4 ms·
Not only is the software expensive it's often crap. By which I don't mean, oh no it doesn't look nice - crap as in productivity-harming. For example, Altium De
by mhh__ 6y ago
Not only is the software expensive it's often crap. By which I don't mean, oh no it doesn't look nice - crap as in productivity-harming.
For example, Altium Designer is probably the most modern (not most powerful although close) PCB suite and yet despite costing thousands a seat it is a slow, clunky, single-threaded (in 2020) program (somehow uses 20% of a 7700k at 4.6GHz with an empty design). Discord also thinks that Altium Designer is some kind of Anime MMO
- stjo 6y ago> Discord also thinks that Altium Designer is some kind of Anime MMO Hardly Altium Designer's fault, but I too would avoid using it.
- pantalaimon 6y agoKiCad nightly can now import Altium Design files, might want to give it a try ;) https://kicad-pcb.org/blog/2020/04/Development-Highlight-Altium-Pcb-Importer/ https://kicad-pcb.org/blog/2020/04/Development-Highlight-Alt...
- mhh__ 6y agoKiCad is getting very good but it requires a lot of work to compete with the big boys - for example there's no signal integrity built in, and impedance control is fairly detached from your board i.e. I don't think you can do RC on impedance control yet. I don't need a huge amount but signal integrity is fairly important for the project I'm designing.
- imtringued 6y agoFrom what I can tell a lot of parametric design software is also single threaded. I felt like this is was an opportunity where usage of multiple cores could make Freecad stand out a little bit. Except Freecad uses opencascade as their kernel and they require you to sign a CLA just to download the git repository. Considering that barrier to just cloning the code I just decided to not contribute anything. They do offer zip file downloads of the source code but at that point I lost interest.
- CompAidedPoster 6y agoI suspect geometric kernels and 2D/3D renderers don't fall into the "easy to parallelize" category. Of course there are functions that use multiple threads, but it's not obvious how you could build the core system to do so. However the code in CAD software is often pretty old, it wasn't that long ago that many of these still used intermediate mode OpenGL and I wouldn't be surprised if some still do. In the same vein something like ECAD tools don't use GPU-accelerated 2D rendering but instead use GDI and friends (which used to be HW-accelerated, but isn't since WDDM/Vista). A lot of "easy" opportunities to improve UX and productivity.
- jschwartzi 6y agoIt seems like it depends a lot on your representation of the circuit network. If you consider each trace and PCB element as a node in a graph which maps the connections of the traces and PCB elements then you could parallelize provided you can describe the boundary conditions at each node. There's a degree to which they're interdependent, but there are also nodes at which the boundary condition is effectively constant and I think those would make good cut points for parallelization.
- phkahler 6y agoSolveSpace now has some code paths multithreaded. It's not clear if this will make the next release but you can build from source with -fopenmp. Like you say, it's kind of shocking to see one core running at 100 percent while the rest do nothing and the app is sluggish in 2020.
- nybble41 6y ago> Except Freecad uses opencascade as their kernel and they require you to sign a CLA just to download the git repository. git clone https://git.dev.opencascade.org/repos/occt.git It's not well-advertised, but they do offer public read-only HTTP access to the git repository.[1] This URL really should be listed on the Resources page as well as the project summary in GitWeb. [1] https://dev.opencascade.org/index.php?q=node/1212#comment-864 https://dev.opencascade.org/index.php?q=node/1212#comment-86...
- swiley 6y agoI thought xpcb/gschem were decent although admittedly I’ve only ever tried PCB design once.