7 ms·
> Twitter is not on the masthead of The New York Times. But Twitter has become its ultimate editor. As the ethics and mores of that platform have become those o
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> Twitter is not on the masthead of The New York Times. But Twitter has become its ultimate editor. As the ethics and mores of that platform have become those of the paper, the paper itself has increasingly become a kind of performance space. Stories are chosen and told in a way to satisfy the narrowest of audiences, rather than to allow a curious public to read about the world and then draw their own conclusions. I was always taught that journalists were charged with writing the first rough draft of history. Now, history itself is one more ephemeral thing molded to fit the needs of a predetermined narrative.
In other words, the New York Times isn't leading. It's following the crowd on Twitter. And in abdicating the role of finding out the truth and saying it, the NYT gave up relevance. (We don't need them to echo Twitter. Twitter does that just fine. And we don't need them for performance theater, either - we've got Broadway.)
> There, some coworkers insist I need to be rooted out if this company is to be a truly “inclusive” one...
"You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means." - Inigo Montoya
Can't anyone there see past the current insanity and think? "To be inclusive, we have to get rid of her"? Don't they even hear the words coming out of their own mouths?
- TomSwirly 6y ago> Can't anyone there see past the current insanity and think? "I am the voice of reason!! All must think as I do! Can't you see?" She has set out to be combative and say things that a lot of people find repugnant. In particular, she has publicly mocked many of her coworkers, which isn't really a great way to make friends in the workplace. She presents no actual examples of misconduct against her either. Near as I can tell, she's leaving because she perceives people don't like her. Well, it's their right not to like her, as long as they obey the rules. The world won't miss her strident and dishonest voice.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway894345 6y agoShe paints a pretty clear picture of a hostile workplace, particularly in the context of all of the other drama going on at the Times. It's surprising that so many people who don't work at the Times are so confident that Bari is awful, lying, and generally deserving of harassment. Moreover, I don't understand how a good faith participant could read her letter and derive from it "All must think as I do!"--do you really not perceive a difference between a desire not to be harassed and a demand for ideological conformity? The general cancel culture debate on this forum has featured a shocking number of "harassment is criticism" arguments, and this seems like yet another. As a professional, you're allowed to think that her views are repugnant, and you're allowed to professionally criticize her views; however, harassment crosses the line. However, perhaps Bari is lying about the alleged harassment--I don't understand how you and others are so confident this is the case (yes, I'm aware that she accused professors of racism in college nearly 20 years ago, I don't see one minor offense in almost 20 years--and one which is frankly milder than those churned out at the Times on a daily basis--as indicative of a deeply flawed character, and attempts to use this to smear her only leave me with less respect for the critic). > Well, it's their right not to like her, as long as they obey the rules. Yeah, that's the whole point. Bari alleges harassment that the Times wouldn't put up with if the target was a progressive and not a Jewish liberal. According to her, her colleagues weren't 'obeying the rules'.
- PunchTornado 6y agoshe presents clear examples of bullying that should get people fired, like her name followed by an axe on slack. I hope she has a screenshot. But I doubt that she invented that example. NYT should investigate and punish the bully. Otherwise, I am dissapointed when I open the paper and barely see any conservative columns while half the country still is conservative. I want to see how and why people think that way in this country, read their opinions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 6y ago> Can't anyone there see past the current insanity and think? The bitter lesson of the 20th century is that the answer to this question is "no". Read Eric Hoffer's "The True Believer": in this book, Hoffer looks into how mass movements compel masses of people to forego independent judgement for a sense of belonging and righteousness. He wrote the book 70 years ago, but it's as relevant as ever.
- benlumen 6y agoIt's the same story across journalism and I wrote about this exact phenomenon in the article I submitted yesterday - journalism had to please the social media, news aggregator and SEO algorithms to stay alive. They write and say what's popular to their audience and suitable for the tech platforms - not what's right.
- koheripbal 6y ago...and this is why it is so vulnerable to foreign influence. An army of bots (human or programmed) can sway Twitter incredibly easily and drive outrage, which now seems will shape the US media narrative. It's like they are intentionally steering the ship towards the rocks. I wonder who might be helping this effort... hmm... /s
- thu2111 6y agoThere are no armies of Twitter bots swaying mass public opinion. That's another nonsensical conspiracy theory of the sort of the New York Times has gone all-in on to try and explain how Trump won without having to engage with his policies or arguments. This article looks at just one news story+research paper alleging a Russian Twitter bot army swaying politics, but in the UK rather than the USA: https://blog.plan99.net/did-russian-bots-impact-brexit-ad66f08c014a https://blog.plan99.net/did-russian-bots-impact-brexit-ad66f... tl;dr - the paper is filled with fraud but was breathlessly reported by the (London) Times, and it convinced the Prime Minister despite being false.
- thedudeabides5 6y agoWell, an army of bots is not free. So you have a new medium which allows power in the real world to become manifested in the digital world. Illiberal forces have been using capital to mess with the institutions of open and free discourse since before the printing press, Twitter is just yet another new market where power and money matter.
- gguevaraa 6y agoCan you explain? Genuinely can't connect the dots here (don't keep up with politics too much).
