5 ms·
A few extra seconds of app startup time or an extra frame of latency in your terminal is a small price to pay for the absolutely massive difference in functiona
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
A few extra seconds of app startup time or an extra frame of latency in your terminal is a small price to pay for the absolutely massive difference in functionality of newer apps.
It’s fun to see how fast apps were when everything was extremely simple, but you can’t dismiss the fact that it was orders of magnitude less capable than modern software.
The bottom line is that modern apps are fast enough. I’ve never once thought that my terminal latency is too slow or that a few extra seconds of app startup time made a any impact on my day whatsoever.
The difference between the fastest and slowest terminals on that list is less than 30ms, or 3/100ths of a second. Literally less than a blink of an eye. It’s a fun study and enjoyed the article, but the reality is that it just doesn’t matter at all.
Anyone suggesting that computers felt faster a decade ago is misremembering the past. Try using a 2008-era computer with a mechanical HDD and you’ll quickly realize that apps did not launch faster back in the day.
- antepodius 6y agoModern programs are 100 times slower, but they definitely aren't 100 times more functional. And speed is a part of functionality and UX! I don't want to have to use a high-powered workstation or a gaming laptop to get reasonable responsiveness in my text editor. Many Javascript-powered websites with 'fancy' canvas features are janky and slow as shit on hardware that's only 10 years old, where as websites that use HTML are still snappy and fast. That 'nothing at all' matters when our current culture involves building layers and layers and mountains of stacks on top of software. That 30 ms compounds, because everyone working on each layer thinks 'hey, this is a bit slow, but it doesn't matter because it's only milliseconds.' Given this, it's obvious that modern software will be as slow and inefficient as it possibly can be before normal people notice and complain (usually only because they've used other equivalent software that's smoother and faster- it's easy to get used to jank, like low FPS in a video game.) I think that people undervalue the cost of all these layers of abstraction.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Modern programs are 100 times slower, but they definitely aren't 100 times more functional. My IntelliJ IDE is easily 100 times more functional than early text editors. As for slower: Any relative comparisons are still missing the point. It’s not a relative question. It’s an absolute question: Is this fast enough? Let’s be honest, none of us are sitting around waiting for our complex IDEs to render characters on the screen. No one really cares if it’s 1ms or 30ms or even 200ms. Likewise, I don’t care if it takes 100ms or 10s to open the IDE because I’m not quitting it and re-launching it all day. I launch it, leave it open, and that’s that. People like to glorify the good old days when apps were supposedly faster to launch, but they forget the convenience of simply leaving apps open with our oodles of RAM and letting our computers rely on suspend/wake. The longest delays in my workflow are getting my laptop out of the bag and typing in the password, or maybe downloading things from the internet. Terminal latency or app launch time just don’t even register on the list of delays during my day.
- Retric 6y agoAre you talking pre 1980’s as early? Because IntelliJ vs EMACS is hardly a 100x improvement.
- formerly_proven 6y ago> Let’s be honest, none of us are sitting around waiting for our complex IDEs to render characters on the screen. No one really cares if it’s 1ms or 30ms or even 200ms. I actually do, because I'd like for IntelliSense and clones to save me some typing, but often that doesn't quite work out, because they're too slow (inconsistently slow, too). I'd also like it if my IDE or Word editor could highlight errors in realtime, but in reality it's more like a couple seconds delayed, so I have to navigate a significant distance back to correct them, instead of being able to fix it almost on the spot.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThat’s a different topic, thought. The OP posted about typing latency, not the latency of additional complex features. It’s not exactly fair to claim that software is “slower” than old software when the software you’re comparing to doesn’t have those features at all.
- justin66 6y agoUI latency is UI latency, and the problem in both cases is due to what markstos mentioned in his initial comment: the increasing internal complexity of the software stack used to develop the software. It's not like modern hardware isn't fast enough to do literally everything that needs to be done locally with minimal UI latency.
- 6510 6y agoI'm guessing 1000x
- justin66 6y ago> Let’s be honest, none of us are sitting around waiting for our complex IDEs to render characters on the screen. No one really cares if it’s 1ms or 30ms or even 200ms. Waiting longer for a character to render to the screen than it takes to send an IP packet to a different continent and receive a reply may make you happy for some reason, but UI research indicates most people will react negatively to this. It's worse than that. With something like Visual Studio, for example, we are sitting around waiting for local variables to update in the debugger's watch window, if we're experienced enough to know that we need to do that. This kind of thing is a genuine user interface bug: if a person doesn't realize what a slow, awful piece of software they're dealing with, they'll step step step past a variable update in the debugger, never see it happen on their screen because that only works when you pause and give the watch window time to catch up, and assume it's their program that has the problem. People can get acclimated to dealing with very slow software, but they shouldn't have to when all the hardware performance to make it better already exists.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoThe market decides how much latency is acceptable. Computers are made to do work, not stroke some purist programmer ego. Computers and the software they run today enables us to do far more than we used to. If they didn't we wouldn't bother.
