6 ms·
Imagine living without Netflix or Youtube. You mean, the way I and several billion other people do right now?
by reaperducer 6y ago
Imagine living without Netflix or Youtube.
You mean, the way I and several billion other people do right now?
- beamatronic 6y agoWell, those folks don’t really count. /s
- OhSoHumble 6y agoFor me, it's more about what kind of opportunities people miss out on when they're in an underserved area. For example, a lot of learning is being done remotely right now. How does a student on a satellite Internet connection participate in a streamed classroom? They can't so they just... miss out on schooling.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoImagine living without JS. 90% of the web would break. Right now a decent amount of web would break without images and even some without video. If you live on a yacht with cheapest sat connection (which is really obscene at $150 per month) you get a mere 2kbps. That's not even enough to load html. You only get to get email and weather via specialised software.
- chongli 6y agoBut then you live on a yacht. Why not pull into a port with known good wifi and download what you want in bulk? Use your sat connection for email to keep in touch. Sneakernet the big things (movies, TV, games). This is what life was like for me when I first got the internet back in the 90s. 14.4 dialup translated to around 1.5KB/sec. And I lived at home. I didn’t get to enjoy travelling the world in a yacht.
- kortilla 6y agoIn the 90s the internet was optimized for dialup. The web now is unusable on 56kbps
- chongli 6y agoHacker News is totally usable on dialup. The home page is only ~7KB. I'm sure there are plenty of other sites out there which are usable as well. RSS feeds should be fine as well. Podcasts can be downloaded in bulk when you pull into port. I didn't even mention the web in my original comment though, and that was on purpose. When you live on a yacht, you get to be out exploring the world and enjoying life. Why would you want to be cooped up in the cabin, scrolling Facebook or Twitter, or watching Netflix all day? If that's what you want, you should probably sell your yacht and get an apartment with broadband. There are plenty of people out there who still live without broadband. People on small islands, or in 3rd world countries. They may not be wealthy, but they have happy lives. With a yacht you can go visit some of them. Spend some time eating food and enjoying different cultures. The world is a big place.
- kortilla 6y agoA big portion of yacht life if you use it to see other countries is travel time. Having the Internet would be super nice. As of now you have to make do with books, movies.
- pixelface 6y agohaving internet closer to normal standards would allow more people to enjoy such a thing. I could afford to buy a sailboat now, but if I were to take it out to sea I would be unable to work the job that funds my existence. starlink (or others) bringing cheap and reasonably fast internet to the ocean would open up a world of exploration to people who can work remotely. supposing you are okay with the inherent compromises of being aboard a sailboat, something like starlink is really the only missing piece for being able to do it without being a successful lifestyle vlogger or very very wealthy.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoBecause you need to do work..? You won't be able push a git commit with those speeds. Let alone debug a SaaS app. Plus pulling to port is one the largest expenses when living aboard. Maybe 4G on the coast can be quite affordable, but depends on the country.
- pferde 6y agoI apologize for an off-topic comment, but I just had to chuckle at the term "living aboard". In similar contexts it is usually a typo of "living abroad", but here it is quite fitting. :)
- rootsudo 6y agoThat's exactly why. 1990s throughput in 2020. 30yr ago speed.
- adsjhdashkj 6y agoCuriously, what is your point here? I'm sure you understood the authors message, so i imagine your reply is cheeky in some manner. I imagine your reply pokes fun at the idea of those being important. However.. i just don't get that. I imagine several billion people can disagree about many "important" things. Does that dismiss the importance of those items? How many millions of people live below basic human means? Should those basic means be considered unnecessary? I imagine if i lived in the woods in the middle of no where i might scoff at the idea of electricity. That doesn't invalidate peoples dependence on electricity. Which, is what is what i take from your comment. Sure, Youtube vs Electricity, not quite a fair comparison - i get that. Nevertheless your comment strikes off the mark for me, but perhaps i don't get your intent.
- paulmd 6y agoif you're implying that people in the developing world live without internet access, you'd be dead wrong. Cell service is ubiquitous and data is cheap. Those people are probably better-connected than rural Americans (not suburban, but truly rural, the people living out in the sticks). American data connectivity is just that bad. It's worse than eastern europe. Worse than Asia. Worse than Africa.
- cptskippy 6y agoYou'd also be surprised by what's considered rural. Vermont is the most rural state and it's right next to Massachusetts which is one of the least rural.
- Ericson2314 6y agoVermont is the state with the most even distribution of people also?
- cptskippy 6y agoI have no idea. New Jersey's population is 99% urban, does that mean they all chose to live in an urban setting or that the State is so crammed full of people that there's no place to live in isolation? Looking at a map of New Jersey, it looks like if you managed to setup camp in the middle of a state park you might manage to be 5 miles from the nearest town.
- driverdan 6y agoHow is VT the most rural state? Both Wyoming and Alaska have a significantly lower population density.
- cptskippy 6y agoRural isn't a simple calculation of area divided by population. It's based on the density of the population. People are not evenly distributed over Alaska or Wyoming, the majority live in urban settings around cities with the majority of the land in those states being uninhabited. 60% or more of the population in Alaska and Wyoming live in an urban setting. In Texas it's over 80% and in California it's over 90%.
- solotronics 6y agoI was in a tiny surfing town in Costa Rica and they had gig fiber. You reach it via 3 hour car ride through the jungle and rivers on a single lane dirt road. Better internet than I have in the US.
- firmnoodle 6y agobut how were those pings to game servers in North America? I'm guessing they take too long no matter the bandwidth to the local exchange.
- xbmcuser 6y agoThe number of people without youtube access is decreasing every year. It is weird to me how many of you sneer of youtube use when I see it becoming more and more a platform for passing knowledge to people specially in the developing world that did not have access to it before. Yes because of easy access a lot of bullshit spreads too but youtube as a whole is an underrated access to knowledge for a lot of the third world.
- randomsearch 6y agoCurious that a HN commentator never uses YouTube. If you’re a dev, don’t you come across video tutorials that you have to watch? Do you have insufficient bandwidth?
- pferde 6y agoUnless it's for something physical (assembling an object) or otherwise visual (painting, 3D computer modelling, mapmaking), video tutorials are pretty bad for conveying information, due to low information density. For programming, it is especially wasteful, as compared to an article with code samples, or, if necessary for the particular topic, a screenshot or two.
- randomsearch 6y agoDon't disagree with you, but sometimes video tutorials are the _only_ source for such information (Some of Google's cloud services are guilty of this).
- thesmok 6y agoI'm a dev, and I only watch videos for entertainment. Any programming video tutorial could be a webpage, and I get professional information in text form exclusively.
- oneplane 6y agoI think the point wasn't people not having it available or not using it by choice, but people who are used to having it and now having to imagine not having it.