7 ms·
The kill rate for the disease the example animal (lobster) the article spends most of its time discussing is ~50%. It isn't surprising that avoiding it is a hi
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
The kill rate for the disease the example animal (lobster) the article spends most of its time discussing is ~50%. It isn't surprising that avoiding it is a highly consistent and avoidable behavior since the competitive advantage is so large.
Humans kick people out far before the stakes are that high. I'm reminded of how people with Leprosy were treated before there were drugs to treat it.
Generally speaking "hanging around with the least fit members of your species" is a losing strategy if you want to not starve long enough to reproduce so it should come as no surprise that evolution selects for the trait of avoiding the least fit members of one's species to varying degrees (depending on the specifics of the species and the type of "least fitness" in question).
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoWould you say public shaming is en evolutionary adaption? I don't have a problem with your argument. I am curious about your thoughts though.
- coldtea 6y agoI'd say that the universe (and evolutionary processes) don't care much about ethics and morals and feelings. They "care" (in as much as they care for anything) about results...
- jacobush 6y agoYes. The caring bit is up to us sentients.
- collyw 6y agoBeing cast out from society appears with many other animal spaces according to wildlife documentaries that I have seen. Public shaming is more difficult to match to animal behaviour.
- 082349872349872 6y agoA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bachelor_herd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bachelor_herd forms when young mammals start to get edgelordy, and are driven from their natal herds?
- colmvp 6y agoVietnam has very few cases of Covid-19, especially given its population and proximity to China. One of the reasons why was because they had some of the strongest containment measures in the entire world. One of the strategies they did early on was to have a very strict quarantines of villages/regions known to have infections. They would quarantine second and third degree connections to people who were infected. It may seem extreme, but given the fact that the number of total infections is fewer than 500, it's hard to argue that it wasn't effective.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoI'm sure strong containment would help, but that degree strikes me as an infringement upon liberties. It is extreme, and the fact that it was effective doesn't change the legality/morality of that sort of infringement on personal sovereignty.
- minikites 6y ago>an infringement upon liberties Which is more of an infringement on liberty, a temporary quarantine or permanent death?
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe American philosophy on this is "temporary quarantine," in general. Feels wrong, but when you look at American behavior through that lens, a lot of things make sense (gun policy immediately comes to mind). America has a deeply-ingrained "rugged individualism" cultural myth that includes the notion that sometimes the pioneer in the wildneress starves to death or gets set upon by wild beasts, and that's "just a thing that happens," "just God's will," "the price of freedom," etc.
- sethammons 6y agoIt is a slippery slope. Many diseases kill. Do we start forcing people to quarantine for those? At what threshold? Do we start controlling other aspects of people’s lifes to reduce morbidity? Unhealthy behaviors? I’m reminded of the sci-fi plot of the AI tasked with not harming humanity deciding to keep each person as safe as possible by effectively putting everyone under house arrest.
- collyw 6y ago> "hanging around with the least fit members of your species" is a losing strategy I could imagine in some circumstances it isn't. The slowest in your group will likely be first targeted / caught by a predator.
- cgriswald 6y agoI think “hanging around” is a little too loose of a term to have a truly meaningful discussion, but I generally disagree with your assertion. If you are in a herd and can be near another other herd member, it would not be beneficial to be near the one that predators are likely to target. If you are near that member, any mistake you make while running away might be your last. Less so the further away from that member (and the predators) you place yourself. Predators do not always catch their prey. A fit herd can escape without any of its members being eaten. A herd benefits from having its weakest members culled, not by having weak members. No herd animal I can think of would slow down a trek for its weakest members.
- collyw 6y agoYoung animals are often the weakest members, and plenty of adults will stay close to protect them from predators (I am thinking of Wolves where an adult bison is too large to take on, but a child is what they target). That seems like part of a winning strategy to me. There are tons of strategies employed in nature, I don't think its correct to say one is winning and one is not.
- cgriswald 6y agoThe young generally aren’t considered unfit. In the cases where they actually unfit (say a lame leg) they certainly aren’t kept around as a sacrificial offering to predators as in your example.
- guenthert 6y agoThat might work with bears, but hardly with viri ;-}
- raxxorrax 6y agoThere are people with vitiligo that are stoned to death. Aside from cosmetic effects it is completely harmless. And that is even though we have a social aspect compared to lobsters.
- MichaelApproved 6y agoDon’t forget about albinos. They’re hunted because some believe they’re witches. Others will dismember them because they believe their bones have magical powers. Here’s a story about albinos in Africa but harmful superstitions and brutal people are rampant throughout the world, western or otherwise. https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/07/africa/africa-albino-hunted-bones-malawi/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/07/africa/africa-albino-hunted-b...
- tomjakubowski 6y ago> There are people with vitiligo that are stoned to death. Citation? I can't find any sources, even non-credible ones, on Google. In fact, your comment is the top result for me when I search 'vitiligo "stoned to death"'.
- raxxorrax 6y agoNo citation, doctors I worked with told me. It's symptoms can be mistaken for leprosy and there is an immense stigma attached that escalated to violence. I doubt they were exaggerating.