4 ms·
I don't really understand what point you're trying to make. The relevant part of the mirror in the quote you're giving from 1984 is that it was compulsory. This
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I don't really understand what point you're trying to make. The relevant part of the mirror in the quote you're giving from 1984 is that it was compulsory. This product is optional.
That means I think they're not really comparable.
You can make anything sound dystopian if it were compulsory. When it's a tool people choose to use it can be empowering and help people achieve the goals they had before they chose the product.
I'm not sure this is really an intelligent or meaningful criticism. I think it's just snark - something said for the sake of it that sounds witty but doesn't really stand up if you think about it.
- cosmodisk 6y agoA mirror showing some training videos may not sound much but we already live in this dystopian world: Google knows all my secrets, I rely on Amazon in so many ways, it's ever hard to comprehend. People have TVs and Alexas that do actively listen to their conversations,not always when they'd like to. We literally sleep walked into this whole thing already.
- kadoban 6y agoI think it's less snark for me. There is a somewhat realistic concern that we're buying our own surveilance state one piece at a time. These corporations are very powerful, and we're inviting their surveilance tools into our homes without IMO a great guarantee of what's done with our data. They also tend to have a pretty cushy relationship with governments. And even where they don't, governments are able and usually willing to compromise these devices for their own purposes. That exists on a specrum from law enforcement asking for data, to the NSA and similar using security vulernabilities they buy or develop. This device in particular is probably not a big deal for the above, but it's one more for the pile.
- leppr 6y agoIt really is just a funny parallel. In objective, pragmatic terms, we've already been way beyond telescreens for a while with smartphones. They are as mandatory for upper-middle class status as telescreens are in 1984, but far more invasive.
- TuringNYC 6y agoThings are often optional until they are not. Smartphones are optional, but much of life -- say in Corporate America -- assumes you have one. Not by policy, but by social expectation.
- Falling3 6y agoOne could argue that peer pressure and forced convenience are often more effective approaches than compulsion by the state.
- root_axis 6y agoIt's not a "forced convenience" it's a veritable one, hence the ubiquity of these devices.
- Falling3 6y agoIt's undeniably both. But the former was the focus of the discussion.
- root_axis 6y agoNo, it's not both, it's not forced by any conceivable definition of the word. Anyone claiming that society is forcing them to own a smart-phone is just making excuses for not wanting to give up the convenience, but nothing is actually stopping them from doing it.