27 ms·
> And then you end up with explanations like "Gravity is like a deformation of a rubber sheet". If you haven't read Eistein's "Relativity : the Special and Gen
by marcosdumay 6y ago
> And then you end up with explanations like "Gravity is like a deformation of a rubber sheet".
If you haven't read Eistein's "Relativity : the Special and General Theory", I strongly recommend you do.
It's a book aimed at laypeople, that requires only a basic (1st undergrad semester) understanding of calculus and vectors (not vector calculus, not linear algebra, just vectors). Yet, it's precise and correct, sacrificing conciseness to get easiness to understand - like every teaching book should.
So, no. It's perfectly possible to explain it without the bad analogies.
- knzhou 6y agoSpecial relativity is well-known for having the least prerequisites of any modern physics subject. Yes, you can explain it with just calculus and vectors. That's precisely what we already do in university courses. But the complaint that started this whole thread is "why can't physicists explain why it's hard to add in extra neutrinos to the Standard Model?" Understanding the reason requires 2-3 semesters of relativistic quantum field theory, a subject which in turn requires relativity, quantum mechanics, and classical field theory. Seriously, any resource that legitimately explains all of this, without bad analogies, and assuming no prerequisites, would end up precisely as hard to read (or likely harder) than the ~10,000 pages of textbook people currently study. The textbooks have already been optimized for ease of learning, there is no magic way to make a hard thing easy.