5 ms·
Minimum wage doesn’t need to be raised. Any time that you place an artificial price floor or ceiling on supply in a competitive market you distort it. Private i
by scarface74 6y ago
Minimum wage doesn’t need to be raised. Any time that you place an artificial price floor or ceiling on supply in a competitive market you distort it. Private industry should not be in the job of providing a social safety net.
That’s government’s job. We should have universal healthcare, expand the earned income tax credit and make it easier to distribute throughout the year and increase taxes to fund it.
But I noticed that you called out people making $500K instead of $200K. Why? Maybe because $200K is not considered “rich” by most people on HN?
Why not raise taxes on everyone that has a household income of $130K since that puts you above 80 percentile of households income or $184K since that puts you in the 90 percentile?
“Tax the rich” often translates to “tax people who make more than I do.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoNo minimum wage? In this world of accelerating automation and dropping real wages? That argument is right up there with 'let them starve'. Are Socialists correct, than our society depends upon a slave class to function? Because so often a suggestion that people earn a humane wage, is met with blanket resistance and dire predictions that the economy will be ruined.
- scarface74 6y agoWhat do you think is going to happen if you increase minimum wage to the point where it makes automation a more affordable alternative? Also, you did see the part about expanding the earned income tax credit and providing universal healthcare didn’t you? I’m not saying let anyone starve. I’m saying that’s society’s responsibility through taxation and redistribution.
- newhotelowner 6y ago> What do you think is going to happen if you increase minimum wage to the point where it makes automation a more affordable alternative? This is going to happen anyway. Walmart is planning to go cashierless. Taco bell has kiosk for ordering. New PlayStation manufacturing plant is fully automated. Universal Basic Income is the solution. I don't even think 20% of the population is doing even a simple task.
- opo 6y ago>> What do you think is going to happen if you increase minimum wage to the point where it makes automation a more affordable alternative? >This is going to happen anyway. Changes that occur more slowly are easier for everyone to adapt too. Why do you think we should force this trend to accelerate?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBecause nobody can live on a minimum wage set 30 years ago and never adjusted for inflation.
- scarface74 6y agoThey aren’t suppose to - thus my proposing an increase use of the EITC.
- opo 6y agoNo, the last time the minimum wage was increased was 2009, not 30 years ago. The original federal minimum wage was .25 in 1938. If it had only kept up with inflation it would only be about $4.55 today. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/minimum-wage/history/chart https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/minimum-wage/history/chart If you are actually concerned about helping the poor, then as user scarface74 points out, increasing EITC is a better approach than a minimum wage increase.
- Nasrudith 6y agoPersonally I see accelerating automation as a pro and not a con for raising minimum wage - it encourages investment into R&D, boosts productivity, and would make a damn good export. Granted it would be a bit of a pain and call for other measures for remediation after the spread of automation but the goal of a job is productivity in the first place - we don't dig ditched with spoons.
- dlp211 6y agoProgress has been happening in our economy for over 200 years now. There is always the next boogeyman that is going to ruin the economy, yet it never materializes. And if automation does in fact cause harm the way you suggest it will, and it might, then we do what we must as a society to alleviate that issue. Trying to hold back the inevitable is a bad economic strategy.
- scarface74 6y agoThere is a huge difference. While progress before meant that workers could be more productive, the amount of workers you needed increased as the amount of goods that were produced increased. It took more people to produce more value. It doesn’t take any additional people if MS sells one copy of Windows or Office than if they sell a million. The same is true for Facebook, and AWS (of course the retail side needs more but that’s even becoming more automated). As I said below, Apple and Amazon are the only two of the five big tech companies that have products or service that requires a lot of people as they scale and Apple’s “employees” are contract workers overseas. That also means that the modern “factory workers” - software engineers, product managers, etc. produce an outsized value, are a larger multiplier and get paid a lot more.
- chii 6y agoand why couldn't more people be "modern factory workers"? Why can't there be a million times more software and services available? It doesn't have to be just MS and Apple and Amazon providing jobs.
- scarface74 6y agoThe entire concept of software and is that the marginal cost is 0. If it gets to the point where there is a one to one ratio between worker and service, it becomes yet another commoditized race to the bottom. There is also nothing stopping many of the three billion people in India and China from producing these services and now all of the protectionist policies in the world won’t protect “good American jobs”. But as far as Amazon and Apple, that’s just the point. Apple’s “manufacturing employees” are overseas and Amazon is trying to automate more so that they don’t need as many FCs.
- newhotelowner 6y ago> Private industry should not be in the job of providing a social safety net. Someone should. Instead of taxing industry, and transferring wealth to poor, its best way to increase wages for the bottom 20%. They will spend that and increase economic activities. > I noticed that you called out people making $500K instead of $200K. “Tax the rich” often translates to “tax people who make more than I do. I didn't call anyone, nor I said: "tax people who make more than I do". I used to work in silicon valley. Now a business owner. I said it's pathetic that people (like me) who make $500k/year pay less than $75k in federal taxes.
- scarface74 6y agoSomeone should. Instead of taxing industry, and transferring wealth to poor, Increasing the minimum wage and paying someone more than their market value is a tax. Increasing minimum wage is a one size fits all solution. “A livable wage” doesn’t take into account the different needs of my teenager living at home flipping burgers for some pocket change and that same burger flipper standing beside him who is a single mom of three. The EITC does take that into account.
- N1H1L 6y agoAnd letting society pick up the tab through food stamps is a tax on the rest of us too.
- scarface74 6y agoAs would be any combination of increased pricing if minimum wage was increased, increased unemployment because automation becomes much more attractive, decreased earnings affecting stock prices which affect public pensions which would cause an increase in taxes to make up the shortfall. If we increased the EITC, and raised taxes to fund it, we wouldn’t have to worry about food stamps.
- dlp211 6y agoSource that a higher minimum wage leads to those undesired outcomes. My best reading of research into the effects of minimum wage increases is that it doesn't lead to higher unemployment, but may result in reduced hours, which is a different kind of raise.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoIt's not a competitive market -- employers have more market power than employees. That's why in practice minimum wage increases don't have much of an effect on unemployment. Here's a recent paper on the topic (that cites many of the previous papers that have similar findings): http://digamoo.free.fr/azar719.pdf http://digamoo.free.fr/azar719.pdf
- scarface74 6y agoIf that were the case that employees don’t have any choice, you wouldn’t hear stories about farmers who couldn’t get American day laborers at any price - even upwards of $20/hour or more. There are some jobs that Americans won’t do at any price.