4 ms·
> This is only possible with fiat currencies because you can't print gold. on the other hand, if the world was still on a gold standard, then the gov't couldn'
by chii 6y ago
> This is only possible with fiat currencies because you can't print gold.
on the other hand, if the world was still on a gold standard, then the gov't couldn't have printed stimulus packages, and it would lead to more poverty and misery in the short to medium term (even if that would've been better in the long term, which is a debatable outcome).
Fiat is only as good as the gov't handling it. It can indeed be abused more than gold can. But it's also more powerful than gold. A tool, in the hands of the capable, can do wonders. So the debate around monetary policy should be how to achieve the best results.
- roenxi 6y ago> if the world was still on a gold standard, then the gov't couldn't have printed stimulus packages Sure they could, borrowing is still allowed. And the government can just declare "property rights are lovely but we're suspending them in this emergency, here are some IOU for after we raise taxes to cover this". Which would have a largely equivalent effect in real terms to money printing but much easier to understand. > Fiat is only as good as the gov't handling it. The government is consistently made up of financial incompetents. Most governments struggle to deliver a balanced budget when they try. All the people who know how to make good financial decisions are in private industry making them.
- AshamedCaptain 6y ago> And the government can just declare "property rights are lovely but we're suspending them in this emergency, here are some IOU for after we raise taxes to cover this". Which would have a largely equivalent effect in real terms to money In no way this has the same effect. The uber wealthy have an even easier time of hiding their property in this case, and the mid wealthy react much worse (violently) to private property forfeits than to the usage of printing press (which as you say most of us don't even understand). > Most governments struggle to deliver a balanced budget when they try. All the people who know how to make good financial decisions are in private industry making them. This is very old bullshit, and thinking like this leads to parties trying to be cool by hiring people from industry with the consequent terrible results ( this trope is so old its even parodied on yes minister).
- roenxi 6y ago> The uber wealthy have an even easier time of hiding their property in this case, and the mid wealthy react much worse (violently) to private property forfeits than to the usage of printing press The uber-wealthy are the major beneficiaries of money printing, they are going to come out of the stimulus ahead. And people probably wouldn't be violent, it would be about as difficult as collecting taxes - ie, not that bad. > This is very old bullshit, and thinking like this leads to parties trying to be cool by hiring people from industry with the consequent terrible results ( this trope is so old its even parodied on yes minister). Being unable to identify that the person who they hired is, effectively, scamming them is a clear sign that they are financially incompetent. It isn't hard for someone with a good grasp of accounting to figure out if someone else is bettering or worsening a financial position. Particularly for government work which is neither novel nor commercially risky.
- Klinky 6y agoPrivate industry is certainly not immune from incompetence or accounting scandals. Wirecard just happened, and history has many other examples. Corruption exists in both private and public sectors.
- eadmund 6y ago> Private industry is certainly not immune from incompetence or accounting scandals. Wirecard just happened, and history has many other examples. Corruption exists in both private and public sectors. This is getting way off-topic, but there is one key advantage to private industry: there are typically competitors. A bad CEO can ruin one firm, but a bad politician can ruin a country. Also typically, a bad CEO may not use armed men to force his employees to do things; a bad politician may.
- Klinky 6y agoLehman Brothers didn't ruin the country? At least there were competitors that could take up the slack, oh wait they all made the same mistakes and basically ruined the entire world. A CEO can outsource labor and materials procurement to countries where armed men are coercing employees/slaves. It's quite likely a company is outsourcing human rights violations. They can also put out marketing campaigns during pandemics worshipping "heroes" while putting their employees in harms way for no extra pay. There has also been a rash of hostile environments involving sexual harassment and racist behavior. Coercion doesn't always require a gun in your face.
- pjc50 6y ago> "property rights are lovely but we're suspending them in this emergency, here are some IOU for after we raise taxes to cover this" People are still upset about the Roosevelt gold confiscation, it's a huge scar across American monetary politics.
- WalterBright 6y agoAlso remember the gold bonds. Before FDR, you could buy government gold bonds or government money bonds. The gold bonds were payable in gold, and with that extra reliability paid a lower interest rate. From 1914 to 1929, the government inflated the money so the dollar was worth about half what the official exchange rate was. (I'm pretty sure this was the main cause of the bank runs as people suddenly rushed to convert their dollars to gold.) FDR decided to pay the gold bond holders in dollars instead of gold, effectively confiscating nearly half of the money.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoThe bank runs were caused by banks failing. There was a run on gold, but it was the Bank of France trying to build up its gold reserves.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe runs stopped when FDR suspended exchanging dollars for gold. Once people realized that the official exchange rate was a 50% off on gold sale, there was no stopping the rush to exchange.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoFDR also announced a bank holiday and by the time the banks opened deposit insurance.
- a1369209993 6y agoAnd they'd be even more upset about the everyone-since-Roosevelt money confiscation, if it hadn't been obscured by being done through currency debasement.
- Ericson2314 6y ago> "Property rights are lovely but we're suspending them in this emergency, here are some IOU for after we raise taxes to cover this" Gold standard + IOU is not the gold standard. I suppose they could be separate currency denominations, but then it is far from guaranteed the IOUs can be converted to goldbacks. > Most governments struggle to deliver a balanced budget when they try. Actually, suggesting that many rich governments should balance their budgets is financial incompetency. > All the people who know how to make good financial decisions are in private industry making them. OK....