnerable to circumvention with modchips.
- theamk 6y agoExactly the same technique can be used on the genuine device to bypass the secure boot and add a backdoor.
- SteveNuts 6y agoBecause presumably the customer tried to apply new Cisco firmware on counterfeit hardware it wasn't designed to run on.
- theamk 6y agoI have no information about Cisco in particular, but a very common tactic to ensure the device is genuine is with some sort of security chip. The security chip has a private key embedded in it in such a way that private key can be used to sign stuff, but cannot be extracted directly. The (publically downloadable) software contains matching public key, and on boot, verifies that the known public key matches the private key embedded in security chip. Even if counterfeiters can buy the same kind of security chip, they'd have no private key to program there. And this means counterfeit devices would be detected on boot. To prevent the software check from being disabled altogether, the vendor adds Secure Boot which is supposed to detect software tampering. But as this article shows, it can be bypassed as well.
- Too 6y agoFor verification, the chip only needs the public key. The SW signature is produced using the private key in factory.
- laurentdc 6y agoI'm wondering, what's to gain in all this? Does switching to slightly different parts (e.g. Micron vs Spansion flash module) make the final BOM so much cheaper that it's worth manufacturing a fake Ethernet switch? Just by taking a look at PCB pictures it looks like the counterfeiter managed to get their hands on some scrap or older revision boards and even went through more hoops (like that "modchip" design) to make them boot. Seems so overkill for a switch that goes for 250$ used - am I missing something?
- fuzzy2 6y agoThere’s certainly some R&D involved. However, the software is entirely pirated from what I understand, so that’s a lot of money you save.
- parliament32 6y agoYou're missing Cisco's margins from the gain. Cisco is taking an easy 50-70% markup above base hardware costs... That switch is $2.5k USD "new". Even if it costs you $300 for parts and a bunch of hours you're still making a ridiculous amount of money.
- SteveNuts 6y agoLike the article states, Cisco does sell at a major premium, so as long as you undercut that, you can make money.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoCisco basically sells software that only runs on their hardware. Slight exaggeration, but the reason old Cisco switches and routers are dirt cheap online is because it's usually a license violation to use them. The software on a Cisco device is licensed to the person or company who purchases it from Cisco or an authorized Cisco partner, and it's non-transferrable. (Also, you can't get software updates unless you have an active support contract or can identify a specific vulnerability and prove that you were the original purchaser of the unit in question in a support TAC.) Which means if you buy an aftermarket Cisco device, you're pirating the software on it unless you go through Cisco's pricey relicensing process... which mostly makes it cost you as much as buying a brand new device anyways. Obviously, homelab folks and test lab folks don't care too much, and Cisco doesn't mind them, but enterprises can't use used Cisco hardware. As such, counterfeit Cisco hardware makes sense: It's basically software piracy, but they have to provide hardware that'll trick it into running.
- dehrmann 6y ago> the verification of non-existence of "backdoor" functionality is also not trivial; requiring a considerable amount of technical investigative work With the recent news about removing Huawei from UK cell networks, it got me wondering...is there a feasible way to verify there aren't backdoors in infrastructure hardware like this other than manufacturers open sourcing (this doesn't mean open licensing) software, firmware, microcode, chip designs, board designs, and compilers so researchers can see what you did and verify production matches the source? How would you defend your IP with it being so out-in-the-open? Competitors seeing your code probably wouldn't be so much of a problem, and it wouldn't be so much of a problem for large players in first world countries, but China has a reputation for knockoffs, and they wouldn't hesitate producing counterfeit hardware for domestic use.
- roywiggins 6y agoYou don't need to make it open source, you just need to make it available to researchers. Microsoft shares some source code with the US government, among others. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/
- nix23 6y agoSome code....with the US government..that really says everything you need to know ;)
- dan-robertson 6y agoThey license source code to a bunch of parties. Another example would be PC OEMs.
- slezyr 6y agoYou still can have hardware backdoor in one of the ICs. You need to check them all. So, step one: produce your hardware on your own.
- EvanAnderson 6y ago
- mprovost 6y agoIt was my understanding that most "fakes" come out of the same factories as the originals. So Cisco orders 1000 switches, but the factory has a secret midnight shift that assembles another 500 that go out the back door. It would take pretty tight supply chain controls to make sure that this isn't happening. As a consumer you wouldn't really care since you're getting the same product.
- fluffything 6y agoMinus the support from Cisco, which you won't get once you tell them your serial number, which either isn't registered to you, or doesn't exist.
- fomine3 6y agoGive duplicated serial number.
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoCisco has spent about $1b and millions of man hours to figure out the seconds market. As the first bootleg hits market, Cisco releases its next gen piece. Always buy from authorized dealers.
