21 ms·
Union, yes! This is an old complaint going back to the early days of the Industrial Revolution at least. The US once had an 8-hour day and a 40-hour week. Now
by Animats 6y ago
Union, yes!
This is an old complaint going back to the early days of the Industrial Revolution at least. The US once had an 8-hour day and a 40-hour week. Now those are only memories.
Unions. The people who brought you the weekend.
- aliante 6y agoAnd the people who brought in stuff like seniority rights and #notmyjob. Unions create an anemic culture.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe increased work hours are among the professional class. It consists of professionals competing, not exploitation from the top. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/02/religion-workism-making-americans-miserable/583441/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/02/religion-w...
- morelisp 6y agoI don't know how you can believe this unless you somehow also believe professionals are at the top.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn the case of professionals, the extra work is generally optional for extra rewards. You can have a career as a software engineer with a 40 hour week if you want. It just won't be at Amazon. You can have a career as a lawyer, just not at big law. Professionals get to opt in and get commensurate rewards. The factory workers didn't get anything extra for their extra efforts.
- ben_w 6y agoWhen I was working in a factory (summer holiday job during my A-levels), onetime was paid at time-and-a-half. Now I’m a software dev working in an office, the base pay is much better, but there is no overtime.
- war1025 6y agoOne of my neighbors mentioned that they were offering triple time to work the 4th of July at the factory he works at. He didn't want to work, and thankfully there were enough people interested in the offer that he could have the day off.
- gjulianm 6y ago> generally optional for extra rewards Rewards like burnout, lower quality of life, worsening relationships with friends and family...? The problem is actually a vicious circle. People work more to be valued more, which causes others to work also more so that they can compete. The company benefits from this and takes it as the new normal: deadlines shorten, workload increases, and it stops being optional to become "optional", as in "you can opt out of more work, but get ready to find another job soon". Now you have a whole group of workers burning themselves out for marginally more money and status, while the company they work for makes more money. And no, it doesn't just happen at Amazon. This happens to software engineers everywhere. Of course, it's not by far the same situation as factory workers, but there's a serious problem with the work culture in software, specially in the US.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> Rewards like burnout, lower quality of life, worsening relationships with friends and family...? But what are those things worth to you? As they have different values to everyone. A friend of mine is currently working on his software project at work (and this is for a massive non tech company, so it is not as if it is a startup). It is 6AM on a Sunday and that is what he is doing. And he is doing it out of boredom as he is in many ways the stereotypical software guy. Another good friend is in Seattle. He logged in to work at midnight today while chatting with me. Why? He has nothing else to do. I spend 100+ hours at my computer a week and have since high school. Spending a greater percentage of that time coding for work does not meaningfully impact my quality of life other than taking away from commenting on forums or my hobby of solving innovation challenges. Whether I am unemployed or facing a major deadline, I am going to be online anyway. I get why long hours would be terrible for people with families requiring attention or girlfriends or those who like hiking, but a lot of software engineers (like me or the aforementioned friends) have none of those, making more work very cheap for us.
- gjulianm 6y ago> And he is doing it out of boredom as he is in many ways the stereotypical software guy. I don't know any software person who works at 6AM on a Sunday. >He logged in to work at midnight today while chatting with me. Why? He has nothing else to do. Does he have time to find anything else to do? > Spending a greater percentage of that time coding for work does not meaningfully impact my quality of life other than taking away from commenting on forums or my hobby of solving innovation challenges. Being online and working is not the same at all. Maybe for you, for not most people. > but a lot of software engineers (like me or the aforementioned friends) have none of those Several things: 1. Not having anything other than your job is bad. Full stop. Maybe a handful of persons can work in that situation, but having such a messed up work-life balance is bad for your health, there are plenty of studies on this. 2. Have you asked why this happens? Maybe it's not just people who like that, but people who have no other options due to companies "forcing" those hours. 3. Is this beneficial? How much productivity can someone get out of the last 2 hours of a 12-hour work day? How much is that extra work worth? 4. Are you and your friends ready to take on those workloads for your whole life? Because it's hard to get out of that dynamic. 5. Burnout is a serious issue. Burnout can lead to depression, can lead to losing your job, to having serious health problems... It's not a joke. It's a serious risk.
- xvector 6y ago> You can have a career as a software engineer with a 40 hour week if you want. It just won't be at Amazon. Even if you are a software engineer you can make top-tier, simply insane amounts of money at most big companies with a sub-40 hour workweek. It is simply a matter of finding the right team and having a good manager. The former is something you can affect and the latter can be luck. But you can definitely make some of the best compensation in CS and have cushy working hours if you play your cards right.
- ianhorn 6y ago> Professionals get to opt in and get commensurate rewards. More like professionals are forced in, but get commensurate rewards. Employment isn't flexible enough for people to really choose extra work for extra rewards. The "typical" (average, median, raced-to-the-bottom, whatever) amount people are willing to work and the typical amount they're willing to work for dictates what jobs are even out there. When you need roughly replaceable workers, you give them all roughly the same deal, so professionals aren't just competing on wages vs skill, but on the whole necessarily-mostly-homogeneous package. I'm happy to have these extra benefits well above a living wage, but I'd take a fraction of my comp for a fraction of my hours in a heartbeat, but we're in a world where a FAANG wage/hour means basically FAANG hours.
