6 ms·
It is difficult to build/create something you don't understand. A computer is just a playback machine for binary logic. We know that "intelligence" can create
by jqpabc123 6y ago
It is difficult to build/create something you don't understand.
A computer is just a playback machine for binary logic.
We know that "intelligence" can create binary logic.
We don't know if binary logic can create "intelligence".
Claims that it is possible are really more "religious" than scientific at this point.
- eli_gottlieb 6y agoThe real question is whether Universal Turing Machines, or some equivalently powerful formalism, can create "intelligence".
- loosetypes 6y agoHow is that not the same question with fluffier terminology?
- eli_gottlieb 6y agoBoolean circuits are memoryless, and a strictly weaker class of computation than Turing machines.
- jupp0r 6y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. In light of our limited understanding of how the brain works, claiming it is not possible to recreate its functions inside a computer programming is a much stronger claim than to assume that it’s possible and we just don’t know how. Unless we see a mathematical proof that it’s impossible, I think people who claim that it’s impossible are the same as people who claimed that only birds can fly and that it is impossible for machines to roam the skies.
- bena 6y agoThis is just flipping the burden of proof around. What is your proof that it can be done? "But planes" is not proof. I'm of the opinion that we don't even know what questions we are trying to answer. What is intelligence? What is consciousness? Can you explain them in concrete terms that are acceptable to everyone and don't have any notable exceptions? That's going to be the first step to being anywhere close to realizing general a.i..
- vidarh 6y agoThe strong indication that it can be done is that brains exists and grow guided by machinery that is computationally limited by the fact it takes up exceedingly little space, and we by extension can put an upper bound on the computational capacity of that machinery. That there is a tough engineering job involved in reproducing such machinery so we can grown brain matter at will, and that we'd prefer our computers to be less squishy does not mean it is likely to be impossible to reproduce it.
- bena 6y ago"It exists, therefore we can make it." I don't find that line of thought compelling. Although you can argue that we already do it because we, as a species, reproduce. It could be quite possible that our level of intelligence is not reproducible by the means we have chosen. It could be that there is something inherent in our entire composition that allows for our particular expression of intelligence and consciousness. I'm not saying it's impossible. I am saying that first, we don't even know what we're looking for. And when pressed as to what that is, the answer comes down to basically, "You know..." while gesturing broadly.
- vidarh 6y agoIt's indeed quite possible it is not reproducible by building digital computers out of silicon, sure, but that does not prevent us from picking another way of building them. I'm very much sympathetic to the idea that there could potentially be aspects about the specific structure of a brain that is necessary to produce intelligence, or at least necessary for sentience. But does not inherently make it impossible to reproduce. For it to be impossible to reproduce a brain, there would need to be something in the cellular machinery used to construct a brain that we can not pick a party and replicate. As a reminder, the argument made in the article is that it is impossible even in principle, not that it is impossible to do it using a digital computer of typical current architecture.
- bena 6y ago
- quibbler 6y agoWe know that machines with AGI are possible - humans are such machines. Maybe you could discuss whether classical computers could achieve AGI, but I think overall the quest is to build machines with AGI, not necessarily in the form of classical computers.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"We know that machines with AGI are possible - humans are such machines." I believe, it is disputed, whether humans are just machines. But it is mostly a matter of definition, I believe.
- baddox 6y agoTo claim otherwise is to claim that there is some barrier beyond which scientific inquiry is not allowed to cross or is incapable of crossing. The epistemological status of such a claim is roughly equivalent to explaining something about the Universe by saying "it's because God did it."
- jqpabc123 6y agoNo. It is not necessarily a claim that it can't be crossed, it is a claim that we currently lack the knowledge and resources needed to cross it. We haven't figured out how to travel faster than the speed of light. That doesn't necessarily mean it can't be done. But we currently lack the knowledge and resources needed to do it.
- hutzlibu 6y agoNothing to do with god. Machine comes from mechanic and there is doubt, that general artificial intelligence can be achieved with a mechanical base. But if you define any complex systema machine, then yeah sure, we humans are machines. Therefore GAI can be achieved with machines. Tautological proof.
- quibbler 6y agoThere are of course people who believe something supernatural (a soul) is involved.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"A computer is just a playback machine for binary logic." If you have code changing code, based on input, which is a neural net, then you have a bit more.
- jqpabc123 6y agoAll purely binary logic. It can't be anything more --- this is all the hardware understands.
- chess_buster 6y agoWrong. The process is more than the operations. A computer is not just a playback machine like a mechanical loom.
- jqpabc123 6y agoA computer is not just a playback machine like a mechanical loom. What is it then? Magic? The fact that you don't understand how it works doesn't make it magical. Every program ever written for your desktop computer was ultimately "compiled" into a long series of simple binary logic operations that your computer blindly repeats at very high speed. For every set of inputs, it recreates the same output --- kinda like a loom mechanically weaves a particular pattern at high speed once it has been "programmed" using a set of punch cards not unlike those once used to program computers.
- hutzlibu 6y agoA video player is just a static playback machine. A computer is dynamic playback machine, which can change what "to play" and how to play it over time. Indeed magic, for anyone who does not understand it.
- jqpabc123 6y agoDynamic = Binary Logic By it's nature, binary logic is "dynamic". A computer is just a playback machine for binary logic.
- doliveira 6y agoWhat is "religious" is this inclination to treat human intelligence as this magical thing that works outside the laws of nature, as if our neurons and our brain were something other than just chemistry doing very complex things. That would be quite an extraordinary claim that requires equally extraordinary evidence.
- jqpabc123 6y agoLife in general and your brain in particular may very well be more than "just chemistry". We really don't know. What we do know at this point is that no amount of "just chemistry" has ever managed to create even the most rudimentary form of "life" from inert chemicals. And the only working models we have for "intelligence" at this point are inextricably bound to life.
- doliveira 6y agoYeah, demons may be pushing chemicals down your neurons or your soul is giving tiny electrical shocks to the axons. Anything is possible. One would think that the synthesis of urea back in 1828 would at least weaken this argument, but hey...
- jqpabc123 6y agoNice straw man.
- dwaltrip 6y agoDon’t beat around the bush. Are you implying life is supernaturally sustained? That would be quite the claim. If not, then the history of science strongly suggests we can eventually learn the mechanisms of life and intelligence and then find a way to imperfectly yet sufficiently reimplement them.
- jqpabc123 6y agoAre you suggesting life is supernaturally sustained? No. I am simply suggesting that creating life (and intelligence) from inert materals may involve more than "just chemistry". In the same way that lead can not be turned into gold by "just chemistry". I welcome knowledge and proof to the contrary but thus far, there is none.
- sobellian 6y agoIs your problem digital logic? Analog computers predate digital computers. I doubt that's the sticking point but if it is, it's not an impossible hurdle.
- jqpabc123 6y agoSomeone won an award for mathematically proving that a simple general purpose computer could be built from a handful of color coded wooden switches powered by a hand crank and programmed by punched tape. This simple analog device could run any possible binary logic program that could ever be created --- albeit much slower than a modern digital computer. In other words, this rudimentary analog logic playback device is every bit as "smart" as any other binary logic computer will ever be --- which is to say, not at all.
- mcguire 6y agoNow go back to step 4, make the additional assumption that dualism is false and restart the proof.