- csande17 6y ago> Computers and the software they run today enables us to do far more than we used to. This is true in the broadest sense -- certainly calc.exe is better than an abacus! -- but I'm not sure it's true on the 10-to-20-year timescale people are usually thinking about when they say software is declining. I use exactly zero features of my computer that were not available in Windows Vista, released in 2006.
- 8organicbits 6y agoLook at Thunderbird since 2006 to see how the product has grown. Sure, we all used "email" in 2006, but email clients were terrible. * 2007 - message tagging https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderbird_releasenotes/en-us/thunderbird/2.0.0.0/releasenotes/ https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderb... * 2009 - search result filtering https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderbird_releasenotes/en-us/thunderbird/3.0/releasenotes/ https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderb... * 2010 - mail account setup wizard https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderbird_releasenotes/en-us/thunderbird/3.1/releasenotes/ https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderb... * 2012(ish?) Support to send large attachments via 3rd party, I.E. box.com https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderbird_releasenotes/en-us/thunderbird/16.0/releasenotes/ https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderb... * 2013 - ignore threads https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderbird_releasenotes/en-us/thunderbird/24.0/releasenotes/ https://website-archive.mozilla.org/www.mozilla.org/thunderb... * 2014 - attachment reminders https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/31.0/releasenotes/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/31.0/releaseno... * 2016 - subject line spell check https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/45.0/releasenotes/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/45.0/releaseno... * 2018 - message templates https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/60.0/releasenotes/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/60.0/releaseno... * 2019 - mark all folders for account read https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/68.0/releasenotes/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/68.0/releaseno...
- 8organicbits 6y agoI think users have a performance budget and once you are inside that budget, there are rapidly diminishing returns for faster speed. > it's obvious that modern software will be as slow and inefficient as it possibly can be before normal people notice and complain Thats sort of circular. If people don't complain there's probably better places to spend engineering effort. Besides, the slower speed is traded off for something: a safer abstraction, faster development, features the users are requesting, better security, etc. I think some of us on HN have higher expectations for software performance than "normal" users, so we are the first to complain (or use alternate, faster software).
- Narishma 6y agoThat's because "normal" users don't know any better. They don't know what their hardware is capable of, so they don't know that their software is slow, so they don't complain about it. If they do they usually blame hardware.
- userbinator 6y agoUnfortunately, from some of the other comments in this discussion, it seems a lot of developers don't know any better either --- they've never seen what real "fast" is, so they think the amount of latency they experience is normal.
- edeion 6y agoI sympathize to your comment... But at the same time I'm likely to be in the crowd of the unknowings. Could you suggest examples or a way to get an idea how fast computers can be. I've recently been amazed when cracking an old cryptanalysis puzzle at what Python can do in very little time. But I have no idea what a responsive OS feels like on a general standpoint. Should I try to compile Firefox on Windows 3.1? (Just kidding on this last one, obviously.)
- boring_twenties 6y agoRight. Normal users think things like, "my computer is slow, it must be getting old, time to buy a new one."
- wyattpeak 6y ago> Modern programs are 100 times slower, but they definitely aren't 100 times more functional. I don't know if this matters. My terminal is fast enough that I've never thought about its latency. If my computer doubled in speed, I'd be happy for all of that to go to a 10% increase in terminal functionality, because otherwise it's getting wasted speeding up a task I can't tell is taking any time at all.
- tuatoru 6y agoFine, your computer can render textual characters quickly enough for you. OK. People do other things with computers. Draw. Make music. Edit music and video. Play twitch games. Get them to understand and respond to speech. The extra layers of abstraction--specifically, the latency caused by the layers--really hurts these activities. Saying that today's computers are better than those of the 1980s is very weak tea. They weren't good enough then, and they're still not good enough now.
- kranner 6y ago> People do other things with computers. Draw. Make music. Edit music and video. Play twitch games. Get them to understand and respond to speech. But these compute-intensive tasks are more often than not implemented in lower-level, highly optimised code like BLAS, CUDA, etc. I think your overall point is valid though -- I'm looking at the Gmail tab in Chrome -- but maybe not for these particular examples.
- adrianN 6y agoIf your software doubled in speed you could use a processors that needed only a fraction of the power your current processor needs. Computers consume on the order of 1% of all global energy.
- blackrock 6y agoIs the browser able to render all that JavaScript code in parallel on multi-core CPUs?
- Junk_Collector 6y agoA really good typist runs around 100 words per minute. 30 millisceonds of delay vs 2 is enough that the terminal won't keep up with the person working on it. And these are TERMINALS, other software has gotten much worse in typing latency.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoI think you’ve misinterpreted these results. The delays don’t mean that the terminal will start missing keys or won’t keep up with the operator. Humans don’t type on a tight feedback loop of waiting for characters to pop up on the screen, obviously. We also need to keep the big picture in mind. If you’re using a 60Hz monitor, it’s only going to update every 17ms anyway. Add buffering and even pixel transition latency to the equation and the end-to-end latencies are even higher. You’re not going to notice the difference between a terminal editor with 20ms of latency and one with 15ms of latency.
- 65536 6y agoI have definitely used software where it started lagging behind significantly while I was typing. That kind of stuff is absolutely infuriating.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThat’s a very different problem than the 15-30ms latency discussed in the link above.