- enraged_camel 6y ago>> Can't anyone there see past the current insanity and think? "To be inclusive, we have to get rid of her"? Don't they even hear the words coming out of their own mouths? This confuses a lot of people, but the explanation is simple: it is the Paradox of Tolerance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance Namely, not tolerating someone, who themselves espouse intolerant views and give voice to intolerant extremists, is not itself intolerance. And Bari Weiss is the perfect example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amscanne 6y agoUnfortunately, there does seem to be a massive lack of consistency on which intolerance to tolerate. Since we’re talking about Bari Weiss, Israel serves as a good example. While the left is typically critical of Israel and their “racist”, “apartheid” state, they generally have very little to say about their overtly anti-Semitic neighbor states. I’m sure there’s lots of criticism to go round here, but whoever is talking, the conversation rarely feels objective to me.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI would also suggest we look at how different groups define 'intolerance' in practice. In my opinion, a certain group has contorted the term beyond recognition to the effect that it exactly describes their outgroup. One could be forgiven for thinking this contortion is deliberate, particularly in light of this group's propensity toward semantic games.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoIsrael's a tricky case, to be honest. It's worth noting that the more virulent people on both sides I've encountered tend to be either citizens or residents of America, which I find odd. I do generally agree with your point, but it's a general facet of humans, rather than something specific to an issue.
- 6y ago
- pingpongchef 6y agoIt's easy to use words and not have to square them with existing ideas when you also feel free to redefine them to suit an agenda. That's what we see commonly now.
- bloopernova 6y agoThe newspapers don't know what to do with themselves. In my opinion, they're following because we're in a period of flux or change in our society, driven by the massive impact of the internet and the barriers to publication being practically zero now. Because there are so many voices shouting out right now, it's impossible to find the ones who are speaking "the truth" when that was something defined by a handful of editors in newspapers and TV networks 30 years ago. Into this cacophony we also have bad actors, people, organizations, countries who intentionally set out to poison the truth and watch it die. I don't know if that problem is solvable in any way with the Internet in its current form. Parallel with that misinformation and disinformation, society (speaking mostly about the USA) is struggling with enormous capital and power inequality. Groups of people of every political leaning know that "something is wrong" but so many are being told to blame this or that group of others. We've been shown that those with the command of immense resources can exploit and control our laws and government to the point of being beyond the law. We've been shown that we may not be able to do anything about that without significant revolution. So in this period of massive change, we're told we're powerless. Yes, the New York Times is following, because we all are.
- randomsearch 6y agoI think that’s too pessimistic. If it weren’t for Twitter and Facebook then yes the environment for journalism would be challenging, but we wouldn’t be in the dire straits for debate that we’ve found ourselves at. Notable that this crisis did not happen pre-Facebook.
- tqi 6y ago"Pre-Facebook" was also notably a time when internet penetration in the US was only 63% (15% globally) and smartphones were practically non existent.
- thu2111 6y agoI don't think that's really true. The pathological problems affecting most of the news media aren't universal, even within that industry, and certainly not if you broaden the definition of journalism slightly to include independent writers on blogs. I remember some years ago, a big debate in the media was whether blogging represented some new revolution in journalism. Eventually the mainstream became obsessed with Twitter and sort of forgot about blogging, but it never went away. By far the best journalism and analysis available during COVID-19 has been from this wider group of journalists. Some of them are both independent bloggers and writers in regular newspapers simultaneously. But many are just ordinary citizens who happen to work in mathematically or statistically rigorous fields, and found themselves with time on their hands to do analysis. I think one reason they can do a better job is they're less conflicted than journalists are. They can write some calm, level headed articles pitched to any audience they like and don't have to worry about how many clicks they get, or whether subscriptions will grow or shrink as a consequence. A huge problem professional journalists have is that they earn more money when telling people there's a crisis, because news consumption goes way up. So anything scary is blasted out at full volume, and when it's discovered to have been a false alarm there's crickets. There's no incentive at all to tell people, OK, maybe this isn't as bad as it seemed. I think this is also why so many journalists end up attacking vague, unnamed "deniers" and "sceptics". It's common for such people to write detailed blog posts drilling in to a specific scientific issue far deeper than newspaper or CNN talking heads can, and often concluding, actually, the issue is overhyped. They can reach that conclusion because their livelihoods don't depend on finding the opposite. But any time anyone reads this alt-journalism and concludes, hey, maybe I'm being manipulated into believing things that sell a lot of news, they drop out and stop consuming as much of the "pro" output. It makes sceptical bloggers the arch enemies of mainstream news. Into this cacophony we also have bad actors, people, organizations, countries who intentionally set out to poison the truth and watch it die .... We've been shown that those with the command of immense resources can exploit and control our laws and government to the point of being beyond the law. I don't think we have. I think that's another narrative newspapers like to feed people to keep them watching or reading.
- cm2187 6y agoThat's the part I disagree with. The NYT isn't following Twitter. Twitter is the modern way to express at the 3rd person ("twitter mob says") what is really meant at the 1st person ("our editor thinks"). You will never see some angry tweet from Trump supporters quoted or even mentioned. In the old days you would interview enough random people in the street until you found one that said the narrative you wanted to push and that the one you showed on TV / quoted in the article. Another technique still widely in use today is when you want to attack person x, you go collect some quotes from known opponents to criticize x, and quote a list of criticism as if somehow these were the only relevant reactions. None of that is subtle or done subtly.
- throw_m239339 6y ago> The NYT isn't following Twitter. What is said here is that journalists are trying to appealing to their Twitter follower instead of doing their job. It's peer pressure, but on Twitter, not in the editing room of the NYT.
- TeaDrunk 6y agoShe would probably be fine if she wasn't publicly bad mouthing her co workers on company time, during an all-hands meeting. She's injecting a politically convenient narrative to protect herself from the consequences of her own actions.
- PunchTornado 6y agowhat were her actions that demands bullying in the workplace?