4 ms·
The more pressing issue is that everyone more powerful than the Pope has so far found themselves impotent in the face of the Chinese threat. Trump, Merkel, Modi
by LatteLazy 6y ago
The more pressing issue is that everyone more powerful than the Pope has so far found themselves impotent in the face of the Chinese threat. Trump, Merkel, Modi, Putin etc all too weak to act.
- bawolff 6y agoAre you really surprised that putin is not at the forefront of defending human rights in china?
- LatteLazy 6y agoI'm surprised he's not more concerned by Chinese border expansion against India. A nuclear war on his doorstep might affect business, or Russia might be next, or it might invite more US activity in his back yard. But yeah, I think Putin gave up on internationalism back in the 2000s.
- simonh 6y agoDestabilisation almost anywhere is bread and honey to Putin, it's what he lives on. Anyway that disputed border is 2,000km from the nearest Russian territory, which itself is some remote Siberian backwater. India buys a lot fo Russian military gear, so ka-ching!
- peteretep 6y agoIf I was a large, sparsely populated country that shared a border with China, I’d be more than a little worried about Chinese territorial ambitions. If they’re willing to rattle sabres with India over some Godforsaken rocks, imagine what they’d be willing to do for the territorial riches that lie North.
- adventured 6y agoNo question it's an issue for the coming decades. China still respects the military capabilities of Russia and their ability to defend their territory. Russia is well ahead of India in capabilities. The question is when or will that respect change and what would change it. Arrogance inevitably gets the better of all superpowers, it can't be more than 10-20 years before China starts openly trying to take Russian border territory. I also wouldn't want to be Mongolia. There's a potential that China will leave Mongolia intact as a buffer with the long Russian border. If China wants to expand its territory, there's no easier, larger target than Mongolia (17/18th largest nation by land with only 3m people and essentially no military ability to defend itself).
- peteretep 6y ago> I also wouldn't want to be Mongolia My (limited) understanding is that Mongolia is mostly steppe, and the Mongolians have several thousand years of claim to the land, neither of which is true of — say — Outer Manchuria. Russia will struggle to get much sympathy if the Chinese execute a “Crimean Gambit” there.
- jacquesm 6y agoCanada or Australia will be taken over by the Chinese long before Russia needs to worry.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoWhat’s your reasoning here? Russian military strength?
- echaozh 6y agoThe Chinese people are not mass emmigrating to Russia, yet.
- dirtyid 6y agoCCP has settled 12/14 of her inherited land borders disputes (China being the most bordered nation in the world), including with Russia in the 90s after border skirmish in the 60s. All of which with greater Chinese concessions with exception of Pakistan who gave more to spite Indian. Putin's not worried because CCP has a categorically good record for settling land border. Also Russia is China's backup lifeline for energy products via pipelines and Putin is probably interested to see how far Chinese lawfare methods can go. India/Bhutan is China's the last unsettled land border, India is currently beefing with all her neighbors which is conveniently not reported upon. This South Asian in a Nutshell gif summarizes the situation pretty aptly. https://www.reddit.com/r/KireMama/duplicates/hda8kq/south_asia_in_a_nutshell/ https://www.reddit.com/r/KireMama/duplicates/hda8kq/south_as...
- ppf 6y agoTrump is un-necessarily provocative towards China, or is weak on China? Which is it?
- dragonwriter 6y agoYou can be both unnecessarily provocative and weak in the same domain. Provocation and effective use of strength aren’t the same thing; just as you can “speak softly and carry a big stick”, so can you do the opposite.
- ppf 6y agoMaybe, but that depends if you think trade action against China, and drawing attention to the increasing oppression of the citizens of Hong Kong, is ineffectual. Do you have any proposals?
- unfunco 6y agoAll bark.
- ppf 6y agoAny ideas for "bite", if trade sanctions aren't enough?
- jacquesm 6y agoI wouldn't immediately associate Trump with rational thought, there may not be an answer here that satisfies.
- ppf 6y agoRight, so somehow he navigated the entrenched political machine of Washington DC to become president, de-escalated and decreased American influence at various war-torn hotspots (this is a whole different debate, but IMHO withdrawing from hotspots that the US has largely helped create is only a good thing), implemented a number of quite successful US business and trade policies, and started healthcare reform in the form of transparent pricing laws, all while being an irrational, despotic lunatic?