10 ms·
Venice test brings up floodgates for first time
- esturk 6y agoMissing in the article is the cost of the MOSE system which projected to cost 5.5 Billion Euros! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project#Projections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project#Projections
- arcticbull 6y agoI suspect building a new Venice would cost a few bucks more.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoLetting Venice go is also an option. Going to happen to a lot of low lying geographies as sea levels rise and mitigation becomes unaffordable. Hard decisions ahead about what’s worth saving. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180703190745.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180703190745.h... (“Rising sea levels could cost the world $14 trillion a year by 2100”) For comparison, the EU’s budget is around €150B/year.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe EU's budget is only a tiny part of public spending of the EU's member states, though, as they each handle their own military, welfare, etc. spending individually. It's more like DC's budget than the US Federal budget in magnitude/importance.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThat’s a fair point. Looking at the EU as a whole, I would argue it doesn’t have the resources to spend on enormous climate mitigation capital projects consistently with most of its countries dependent on a handful of economic engines (primarily France and Germany with the UK leaving), compounded by a rapidly aging workforce turning into pensioners who will be competing against those capital projects for fiscal support.
- pmontra 6y agoEU Contributors and Beneficiaries 2018 https://www.statista.com/chart/18794/net-contributors-to-eu-budget/ https://www.statista.com/chart/18794/net-contributors-to-eu-...
- EricE 6y agoPlease. Every 20 years the predictions that ocean levels are going to rise by x feet happen and decades later they haven't moved anywhere close.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoHaven't seen that. Can you link some of those predictions?
- mhh__ 6y ago[Citation needed]?
- CameronNemo 6y agoNot backing up the parent skeptic comment, but here is a source I found for sea level rise: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/global-warming/sea-level-rise/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/global-warmin...
- mikepurvis 6y agoLooks like some real actual rise to me: https://www.globalchange.gov/browse/indicators/global-sea-level-rise https://www.globalchange.gov/browse/indicators/global-sea-le...
- soamv 6y agoNo, sea levels have risen as predicted; see for example https://blogs.egu.eu/divisions/gd/2017/09/13/modern-day-sea-level-rise/ https://blogs.egu.eu/divisions/gd/2017/09/13/modern-day-sea-...
- aaron695 6y ago"Humans Can Survive Underwater Alarming media stories that twist the facts about rising sea levels are dangerous because they scare people unnecessarily and push policymakers toward excessively expensive measures to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions. The real solution is to lift the world’s poorest out of poverty and protect them with simple infrastructure." https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/rising-sea-levels-media-alarmism-by-bjorn-lomborg-2019-11 https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/rising-sea-leve...
- Udik 6y agoArchived: http://archive.is/smovR http://archive.is/smovR
- sandworm101 6y agoNot really. Venice is sinking faster today due to seas rising, but the city has been sinking into the mud since day one. In the past buildings were regularly demolished and new ones built atop the rubble. At some point in recent history we decided to stop doing that, to lock all the buildings in place and "protect" them. This phenomena is not unique to Venice. Whether it is sea level rise in Venice, height limits in Paris, or widespread "heritage" status for anything over a few decades old, all over the world we protect buildings and architecture. This means sacrificing the needs of greater cities and the people who live in those cities. Let's protect all the Venices of the world, but treat them as what they are: museums or theme parks, not places people actually live and work. Venice already has the boat rides and is talking about a gate price (a tourist day fee). Next will come the wrist bands. Then the mascots and cotton candy. How many of the tourists on those giant cruise ships actually get off the boat? Do many of them that just look at Venice from their cabins? That might make Venice the world's largest public art exhibition.
- arcticbull 6y agoI'm not sure even letting the sea reclaim it would be cheaper, the environmental impact alone might well require either a costly dismantle operation or just walling it in where the waste can't get out.
