11 ms·
Healthy Self-Doubt
- wilsocr88 6y agoI wonder how much of this ends up being from gender-based socialization. Maybe this individual got just the right balance of encouragement and luck in her upbringing to build a healthy balance of self-confidence in her abilities and self-doubt to encourage her to keep learning. Meanwhile, a ton of men are insecure and scared, but they're treated as "the default choice," so in many cases they may not receive that formative boost of self-confidence. Thus, we get grown men convinced that they don't belong in their own careers.
- loopz 6y agoThe individual may feel impostor syndrome or similar negative feelings. On one level emotions need to be managed (observed & accepted). Associating emotion with being "underrepresented" may just be one of many possible internal justifications. The environment, work-environment dynamics, unreasonable demands and lack of leadership, are probably more powerful influences than one single individual's exhaggerated feelings of responsibility. Psychological safe space must be consciously built and maintained, sometimes by dilligent effort on multiple levels pushing back against existing marginalizing forces. The modern victim narratives I don't automatically subscribe to. Though, try to relentlessly direct attention to official and unofficial power structures: How they shape interactions, siloing and the inevitable unhealthy power dynamics (entropy). The dynamics is defined from top and down in typical hierachical structures, but is not rectified until cooperation starts at the top. Sometimes, technology and knowledge hoarding is used to same effects and ends. With good people all this may happen unwittingly, no matter the color, gender or "representation". The cure to self-doubt is a healthy and supportive environment to provide necessary feedback during the course of creative and deep knowledge work. This happens to really be what agility is about too. The Divide & Conquer-people would like us to fully believe in individualism, to justify shortcomings in leadership, for own small-minded benefits or managerial simplicity.
- Negitivefrags 6y agoImposter syndrome such a popular thing to belive in because actually most people really do suck at their jobs. I see a similar sentiment all the time where people say things along the lines of "Nobody really feels like an adult, we are all just muddling through" etc etc. Actually no, some of us actually have our shit sorted out and are actual adults.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> Imposter syndrome such a popular thing to belive in because actually most people really do suck at their jobs. The question then is whether there's a correlation between professional confidence and job performance.
- loopz 6y agoIs the metric individual job performance, or outcome on the whole?
- hnarn 6y agoBoth "professional confidence" and "job performance" are hard, if not impossible, to quantify, so I'm not sure how one would even begin to answer that question.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoProfessional confidence isn't hard to quantify. Give a quiz with scoring from 1 to 10. Job performance may be easy to quantify depending on the job role. For students, it's trivial.
- baxtr 6y agoTrue that. Dunning Kruger still applies
- 65536 6y ago> I see a similar sentiment all the time where people say things along the lines of "Nobody really feels like an adult, we are all just muddling through" etc etc. To me, when I used to feel like this a few years ago, it was not about the fact that I didn’t have my stuff sorted (which is also true that I hadn’t), but rather that it turned out that what I thought adult life was about when I was little turned out to not be true. Since then I have been able to reconcile that, and to work out a direction that I am pursuing. One footnote to that though, is that I am still not an adult in the traditional sense of having financial security and a spouse. But I am working towards that.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThe more I know, the more I know I don't know. Being wrong is the first step to being right.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoThe more I know, the more there is to learn... this is what causes impostor syndrome.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI always equate "impostor syndrome" to being insecure. There's a ton of stuff I don't know, and that's fine. I'm not afraid to ask "stupid" questions, and let folks know that I don't know something. Sometimes, I have no interest in knowing it, so I don't ask questions about it, and don't pretend that I know anything about it. But there's also a lot of stuff I do know. At one time, I didn't know it, and asked a question. Now I know it. The only annoying thing about my approach, is that when I state confidence in what I do know, it's perceived as "arrogance," and when I state what I don't know, I'm labeled as "stupid," or "lazy" (I'm none of the above). I've learned to ignore this type of thing, and go ahead and ask my silly questions. Over the years, I have become better at asking questions. That's an art, in its own right. Sometimes, the best way to get a correct answer, is to state something wrong. People will fall all over themselves to correct me. It can be grating, because they are sometimes rather nasty about it, but they also tend to do their homework, to make sure they are right, and I can rely on their response. I've also found that the world will continue to rotate whether or not I provide my opinion/experience/knowledge at every opportunity that pops up. I'd like people to respect me, but I won't go off into the desert to die, because someone on the Internet doesn't like me.
