3 ms·
if you're implying that people in the developing world live without internet access, you'd be dead wrong I imply no such thing. You're projecting your own bia
by reaperducer 6y ago
if you're implying that people in the developing world live without internet access, you'd be dead wrong
I imply no such thing. You're projecting your own biases.
I'm merely stating a fact: That not everyone uses Netflix and YouTube, and to consider those life essentials is absurd.
- ajhurliman 6y agoI've used YouTube to learn a tremendous amount from programming to home improvement and beyond. I wouldn't consider it essential to my life, but I would certainly be worse off if I didn't have it.
- deeviant 6y agoI think saying something that is not essential to you cannot be essential to somebody else is absurd.
- Dylan16807 6y agoDid you forget the part where you said "several billion other people"? If you're not talking about the developing world, and just look at the rural and those who don't want a connection, that's not nearly enough people. So it's not wrong at all for people to assume you meant the developing world. And nobody said they were 'life essentials'.
- culturestate 6y agoTo be fair to the other person, China alone (in which neither Netflix nor YouTube are widely available) is almost 1.4 billion people. That could easily be part of their calculus, though I guess you could argue over the meaning of “several” in this context.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI see that as pedantry. We're talking about internet speeds, and the equivalent of youtube.
- culturestate 6y ago> We're talking about...the equivalent of youtube. Well, you certainly are, but I don't think the person who originally brought it up was.
- causality0 6y agoFirstly, I didn't call them life essentials; I invited the typically nerdy and internet-focused HN audience to imagine life without two services which comprise over 25% of global bandwidth usage in order to remind them of the massive accessibility gaps which still exist even in wealthy countries. Secondly, why does something have to be completely universal to be considered a life essential? Also, you tweet about streaming shows on FoodNetwork Go, so why do you act like that's any different from Netflix and Youtube?
- rootsudo 6y agoI would say in many developing world regions, Facebook is the internet.
- ajhurliman 6y agoThis. When I travelled to Vietnam I was shocked to find out access to Facebook was free (unlike the data plans, which seemed expensive to me and therefore likely out of reach for most of the folks there. It was really nice to be able to communicate with my travel buddies reliably, but this is definitely the tiered internet people are afraid of.