- II2II 6y agoThe city that I live in faces similar issues, even though it is young by international standards, and those issues exhibit themselves in very peculiar ways. If we were talking about a building that is actively maintained and played a significant role in events, I can understand the desire to preserve it. Yet, more often than not, the buildings are decayed due to neglect and very few people actually care about the building until it is about to be torn down. Worse yet, the structure has frequently been altered to the point where it is no longer of architectural interest. So yes, this is a concern from the perspective of the greater needs of cities. Which is why I was puzzled by the opposition due to the environmental impact. On the other hand, I suspect that these attitudes stem from something other than a desire for preservation. It may sound noble to talk about the greater needs of cities, yet some mighty nasty projects have been undertaken in the name of redevelopment. For some people this brings up extreme cases of forced removal, serving the needs of special interests, or simply creating inhumane environments.
- Razengan 6y agoThey could move it to Mars: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aria_(manga) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aria_(manga) https://aria.fandom.com/wiki/Neo-Venezia https://aria.fandom.com/wiki/Neo-Venezia
- Tade0 6y agoMy SO used to work seasonally in Venice. It is said that Venetians swear a lot, but perhaps those who got this impression were simply overhearing conversations about this system.
- Jerry2 6y agoFTA: >Protesters from the No Mose group tried to disrupt the test but police stopped them. The article doesn't elaborate on their motives at all but does anyone know what they were protesting? The cost? The corrouption? Surely not the function of the system itself...
- myself248 6y agoOr just protesting because they're bored and feeling unfulfilled, and opposing something makes them feel alive?
- dewiz 6y agoFuture maintenance costs; environment impact; actual effectiveness once water level raises in future; excessive realization costs and corruption.
- dan1234 6y agoThere’s a Wikipedia article about MOSE, seems like cost, corruption and environmental impact are all factors. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOSE_Project
- raverbashing 6y ago"Environmental impact" To me it makes as much sense as protesting against 5G but anyway
- Udik 6y agoUnfortunately it's a cultural trait in Italy that people prefer to have been right all the time rather than working together for a common goal. The MOSE project was heavily criticized from the beginning for a variety of reasons, ranging from the basic physics principles on which it works, to the engineering details, to the effects on the lagoon's ecosystem. It is generally claimed that there are cheaper "other methods" to achieve the goal of protecting the city from high tides, but it's not clear which they would be, how effective they would be, and what would be their environmental and visual impact. In any case, a protest from the group opposing the construction of the MOSE on the day of its general test is absolutely ridiculous. These people cannot possibly be asking for anything concrete, they just hope that something will go wrong so they'll be able to say that they've been right all the time, Venice be screwed.
- dailygrind___ 6y agoIt's worth noting the corruption around the building of this infrastructure. The president of the region at the time had been arrested along with notable other people within the public and private sector. This, unfortunately, is the story for every public infrastructure in Italy.
- lbeltrame 6y ago> This, unfortunately, is the story for every public infrastructure in Italy. I argue it's not the case. Over-bureaucracy (ironically, to fight "corruption", like the useless "anti-corruption authority") is one of the major reasons things get done at glacial paces (and the same reason sometimes people use "other ways" to speed up things). The replacement of Ponte Morandi in Genova is a prime example of this fact: to rebuild it lots of "rules" had to be suspended.
- camillomiller 6y agociao Gigi ;)
- throwaways8n27d 6y ago> Over-bureaucracy (ironically, to fight "corruption", like the useless "anti-corruption authority") is one of the major reasons things get done at glacial paces (and the same reason sometimes people use "other ways" to speed up things). Data in 2018's report "Tempi di realizzazione delle opere pubbliche" [0] seems to contradict this. The 7th post in this [1] twitter thread summarizes it. [0] https://www.agenziacoesione.gov.it/news_istituzionali/tempi-di-realizzazione-delle-opere-pubbliche-online-il-rapporto-2018/ https://www.agenziacoesione.gov.it/news_istituzionali/tempi-... [1] https://twitter.com/CarloStagnaro/status/1280401691997876227 https://twitter.com/CarloStagnaro/status/1280401691997876227 Edit: added post number.
- lbeltrame 6y agoThe Twitter thread seems to contradict this claim. > Seconda domanda: da cosa dipendono allora le lungaggini, se non dall’affidamento? La risposta è esattamente quella che state pensando: dalla burocrazia. "Second question: what is the cause of slowness, if not when a work is actually given [to whoever got the contract]? The answer is exactly what you're thinking about: bureaucracy." The next few tweets bring data which supports this.