13 ms·
It’s crazy that Intel owned the best ARM design 15-20 years ago (Xscale) yet sold it a year before the iPhone shipped. Intel actually turned Apple away when the
by pavlov 6y ago
It’s crazy that Intel owned the best ARM design 15-20 years ago (Xscale) yet sold it a year before the iPhone shipped. Intel actually turned Apple away when they wanted an ARM SoC.
Both Intel and Microsoft made some kind of categorical error in 1995-2005 in assuming that their dominance was tied to a particular programming interface. Intel clung to the x86 instruction set while Microsoft operated on a “Windows everywhere” mindset, first pushing Win32 and then .Net.
Wintel seems finally dead, and good riddance.
- ETHisso2017 6y agoApparently the financial planning model Intel used to justify turning down Apple in that case had a math error (dividing by 1+X instead of multiplying by 1+X) that actually swung the analysis in the wrong direction. Given the resulting impact (Intel being far behind in the smartphone market), it might qualify as the costliest Excel error of all time.
- vlovich123 6y agoSource? That would be a fascinating read.
- bigdict 6y agoDo you have a source for that?
- patmorgan23 6y ago.... That's like literally trillion dollar mistake
- lumost 6y agogiven Apple's near monopsomy power in the mobile market Intel may never have been able to produce high margin chips in that market.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoYeah, it never would have been that profitable to be an ARM vendor for Apple. I couldn't even remember who made the chips in the iPhone 1, I had to look up that it was Samsung. If Intel managed to convince Apple to go x86, and they had low power chips competitive with ARM at the time, then that would be a different story. You could even argue that it was a happy accident; Intel providing a high performance ARM core may have forced mobile competitors to react, producing high performance ARM chips of their own, and sped up the erosion of the x86 monopoly we're finally witnessing today by several years.
- GeekyBear 6y agoIntel refusing Apple's business and not moving into handheld mobile devices put a whole lot of R&D money into the pockets of Intel's rivals. I doubt TSMC would have been able to afford to catch up to Intel without their current high volume business.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoIf they stayed with Intel for a very long time, I agree. But I don't think that would have happened. Apple pursued custom silicon very aggressively from the start, with the acquisition of PA Semi less than a year after the launch, and the first custom chip coming in the iPad in 2010. Although with an Intel chip they wouldn't have needed to do this for performance reasons, Intel's fat gross margins would have been equally compelling. If Intel was willing to design the chips and take TSMC sized margins on them, I guess they could have kept the iPhone business for years, but that isn't in their DNA. I can't see Intel ARM iPhone chips as anything other than a shortly lived oddity.
- GeekyBear 6y agoMy assumption is that if Intel had gotten serious about mobile devices, Apple would not have been their only customer. By sending all that business to TSMC and Samsung, they were financing their rival's R&D.
- colonwqbang 6y agoSource?
- Ericson2314 6y agoSounds to me like a joke based on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_FDIV_bug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_FDIV_bug
- pankajdoharey 6y agoI think it was mostly the greed of Business Development people at Intel who thought why build a chip with such low margins, what they didn't see was that mobile revolution was about to take place and billions upon billions of ARM chips would be shipped in mobile devices around the world.
- KMag 6y agoSee also the rumoured refusal of DEC to drop margins on the Alpha when Apple was shopping around for a replacement for the m68k.
- GeekyBear 6y agoOtellini mentioned in one interview that Intel's projected cost was wrong, but I've never seen anyone at Intel go into specifics as to how it was wrong. >At the end of the day, there was a chip that they were interested in that they wanted to pay a certain price for and not a nickel more and that price was below our forecasted cost. I couldn't see it. It wasn't one of these things you can make up on volume. And in hindsight, the forecasted cost was wrong and the volume was 100x what anyone thought." https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/05/paul-otellinis-intel-can-the-company-that-built-the-future-survive-it https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/05/paul-...
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> Intel clung to the x86 instruction set Itanium launched in 2001 (per Wikipedia); if anything, I'd say they overestimated how readily they could ditch x86. Of course, it might be that replacing x86 was a good idea and it was just that Itanium sucked (I'd accept that possibility, given the whole "needs a smarter compiler than exists" thing). But I do agree with the general feeling that Intel and MS both overestimated how solid/entrenched they were.