- formerly_proven 6y agoNah, I've written texts in certain Word editors and IDEs and looked up mid-paragraph for spellchecking or re-reading it, just to see the computer still spurting out letters on the screen slower than an half-asleep OM morsing it. Sometimes these multi-core 4+ GHz fast marvels of nanotechnology simply can't keep up with a meatbag on caffeine punching keys for food. Sad in a poetic way.
- 6y ago
- FpUser 6y ago>"few extra seconds of app startup time" This is atrocious. Barring the cases when the application loads and deciphers some massive dataset upon startup normal application should start instantly or close to that.
- deiznof 6y agoAt this point I'm not even sure what people mean when they say "slow" or "poor performance", since I have a mid-tier PC and have no problems with VSCode or anything else. Everything starts fast and I have no latency issues when typing. Imperceptible differences in time are not something I would ever consider a performance problem, certainly not in the case of UX. Same thing with memory usage. If I'm not even using a third my RAM with my browser, editor and a few other random things open I'm not going to complain about something being a "resource hog".
- atq2119 6y agoThere are two possible reasons for this. One, you simply may not know better. If you've never experienced the typing latency of an 80s or 90s style system, you may not have a reference point for low latency. Not saying this is necessarily the case for you, but I suspect it's the case for some people. Second, people genuinely have different perception. The most stark example of this in practice for me was the perception of flicker on CRTs. Many people claimed to just not notice flicker at 60Hz, while for me going back from 100Hz to 60Hz was unbearable for longer amounts of time. I'm sure similar differences exist with our perceptions of latency.
- znpy 6y agoI would be okay and favour the tradeoff... But I recently decided to eradicate gnome-calculator in favour of xcalc because gnome-calculator (probably due to being packaged as a snap) was taking 5-10 sec to show up whereas xcalc is literally instantaneous.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> absolutely massive difference in functionality of newer apps As antepodius already said, this isn't really true. Slack has a few more features than the chat applications of 15 years ago. I suspect it may also lack a few of their features. It uses vastly more resources. Visual Studio is a full IDE, with more features than the Electron-based Visual Sudio Code.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Slack has a few more features than the chat applications of 15 years ago. I suspect it may also lack a few of their features. It uses vastly more resources. Yet Slack has massively more adoption than any previous chat app. That’s not by coincidence: They made it at least an order of magnitude more useful for their target audience. Slack is, without a doubt, orders of magnitude more complicated than previous-gen chat apps. It’s not like they could have built it with a handful of engineers operating some IRC servers. However, I was specifically referring to text editors (responding to the OP) vs modern IDEs. As you said, full IDEs have vastly more features than a simple terminal program or basic text editor. That’s where the order of magnitude more functionality comes from.
- flukus 6y ago> Yet Slack has massively more adoption than any previous chat app Maybe just, by virtue of there being more internet users these days. But you're underestimating just how ubiquitous IRC was, it was near universal. Sure there was no single app that everyone used, but that was a feature. With slack we've gained a few features but regressed in so many other ways.
- userbinator 6y agoTry using a 2008-era computer with a mechanical HDD and you’ll quickly realize that apps did not launch faster back in the day. I'm still using one! And it's fast enough for what I do with it --- mainly native development in C, but also the usual communications: email, IM, watching videos, reading content-focused web sites (not web apps), etc. Since I don't use anything bloated, 4GB of RAM is more than enough and the HDD remains silent most of the time. I experience far more delay and frustration using a much newer, ~1-year-old work laptop with much faster CPU and several times the RAM, but with Electron apps or any other "modern crap" that has a fraction of the functionality. The most vivid recent example is the YouTube "new design" --- it is disturbingly slow and dumbed-down. On this new machine I still experience lag often when interacting with bloated JS web apps, which can't even keep up with my typing speed (web-based Outlook is a notable example of this.) Even presumably-native applications are not immune to this cancerous growth. UWP is another example; the Win10 calculator somehow needs a loading screen, and so does the Settings app, whose featureless pathetic excuse of a UI somehow manages to be less responsive than the classic Control Panel, which opens basically instantly and is just as responsive to input. Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18506170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18506170
- abjKT26nO8 6y ago> the Win10 calculator somehow needs a loading screen This right here made my day. No further comment on the state of technology today needed.
- wolco 6y agoI still use a machine like that. They were faster hands down. Even faster a commodore 64. Flick a switch the os is ready. Load geos now you have a basic windows.
- hedora 6y agoMy desktop is about 10 years old with an old SSD, but /home is on a btrfs raid NAS on spinning disk (over WIFI). It runs a minimalist WM. I paid about $1000 for it (and a few hundred later for the boot SSD, a new video card, and a 802.11ac pcie card) It is significantly faster at all mainstream tasks than my late 2018 $2700+ work laptop running $VENDOR_DEFAULT desktop environment.
- tonymet 6y agoSorry the opposite is true here . Desktop gui apps from the 90s were much more advanced , with more features and more responsive
- pjc50 6y agoQuite a lot of the new functionality is "value subtraction": adware or spyware that makes the user experience worse. The recent fiasco where Facebook accidentally broke startup for all apps using their toolkit is a good example.