4 ms·
> Is significantly slower than a $400 iPhone SE in single core, and only slightly faster in Multi-core. Geekbench is super misleading because they do things li
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Is significantly slower than a $400 iPhone SE in single core, and only slightly faster in Multi-core.
Geekbench is super misleading because they do things like include benchmarks which are hardware-accelerated on the CPU in the iPhone but not the Intel ones. The weak little low power CPU in the Air is also hardly the fastest single thread Intel processor, much less multi-core, so I don't know what they're planning to do on the desktop.
> Now imagine next years MacBook Airs running the next generation A14 processors on a 5 nm process instead of 7 nm
But then it's competing with not only whatever Intel manages to come up with in the meantime but also AMD processors on the same 5nm process.
> with far faster integrated GPUs than Intels
But, again, faster than AMD's? Or what Intel will have at the time, given that they're now developing discrete GPUs and will have that in house to improve their iGPUs?
> And using processors that are at least $100 cheaper.
Which Apple has no incentive to give to you instead of putting in their own pocket, especially if what they offer is actually better.
> how much longer their battery life will be
"Much more thermal head room than a phone" and "much longer battery life" don't go together, they're a trade off against one another.
The amount of hype around this is getting to a level that people are going to be very disappointed if it doesn't live up to it.
I'm waiting for some independent third party benchmarks before getting so excited. And not the first ones which were given early access in exchange for favorable skewing.
- valuearb 6y agoIf Geekbench was so misleading, why does the Intel version of Geekbench run so fast on two year old iPad chips? And “Hardware acceleration” isn’t misleading if it’s accelerating commonly done tasks. Intel is years behind on process and GPUs. Apple is not just getting faster CPU and GPU performance in lower power envelopes, it’s getting those processors at less than half the price. Apple could have switched to AMD to get better faster processors cheaper, but nowhere near half as cheap, and nowhere near as power efficient. And Apple has no reason to use this to increase margins, when they can use it to dramatically increase volume and market penetration, which will increase margins on its own. Fir example, the iPhone SE is faster than any Android phone ever made, yet Apple still priced it at $399. They wouldn’t risk cannabalizing their higher end phones unless SE margins were comparable to higher end phones. Which again shows you how cheap their Ax CPUs are. And iPhones and iPads have all day batteries a fraction of the size of laptop batteries, and without the space, mass, or fans of laptops. The A14 will be able to run in MacBooks at a higher power level while still remaining cool, providing for more cores and faster processor speeds. It will still be using significantly less power than the latest generation Intel laptop CPUs. Also because the SOC will integrate a performance GPU, T2 functionality, Neural Engine, etc all in one package.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> If Geekbench was so misleading, why does the Intel version of Geekbench run so fast on two year old iPad chips? If Geekbench wasn't so misleading, why do they do worse on other benchmarks? https://benchmarks.ul.com/compare/best-smartphones https://benchmarks.ul.com/compare/best-smartphones https://www.gsmarena.com/benchmark-test.php3 https://www.gsmarena.com/benchmark-test.php3 > And “Hardware acceleration” isn’t misleading if it’s accelerating commonly done tasks. Hardware acceleration is misleading because it can give you huge speedups in a single measurement which significantly affect the overall score when it's averaged in, and because it's easy for the competitor to hardware accelerate the same thing if it really matters without losing any of their advantage anywhere else. > Apple could have switched to AMD to get better faster processors cheaper, but nowhere near half as cheap, and nowhere near as power efficient. With the amount they have to spend on R&D in order to do this, it's hard to argue "cheap" and the AMD processors have TDPs down to 10W, so it's also hard to argue efficiency. > And Apple has no reason to use this to increase margins, when they can use it to dramatically increase volume and market penetration, which will increase margins on its own. Lowering prices never increases margins. It may increase volumes, which reduces amortized costs, but there is a grisly trade off there. If you're selling a phone for $400 which has a $200 unit cost, lowering the price to $300 is probably not going to double your sales but it is going to half your margins. > Fir example, the iPhone SE is faster than any Android phone ever made, yet Apple still priced it at $399. Meanwhile this is the cheapest iPhone and it still costs significantly more than the average Android phone, which is around $250. > And iPhones and iPads have all day batteries a fraction of the size of laptop batteries, and without the space, mass, or fans of laptops. Predominantly because they have smaller screens, and screens consume more battery than a mostly-idle CPU. > The A14 will be able to run in MacBooks at a higher power level while still remaining cool, providing for more cores and faster processor speeds. You still seem to be confused by this. "A higher power level" and "remaining cool" are the opposite of one another. If they use the power budget to have as many cores as e.g. a Ryzen 7 4700U then it will probably use about as much power on the same process node. They're not magic, they're just making different design trade offs for phones than AMD and Intel make for laptops.