- himinlomax 6y agoItanium didn't fail because people wanted x86, it failed first and foremost because it sucked badly.
- corty 6y agoMaybe correct, there was even a 32bit x86 mode, it was just ridiculously slow.
- TheCondor 6y agoI believe that was software that did the emulation. I actually had a dual Merced system that I ran linux on for a while. It didn’t suck so much as it was “different.“ Intel should have known this, but you buy processors because they are faster or cheaper. These days the third rail is energy but it’s basically the same, if you pay more you want a lot more and “Different” costs. Itaniums where a whisker faster than their ia32 offerings at the time, they cost a lot more though, and they were different. Beyond that, it was like a geek designed the specs with out a market story, risc chips were coveted by x86 dorks because they had 32 registers to the x86’s 5 or 6, well ia64 had 128... If you’re just doing simple stack frame compiler work without full program optimization, how many functions need 32 registers? Let alone 128? everyone could see that you wanted to simplify things in order to put silicon where it mattered for longer term performance, mid to late 90s reordering conditionals for branch prediction was sort of hot in compiler dork and low level circles, well Merced fixed that by adding a lot of complex logic to take both branches and retire the wrong one. IBM, HP and Sun needed different reliability and serviceability features on their high end systems too, from the big enterprise metal perspective they were toy parts for PCs, but they cost more, didn’t run your existing software and weren’t 2x faster or anything like that. They didn’t take a holistic market view as they made it. Rather than work with ibm, sun and hp on those high end issues, they just went back to the lab and told them when the first parts would be out. Not really sure what goes on inside intel, they have a lot of brilliant people. I suspect that they cannibalize themselves because nothing will ever be as successful as the x86 was when they owned every aspect of the part and package and things are decided to be a failure before they ship. With ia64 nobody asked why. Xeon phi, they gpu and machine learning stuff reflects that too.
- Ericson2314 6y ago> Both Intel and Microsoft made some kind of categorical error in 1995-2005 in assuming that their dominance was tied to a particular programming interface. Actually their judgement there was correct. There dominance absolutely was tied to monopoly power, via "particular interfaces". Working on alternatives would have undermined the monopoly. They error was thinking the monopoly wouldn't have eventually been undermined anyways. They upped the risk for more reward, and got bit. This incidentally is another reason why monopolization is bad: even when it doesn't last indefinitely, it makes for shitty companies that refuse or cannot adapt, and will be stubbornly stick to their ways until more sudden failure. Stagnation and then a jolt is less growth, and irrespective of growth bad for society. No government should want this.
- dannyw 6y agoIntel deserves it 100%. No tears shed.
- S_A_P 6y agoI think this signifies that the management has failed the company. Taking safe bets instead of taking risks. There is no reason Intel shouldn’t have embraced both architectures. They had to know x86 is never going to be a low power device. Apple wasn’t the only company that saw mobile coming.
- gsnedders 6y agoBut notably, Intel still have an ARM architecture license and thus can still design their own ARM cores if they so desire.
- cdmckay 6y agoI believe they lost their license when they sold XScale to Marvell.
- gsnedders 6y agoFrom https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2012/10/31/amd-jumps-into-the-arm-server-business/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2012/10/31/amd-jumps-i...: > In fact, Intel pointed out to me in the wake of the article’s publication that it possesses an ARM architectural license, the highest level of relationship with the British intellectual property (IP) licensing firm, which Intel retained when it sold its communications product line to Marvell in 2006.
- blackrock 6y agoIs there a need for .Net anymore? Even Microsoft proved that they could build a featurific program without .Net, in VSCode. It’s an electron and JavaScript application. And, they were able to make it run everywhere.
- tigershark 6y agoYes, it’s obviously needed, especially with the introduction of .Net Core. And seriously, comparing C# or F# with JavaScript is ridiculous. Typescript on the other hand is quite good, but its compiled JavaScript performance is much worse than .Net.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoYou can make everything in anything, and it doesn't prove anything!