- kubanczyk 6y agoWell, knowing something is not arrogance. Stating that you know something is arrogance, unless you take precautions. I'm not saying it's bad, I'm saying the situation perfectly matches the dictionary definition of the word "arrogance". Everyone around here surely knows that it's often sufficient to prefix the opinion with "everyone here surely knows that <X>". Because if you say raw "X" very confidently, people immediately assume that your full implicit message is "I cannot believe I even have to waste my precious time to explain to you nitwits that <X>".
- kevsim 6y agoTo me what the author is describing as 'healthy self-doubt' doesn't sound like self-doubt to me at, but rather admitting one doesn't know everything, one needs to surround oneself with competent people, etc. If you feel you're good-to-go except there are some things you just don't know, I'd say you're not suffering much self-doubt at all.
- twic 6y agoHealthy self-skepticism might be more accurate, but it's clunky.
- luckylion 6y ago> At some point in my software engineering/leadership career, it became evident that I was expected to have Impostor Syndrome. Indeed, it became clear that all underrepresented people in tech were expected to have Impostor Syndrome. Is that so? I agree with the first part: it's somewhat expected that you deal with impostor syndrome. But it's pretty much expected for everyone, regardless of some group representation. I believe it's an occupational thing, not a "I'm in the minority" thing. That may contribute, but it's not the factor at all.
- blickentwapft 6y agoIt’s strange. In the tech industry, whenever you express any self doubt, people read that as you saying you have impostor syndrome. Why is that?
- bitten 6y agowith imposter syndrome you have self doubt, but having self doubt doesn't mean you have imposter syndrome. at least to my understanding and experience. so the difference can be confusing and it's easy to label one as the other. but i also appreciate your concern, my friends use imposter syndrome when they sometimes mean self doubt.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoBecause as opposed to what many people like to think, and even though tech is a purely desk-kind-of-job; tech doesn’t actually require deep intellectual thinking. Tech is the least risky engineering discipline and in the huge majority of jobs requires the level of a plumber work with almost none of the liabilities of physical manufacturing. So of course a lot of us have impostor syndrome as we’re simply not doing anything special (but also the job doesn’t actually require anything special either)
- kubanczyk 6y agoI read you. Impostors bad-mouthing themselves? That's a contradiction in terms pure and simple.
- twic 6y agoTangentially related, John Carmack on the value of feeling ashamed of your work: https://www.wanzafran.com/posts/2020/shame-and-code/ https://www.wanzafran.com/posts/2020/shame-and-code/
- philosopherdog 6y agoImposter syndrome is where you actually have the skills and/or knowledge but don’t believe you do (irrationally). Most people are simply incompetent. That is not imposter syndrome. Having a rational sense of your actual abilities is tough because beliefs affect confidence. So most people seem to be encouraged to over inflate their abilities. The syndrome is not imposter but over inflation.
- knightofmars 6y ago"I distinguish four types. There are clever, hardworking, stupid, and lazy officers. Usually two characteristics are combined. Some are clever and hardworking; their place is the General Staff. The next ones are stupid and lazy; they make up 90 percent of every army and are suited to routine duties. Anyone who is both clever and lazy is qualified for the highest leadership duties, because he possesses the mental clarity and strength of nerve necessary for difficult decisions. One must beware of anyone who is both stupid and hardworking; he must not be entrusted with any responsibility because he will always only cause damage." -Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord
- kubanczyk 6y agoYet the question is not "am I stupid or clever?", the question is should I take advice from the army's central Hitler's opponent whose decisive moment of the career is described by Wikipedia like this: > Hammerstein repeatedly warned President Paul von Hindenburg about the dangers of appointing Hitler as chancellor. In response, Hindenburg assured Hammerstein that "he would not even consider making that Austrian corporal the minister of defense or the chancellor". Barely four days later, on 30 January 1933, pursuant to a request by Hindenburg, Hitler formed a cabinet as the German Chancellor [...]. Hammerstein was forced to resign from his office on 31 January 1934.
- interactivecode 6y agoHere is the thing, it's not very accepted or welcomed to have a lack of skills and knowledge in any paid work. So if you don't have some or all skills for the job you are in, how do you reconcile that?
