4 ms·
It's like asking for ten years' experience with Swift. The job descriptions (especially in hidebound companies like Big Blue) tend to have mandated experience
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
It's like asking for ten years' experience with Swift.
The job descriptions (especially in hidebound companies like Big Blue) tend to have mandated experience levels.
HR folks aren't engineers, so they should not be expected to know.
However, this should be highly embarrassing to the hiring manager, who I'm sure, was handed the ad text for approval, and probably rubberstamped it without thinking.
- christophilus 6y agoIt would be trivial for someone to Google it, then make a canonical list for the entire HR department. You’re talking about maybe 30 minutes of work to prevent your company from looking like corporate clowns.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoOr, you could hand the ad copy to the hiring manager, and assume they would take responsibility (part of the job description for "manager" -I know. I was one for a long time) for approving the copy.
- BossingAround 6y agoYou're underestimating the amount of friction at most companies. For all your recruiters to use your measly google sheet, it has to be encoded somewhere on your intranet, a memo has to be sent by the director (whom you have to persuade that this is the correct thing to do) that there is this sheet, and you then become the point person to approve all the job ads because "you took initiative in the area."
- consp 6y ago> HR folks aren't engineers, so they should not be expected to know. If you job description is to find someone to fill a position you should know what that position is. This is middle management "I don't need to know exactly what I'm managing" levels of cow manure.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoWe engineers tend to apply a "raised baseline" to non-engineers. We seem to assume that everyone "just knows" the "basics" of tech; especially if we are in a tech environment. The vast number of employees at corporations over a certain size are non-tech, with specialties in Marketing, Sales, Finance, Administration, Support, Manufacturing, etc. I see that a lot of tech companies have recruiters that are quite close to their teams. I know that Facebook and Apple do this, as they have contacted me in the past. Those types of recruiters wouldn't make the same mistake, but they are not common in many corporations.
- xxs 6y ago>HR folks aren't engineers, so they should not be expected to know. Yeah, so make the engineers produce the requirements for the particular jobs. HR should not be in the business of defining technical requirements for jobs.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI worked for a hidebound company like that. I would submit a request, which would then get modified by HR. That was why it was so important for me to review the job descriptions. It was often an iterative process.
- scarface74 6y agoOn the employee’s side, I always tell external recruiters that they do not have permission to modify my resume in any way outside of replacing my contact information with their heading. I’ve seen too many horribly mangled resumes from the hiring side and I spend time at least once per quarter keeping my resume up to date.
- oefrha 6y ago> It's like asking for ten years' experience with Swift. Translated: we want to hire Chris Lattner (who started developing Swift in July 2010, so has exactly ten years of experience with Swift).
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoGood point. There is one (1) person on Earth with that kind of experience.