- nix23 6y agoOr don't buy Cisco at all, but Ubiquiti and/or Juniper.
- watertom 6y agoIn order for Cisco to make products in China they need to share all of their IP with their Chinese partner, you need a Chinese partner company in order to do business in China. I've seen people say that you don't need a Chinese partner, I've done business in China, I needed a partner company, and I was only doing software. You need to share your IP with your Chinese Partner company. Your Chinese partner company is partially owned by the Chinese Government. When you share your IP with your Chinese partner company they share it with their owner, the Chinese Government. The Chinese Government then shares your IP with all the other Chinese companies that could benefit. The Chinese haven't needed to steal Commercial IP because western companies have been handing it over to them willingly. Making fakes I got to know people at my Chinese partner company, and a relative of one guy was in the business of helping western companies manufacture in China. I was lucky enough to get a tour of a few "high end brand" factories. The relative was quite open about the fact that they right down the road was another factory, which I also toured, that looked almost identical to the first, where they were making similar products, almost identical to the first. The only difference was the leather, and quality of the fabric, and the hardware, you can't make a knock-off handbag if you use the same quality materials. The relative did allude to the fact that the cost of the second factory was buried in the cost of the first. Never China.
- nabla9 6y ago> share all of their IP with their Chinese partner, This is BS.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- teh_klev 6y agoFair enough, but I think you need to provide a counterpoint explaining why.
- nabla9 6y agoChinese forced technology transfer is “market for technology” policy, not manufacture in China for market policy. Even if you manufacture within United States but want to sell to Chinese markets, the law applies. You can manufacture in China, without transferring IP (apart from what is needed to reveal for the ability to manufacture it). But if you want to sell in Chinese markets, you must transfer some technology. Tesla builds factory in China because wants to _sell_ in Chinese markets.
- driverdan 6y ago> Download the publication here. No thanks. It's 2020, there's no need to make this only a PDF.
- geocrasher 6y agoI once worked at a well known Cisco training company who had fake interface cards for 2600 series routers and knew it, but didn't care as long as they worked. It's not a new problem.
- GauntletWizard 6y agoI have a friend who worked for Cisco on co-op in college. He was working in support, and had access to a physical lab. One day he gets a call and is in the middle of debugging when he asks for a particular device's serial number. He copies it down, and looks at his desk. That device is sitting on his desk. Asks the customer to confirm, and even gets a snapshot of the physical label which matches what was said by firmware. Double Runs where the manufacturing partner builds your devices twice (or more) and sells the remaining ones on the gray market exist. You can have genuine cisco products and still not have genuine cisco products.
- alwaysanon 6y agoCisco has set things up to protect against this by basically killing the secondhand martket. I used to put up with Cisco's "you need to pay for ongoing support (SmartNet contracts) to get any updates/firmware - including for bug fixes and firmware upates for the modem etc." even for my home equipment when I had my CCNA and was still drinking the Kool-Aid trying to keep one foot in the Cisco ecosystem. And you couldn't buy used off eBay because they wouldn't sell you that SmartNet contract on it to get the updates/firmware. I had a Cisco 877W modem/router/WiFi for ages back when I had DSL and, not only was it outrageously overpriced (I think I paid like $1000 for it), I also needed to buy SmartNet for it to get the firmware for the modem part of it to work properly with my ISP even new out of the box (Annex N support if I remember correctly). TBH even if Ubiquiti's EdgeRouter stuff was the same price as Cisco I'd still buy it these days if it was my money instead because it is soo liberating to just be able to go to the website and download the firmware updates free forever. My EdgeRouter Lite was not only like 1/8th the cost of an equivilent Cisco but it is still getting free updates without even needing to register a login with them 5 years after I bought it and I haven't had a single problem with it in that time...
- ttul 6y agoYou are definitely not Cisco's target customer.
- W-Stool 6y agoMid-1990s I was running a boutique software company that made drivers and add-on tools for the graphics library that came with what at the time was the most popular PC desktop compiler tools (Pascal, C, C++). Got a frantic email from a customer one Friday night explaining he was on site (a steel mill) in China and ran across an obscure bug in my code. He was frantic - he was leaving China on Monday and needed a fix ASAP. So I worked through the weekend, fixed the code, sent him an update, all is well. Over the course of the following days he was most grateful and answered some of my questions about doing business in China - remember, this was like 1995-ish. The first thing he told me was that he fully expected the Chinese steel company to steel his code and pass it along to the government for the rest of the industy to use "If you know they are going to steal from you, why do business over there?" I asked. His reply: "I need this sale". 35 years later our industry is still having this conversation.