- edu 6y agoI've seen quite a lot of people from underrepresented groups claiming they have impostor syndrome but from the outside they seem to be closer to the Dunnunig-Kruger effect and just claiming it because it's hype. Of course, I'm not in their minds and I'm absolutely biased.
- throwaway241593 6y agoThis is for last_question. I saw your comment before you deleted it: I could have written something similar in my early 20s, except I was too busy masturbating and playing video games and hating myself. I joined a 12 step group for porn and formed some of the first real relationships in my life. I've stood up to my shitty parents. I've learned to take care of myself and make a life for myself. I have a family now. I try to help other people (and animals). Life is not perfect, but it is good. I learned that God exists and loves me. He loves you too! He only made one of you and he doesn't make junk! I don't know what you should do in your life, but I would recommend setting some goals and finding a way to take a small step towards them every day. You aren't going to claim your life in one big step, it will be lots steps. There will be loses and pain and mistakes, but there will be good too. There will be victories and successes, but only if you put yourself out there and try something. Here are the things that help me: * Going for a walk. * Getting a job. * Getting an apartment (with roommates to cover expenses) * Forming relationships with people. Church, 12 step meetings, meetups. Anything that gets you socializing in a healthy way * Reading a book * Meditating * Swimming * Learning something * Being honest with people I trust about what's going on inside of me * Listening to other people * Feeding squirrels For me, I have spent a lot of time thinking about how the world and my parents have screwed me. It didn't help me too much. A prayer for both of us: God, Thank you for saving me from my demons. Thank you for last_question having the courage to speak up today. Please hold last_question in your hand, and provide the love and comfort that only you can. Thank you for the squirrels that we feed. Thank you for water and the sky. Thank you for giving me a job, so that I get to feed the squirrels. Please lift up last_question with an outpouring of love! Show us what to do and give us the courage to do it. Help us to set aside the garbage from our parents and help us move on with our lives. Thank you for healing us!
- jpxw 6y agoIf you feel like an impostor, chances are you are. Embrace it, relish it, learn, and you’ll become not an impostor.
- skrebbel 6y agoI feel like this comment is actively harmful. I know some ultra competent people who still feel like an impostor. They aren't. Suggesting that they are makes it harder to get out of it.
- zaroth 6y agoAre those people you know in the majority? The point could be made more politely while still being true. More interestingly, steps to take in order to tell the difference?
- TopHand 6y agoFor most of my career I worked with a small group (20 to 30) group of highly educated and mostly brilliant people. I barely graduated high school. As the years passed and we all began to age, I realized that the amount of knowledge we all had obtained during our tenure was an irreplaceable resource for the company. In order to help the younger incoming people bypass this learning curve I set up a wiki where group members could publish articles that they thought may help others not to have to re-invent the wheel. What I discovered was that most of these brilliant people would not share a lot of their knowledge. I often wondered if even these brilliant people suffered imposter syndrome and that they didn't share this knowledge for fear they would be found out. What I did learn from the most brilliant members of the group was to never be afraid to ask a question, even if it sounded ignorant. Never be afraid to expose a gap in your knowledge. If you don't, your missing an opportunity to increase your learning.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tomrod 6y agoImposter syndrome or job security? I've seen both.
- TopHand 6y agoI learned a long time ago that if you share your knowledge freely with your co-workers that only increases your job security. I postulate this plays off imposter syndrome. Your co-workers think to themselves, if this person is willing to share that knowledge, what are they holding back?
- tomrod 6y agoI learned the same, and follow such. I've also seen orgs where there is no version control because the culture encouraged people to consider themselves as sole sources of indispensable knowledge, irreplaceable. Those tended to be toxic places, but as such they show a counterexample where their specific job security was from not sharing their knowledge and experience.