- CamperBob2 6y agoComparing today's IT workplace to the conditions that inspired Marx and the labor movement seems a tad naïve, to put it politely.
- sdenton4 6y agoAnd yet, it seems to be working out fine for the actors and writers guilds... Unions are about dealing with the power asymmetry between a large organization and individual workers, which has nothing to do with the kind of work being done.
- luckylion 6y agoIt works out well for the IT people as well, they're making much more than the average employee. Most could cut back on the hours by taking a hit in the salary. People value getting more money though.
- TheNorthman 6y agoMarx wasn't inspired by poor worker conditions: he wasn't an idealist and his writings aren't normative. To claim that Marx isn't relevant for worker conditions today is to either misunderstand him or misrepresent him. The contradictions arising from social conflict can't be solved by air condition because they are bound to our mode of production.
- amoe_ 6y ago[At risk of veering OT here], it seems to me that Marx clearly was inspired by poor worker conditions; a good 1/3 of Capital is empirical discourse on worker conditions. I feel that there might be something more to your argument, so please elaborate if you feel the need.
- TheNorthman 6y agoI think this is a case of language being context-dependent and how the exact meaning of `inspired' depends on its use. I'll elaborate a bit but ultimately I'll say this: Marx was inspired by the world around him, which consisted of poor worker conditions [0]. We can say this confidently because recent evolution in the study of ideology tells us exactly this: We are a product of our social and material environment, something we can't escape [1]. Anyway, my point is that the way CamperBob2 discusses the topic of Marx's inspiration makes it sound like a fundamental axiom of Marxism is the poor conditions of the working class and specifically their conditions during working hours. If this was true, we'd be able to conclude that the predictions of Marx [2] would be disproved by the gradual removal of these (poor) worker conditions. We can show this isn't true by appealing to our shared knowledge about the world, where global inequality is increasing and where worker conflict was at the center of an (almost) successful presidential campaign. We can also show this with empirical data, where our shared knowledge may fail us. For instance, Marx predicted that the global rate of profit would continue to fall, the reasons for which are beyond the scope of HN. This has been demonstrated to be true by many Marxists along the years, of whom the most prominent since the rise of the IT-worker is the economist Andrew Kliman [3]. [0]: See Marx's theory of alienation and the concept of reification, for instances of this. [1]: In particular, see Anthoni Gramsci through Louis Althusser and Slavoj Zizek. [2]: Ranging from social conflict theory to capital accumulation, the tendency of the rate of profit to fall, the value-form and social conflict theory. [3]: “The Persistent Fall in Profitability Underlying the Current Crisis: New Temporalist Evidence” by Andrew Kliman
- sporkpint 6y agoI'm pretty sure Moses was not in a union.
- cheesecracker 6y agoComplete bullshit. Do a job that is actually in demand, then nobody can force you to work more than you want. And the 8 hour work day was supposedly introduced by Ford, not by Unions.
- baq 6y agoThere’s plenty of jobs in demand that still don’t pay enough to house and feed more than one person. Unions are a way of making HR listen.
- cheesecracker 6y agoWhich jobs would that be, can you give some examples?
- danaris 6y agoFast food worker? Retail clerk? Pretty much anything that falls under "essential jobs" during the pandemic fits the "in demand" label, and the vast majority of those pay low wages. And no matter how easy it is for a company to replace a given worker in their job, no job should ever pay so little that the person in it cannot live on what they make from it. Any business that cannot survive while paying its employees a true living wage does not deserve to exist, because it is offloading its costs onto the rest of us through the various social programs its employees depend upon to survive.
- amadeuspagel 6y ago>Any business that cannot survive while paying its employees a true living wage does not deserve to exist, because it is offloading its costs onto the rest of us through the various social programs its employees depend upon to survive. That's not true. The rest of us would have to pay those costs anyway. It's not like the person wouldn't exist, if they didn't have a job.
- 6y ago
- throw0101a 6y ago> Union, yes! Or at least guilds with 'base' contracts / conditions for employments. Actors all get the same basic level of protection with regards to working conditions, pensions, health care (?), but that does not stop them from negotiating different salaries (with a floor?) for the "100x" performers.
- missedthecue 6y agoActors guilds are the exception to union typicality. Not the rule
- csours 6y agoWhat got you here, may not get you there. I have personally benefited from rights that unions have fought for. I am grateful to them for this. What I see them fight for now is worker retention. The most common fight is for the worst union members, because you have to represent your worst member, otherwise what is a union worth? The other common union fight is whether the members are going to be screwed by management or by the competition, where the competition may be in a different country or a state with fewer protections on workers' rights. I think there are still marginal conflicts where the Union can secure benefits for their members, but I'm not sure how much more they can help society overall.
- femiagbabiaka 6y agoUnions are just a framework. If you dig a bit you’ll find there are factions in almost every union fighting for more democracy and benefits for the members, and many of them are winning. Two off the cuff examples are Teamsters for a Democratic Union and CORE from the Chicago Teachers Union. EDIT: it would also be remiss not to add that much of the power of unions has been stripped away by union busting and bad legislation
- RobertKerans 6y agoWorker democracy is the characteristic that's most useful. Regarding that, imo there's a good case to be made even to the conservative side of the aisle in favour of unions, as at its best they can drastically reduce the need for strong top-down regulatory legislation in favour of much more specific, granular agreements between workers and employers made from the bottom up. But the power to be able to do that has been crippled (for good reason in some cases! But not all).