4 ms·
Question from someone who has no dog in this fight. If your model is right would it be in you best interest to short their stock or do you believe that the mark
by Spivak 6y ago
Question from someone who has no dog in this fight. If your model is right would it be in you best interest to short their stock or do you believe that the market can "remain irrational" forever?
- jonny_eh 6y agoShorting can cause you to go broke in a time frame much faster than "forever".
- mhuffman 6y agoYes it would, but I am very, very nervous that the actions of the government and the capricious actions of retail investors would go against me, so I have no stomach to do it. As an example, image that you shorted bitcoin half-way up its rise ... you would be broke! Possibly less than broke! On the other hand, you would have eventually been right, just the timing on a bubble stock (or possible meme stock, in this case) can make that sort of thing dangerous.
- marvin 6y agoThere is also the significant risk that you are wrong. I haven't seen this mentioned; maybe it's obvious and you've considered that aspect too. A short bet means unlimited downside, and if you arrive at 1/5 of the current market cap, there seems like a significant risk the market has seen something you haven't. Tesla was at $200 one year ago. Guaranteed to be an irrational bubble?
- secabeen 6y agoYou can bet against TSLA with put options, but given its volatility, they are very expensive.
- mhuffman 6y ago>There is also the significant risk that you are wrong. I haven't seen this mentioned; maybe it's obvious and you've considered that aspect too. Yes! This is maybe the most likely outcome! However, to date I have not heard a good reason why Tesla should be valued higher the the other leading car companies combined. There is no moat for them. Anything they are doing, all of the other car companies can easily retool to do ... they don't because not everyone wants an electric car.
- marvin 6y agoI can give it a shot. Maybe you've heard some of these before, it's just a list of claims. Tl;dr is there's a probability Tesla will become a tech behemoth with a tech moat that's Google/Apple/Amazon oligopoly-level unassailable. Not just in cars, but also in autonomous driving and maybe energy distribution. Dunno if I'd invest at the current valuation, but it's not obviously insane. Established automakers are structurally incapable of competing, due to innovator's dilemma. BEVs will eventually get cheaper than fossil vehicles due to decreasing drivetrain cost (li-ion battery++), but this tech will not be a commodity for at least a decade after this point - requires billions of R&D. Means established automakers are under an existential threat they aren't facing. Their best shot at competing BEV models with inferior price/performance make this abundantly clear. Production capacity of enough & the right batteries & motors requires both capital investment and R&D that won't materialize out of thin air just due to demand; existing manufacturers won't be able to source these at competitive price and performance. Development must be in-house at scale. Takes years, no one else is trying. Tens of billions investment. Capital is dirt cheap, so established industry's coffers does not protect them. Tesla now has 15 years lead on another startup trying the same. Superior battery tech at such scale also has unquenchable demand from solar energy industry. As long as no one can compete on price & performance, margins are huge. Will eventually be a commodity, but that's two decades away. Might also be network effects at play here. Must also consider fully-loaded cost of established industry -- meaning enterprise values that consider their debts & pension obligations, not just market cap. Autonomous driving is an industry-defining strategic advantage. Autonomous driving means Uber is obsolete. It's like landing used rockets on a barge. Established industry won't be able to just lease this capability for less than their entire profit margin. Harder than making cars. Waymo approach makes centimeter-level manually curated maps of their entire area of operation; not scalable & not compatible with inclement weather. Computer vision necessary. No one but Tesla has a real-world fleet gathering data at scale any time soon. Might be a strategically critical advantage. But even if multiple autonomous approaches succeed at the same time, established automakers are over a barrel here. Software is eating the world, established automakers don't have the culture for it. UX & software integration increasingly important both for a good driving experience & economics of maintaining a vehicle fleet. Recently saw VW slide bragging about how many lines of code they're making. It shows. Structurally incapable of competing there. Coronavirus pandemic accelerates Tesla's advantage, as the entire established industry gets its profit margins crushed far into unprofitable territory. Lots of misc. points: Dealer network doesn't like EVs due to lower maintenance costs, so established automakers have a sales problem there. Charging network availability for long trips is an obvious UX problem that no one else is handling at scale. It's hard when you don't have batteries to even out load spikes; competitors without cheap multi-kWh batteries in their charging stations will get screwed by energy distributors and be prohibitively expensive. This is also abundantly clear from existing industry dynamics. Etc.
- ajzinsbwbs 6y agoIf you shorted BTC halfway to its peak, and managed not to get closed out, you’d be breaking even right now.
- nmfisher 6y agoWhat kind of bankroll would you have needed to avoid getting closed out from halfway to peak? Genuinely interested.
- imtringued 6y agoTesla's stock price was irrational years ago. Shorting would have certainly lost you money.