- brailsafe 6y agoI think there are different varieties of this that someone can experience. Many have piled onto the "most people suck at their jobs bit" (possibly because they feel like they haven't been pat on the back enough). I feel like it can be difficult to disseminate exactly what it is that you may or may not be good at in a job, partly because the offered reasons are opaque, and partly because being good at a job doesn't necessarily depend on having a high level of whatever skill you were ostensibly hired for. Up until this year, most companies have normalized a standard definition of a job that selects for one type of person with some kind of skill that hopefully they'll be passable at. I personally have been terminated 5 or 6 times from various software related roles, and have pre-emptively quit two other unrelated jobs in customer service and moving. I have at all times, especially during the interview gauntlet, been totally dissolutioned with either my own skills, those that someone is looking for, or what I'm looking to do. I'm fairly sure that if you were a bad programmer at a software developer job, you'd never know it unless you just found yourself intellectually dumbstruck when faces with fairly mundane problems. At this juncture, I have no idea what I'd still feel like doing as a job, but I can pretty reliably guess when I'll depart of my choosing or otherwise, out of boredom, bureaucracy, or a terrible awful no-good sleep insomnia.
- njsubedi 6y agoI constantly have self doubts, something in between Imposter Syndrome and OCD. I need to make sure I did the right thing, and even when I'm done what I had to, the self doubt kicks in, the OCD makes me look over just once to make sure. I'd say, this feeling is the exact opposite of walking away from what you've destroyed behind yourself like in the movies. In the early days of my career I thought this was what is keeping myself from achieving goals but later I realized that my self doubt kept me from making a lot of mistakes that would cost a fixing. It's ok to have self doubts, it's ok to think you're not competent enough, or fear that you'll fail in general. I believe that's what actually makes you a good developer.
- wellpast 6y agoI always get excited when I see a position like this that embraces competence and seems excited at rising to the challenges of learning. There are so many meme-ish ideas that circulate that seem embraced precisely because they tacitly claim to remove the challenges of life and learning and becoming competent. Worried you're not competent enough? Oh, that's just "Imposter Syndrome", don't worry about it, we all have it, you don't need to do anything to address it. Of course there are feelings of insecurity that go too far and it's helpful to have a compassion for ourselves. But I think more important is to not couple our self-worth to our competence. The tacit and wrong assumption behind "Imposter Syndrome" (and many aspects of our culture) is the idea that our self-worth and competence are connected. It's okay to be incompetent at something; life is too short to master everything. But if you do make a conscious decision to grow your competence, then you should respect that it is going to be effort, you should even get excited about that effort, and yes, self-doubt, is essential in following through on that effort.
- yeahgoodok 6y agosmall brain: Dunning-Kruger effect normal brain: 'imposter syndrome' galaxy brain: healthy self-doubt
- leafboi 6y agoPeople always talk about this imposter syndrome thing for themselves. I think it's hard to look at yourself. You gotta look at other people. Do you think this is necessarily true? Do tons and tons of stupid people think they're smart and tons and tons of smart people think they're stupid? In general I've seen some of the former and almost none of the latter... mostly people know their place and how good they are relative to the entire ecosystem.
- mooreds 6y agoThe author also did an insightful guest post for my blog: https://letterstoanewdeveloper.com/2020/04/27/it-never-gets-easier-you-just-go-faster/ https://letterstoanewdeveloper.com/2020/04/27/it-never-gets-...
- brianzelip 6y agoTotally off topic, but damn if that TwentyTwenty WordPress theme doesn't have awful heading letter-spacing!
- drapery 6y agoImposter syndrome is very much an internal struggle and I think for some people who exhibit imposter syndrome wouldn't let other people let on. So, the fact that admitting self doubt in public shows a break from it. I had imposter syndrome while in business school and boy o boy did I try hard to fit in. Only when I realized that there is more to life than external achievements did I outwardly express any self doubt and only then to my close circle of friends.
- ravitation 6y agoThis is a bit of a weird take, the weird part is primarily... > My point is this: if we expect everybody who is a little bit different to think of themselves as an impostor, we’ve totally lost the plot on this whole inclusion thing. I'm wondering why when "especially [...] younger women" refer to "[their] Imposter Syndrome" it's assumed to be related to them being "women" and not to them being "younger?" Many young men and women feel some level of self-doubt early in their careers (and this is often labeled as "Imposter Syndrome"), which is why I'd imagine it'd be expected. I certainly did - self-doubt being simply a difference in internal vs. external "value" or "ability." I certainly wouldn't expect a woman (or man) who has been in largely the same software space for ~20 years to feel Imposter Syndrome. Other than that, which is a large portion of the article, I agree with the other general premise - that some level of humility in what you know is good (I probably would not call it "self-doubt" though, because nothing she described sounds like "self-doubt" healthy or otherwise).