- philistine 6y ago
- GeekyBear 6y ago>Geekbench is super misleading SPEC is the industry standard for comparing performance across platforms. >Last year I’ve noted that the A12 was margins off the best desktop CPU cores. This year, the A13 has essentially matched best that AMD and Intel have to offer – in SPECint2006 at least. In SPECfp2006 the A13 is still roughly 15% behind. https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro-and-max-review/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro...
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoSo now we've gone from being "significantly faster" to being as fast on integer, slower on floating point and slower on threaded applications. Which seems a lot more plausible, but now where's the argument that this is going to be a marked improvement rather than a lateral shift with a huge transition cost?
- GeekyBear 6y agoThis is a comparison of an iPhone part to a laptop/desktop part. The iPhone part doesn't have anywhere near the same power budget, nor does it have active cooling. The SPEC benchmarks take a couple of hours to run, so cooling is definitely a factor. Apple's laptop part will be the first time they have a level playing field on both. The Apple laptop part is also going to have a process node advantage. It will be built on TSMC's 5nm node while AMD is sticking with an enhanced version of TSMC's 7nm node and Intel will still be on 10nm. The word was that Apple's entry level laptop part will have 8 next generation Big cores and 4 next generation little cores, which is quite aggressive for an entry level laptop part. The A13, in comparison, only has two big cores. We'll see how Apple's laptop chip fares when it ships.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The iPhone part doesn't have anywhere near the same power budget, nor does it have active cooling. This is much less of an issue for single thread performance because a single thread isn't going to exhaust an 8-core CPU's full power budget anyway, or if it does it's by boosting to very high (i.e. less power efficient) clocks which only give a few extra percent more performance. The main thing the extra power budget gives you these days is the ability to have more cores, which x64 processors already have. > It will be built on TSMC's 5nm node while AMD is sticking with an enhanced version of TSMC's 7nm node and Intel will still be on 10nm. AMD already has 5nm processors on their roadmap. Apple might release theirs first, but having a modest advantage for a few months until your competitors release their next design isn't especially groundbreaking. It's basically the expected state of affairs when companies compete with each other and neither has a clear advantage -- the one released most recently is a bit faster and then soon the competitor has a release and it goes back the other way.
- mappu 6y ago> Geekbench is super misleading because they do things like include benchmarks which are hardware-accelerated on the CPU in the iPhone but not the Intel ones. This was a problem in Geekbench 4 (especially so on Android) and was resolved in Geekbench 5. You can believe the numbers to be roughly accurate within the sampling variation.
- imtringued 6y ago>"Much more thermal head room than a phone" and "much longer battery life" don't go together, they're a trade off against one another. Every time I see someone write about the benefits of "Apple Silicon" they always mix this up. What they do is say that the ARM chip is much more power efficient and therefore it will have a longer battery life and can be cooled passively. In the next sentence they say you can sacrifice battery life for higher performance and add more powerful cooling. Yet for some reason people seem to think that you can have both at once without any of the downsides. ARM based SoCs are usually power efficient because of asymmetric cores and low frequencies. AMD created a symmetric 8 core chip running at 10W simply by cranking the frequency down to 1.8GHz. If they add asymmetric cores they could lower power consumption even further.