4 ms·
> I've long wondered why education isn't just a bunch of different ladders that people can crawl at their own pace. Just a guess: as far as I understood US par
by dgellow 6y ago
> I've long wondered why education isn't just a bunch of different ladders that people can crawl at their own pace.
Just a guess: as far as I understood US parents are very good at lobbying schools administration, and a lot of them would hate to see that some kids are smarter or more advanced than theirs.
Now regarding your ladder idea, in some cantons in Switzerland and some Bundesländer in Germany the school system is split in 3 lanes:
- a "gymnasium" lane that prepares you for university, mostly focused on theory and go further into technical topics
- a "general" lane that prepares you for white collar apprenticeships, more general knowledge courses
- a "labour" lane that prepares you for blue collar apprenticeships, provide more practical courses and learning support
Lane names don't really matter as they are different from place to place, but that's the general idea. Also apprenticeships opportunities are not locked based on the lane you went to, that's just the general idea. And you have multiple ways to move from one lane to another at any point during your school life if you don't fit for some reasons, with some conditions (for example you need quite good grades to move from "general" to "gymnasium").
The difference I've seen between the Swiss and German approach is how early kids are split. In my swiss canton that was after our 6th grade, so roughly at around 13 year old. In Germany that's around 10 year old.
PS: keep in mind that both Switzerland and Germany have high level of autonomy for cantons/Bundesländers, so things can be drastically different from place to place.
- chewxy 6y agoWhen I grew up (in Malaysia) our high schools were like that: split into two general streams - arts/humanities streams and STEM streams. The problem was there is a glamour to the STEM streams and so parents pushed kids towards that. If you got into the arts stream you were looked down upon
- dgellow 6y agoYeah, we have similar issues with each lane becoming a way to judge people. And as a student you feel that you’re failing if you’re not in the one considered “the good one” by parents. I don’t know if that can be avoided.
- lordnacho 6y agoThis is not quite what I had in mind, though. I lived in Switzerland as well, and it seems more like a traditional education system where everyone in the academic stream still needs to learn a broad range of subjects at the same pace as each other. Also having a single cutoff time at roughly age 12 seems quite harsh to me. I'm more thinking that you could learn English at an age-average pace while being ahead in math and physics, if that's what you wanted. Or vice versa. Qualifications would simply be a number of progressions that people could advance at their own leisure, perhaps with some sort of minimum so that you don't totally neglect certain core subjects.
- dgellow 6y agoYep, I understand. I'm not aware of school systems going as far as what you describe. That's an interesting concept, though I'm not sure how practical that would be. A set of random thoughts: - I would expect that would require more teachers which is already a scarce resource in a lot of places - Also, you mention mostly individual learning and progression, but I would also expect part of school to be about group learning, with topics such as languages that becomes more of an issue if you have part of the students ahead in English, some ahead in French, while other at average level for everything - I guess that would make school classes a more fluid concept, where you are with your advanced math friends for 2 hours, then with kids from the average English course for 2 hours. So you don't have a common group of kids spending their school time together. I'm wondering what social environment that would be, e.g would that result in more or less bullying? More or less social cohesion? More or less difficult to build friendships? If you come from a disadvantageous background, won't you have more difficulties to mix with the ones who can access more advanced courses thanks to their parents? Of course they are open questions.
- analbumcover 6y ago> I guess that would make school classes a more fluid concept, where you are with your advanced math friends for 2 hours, then with kids from the average English course for 2 hours. So you don't have a common group of kids spending their school time together. This is typical of the current American education system, at least from middle school or junior high onward, where you tend to have roughly six different classes per day with different students in each class. Although math is the only class where they will typically move advanced students ahead. You definitely lose the social cohesion that is present in elementary/primary school where you spend the whole day with the same group of kids.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoThe problem with that its in large part class based - come from a working class background or have learning disabilities you get pigeonholed into the lower tracks - with less resources. Jumping tracks is hard and before the EU intervened almost impossible.
- dgellow 6y agoYes, that's definitely an issue. I had 3-4 different version of the system I described during my school time as my swiss canton was struggling to find the correct balance, each time you could see kids finding themselves stuck because of a lack of parental resources or other reasons. Moving from one stream to another is possible, though of course that varies from place to place, but that definitely requires a strong investment from the student in both time and effort if they want to switch to a stream with more opportunities.
- dhshahsndeisjwn 6y agoI would agree. The testing used to stream kids is noisy at best and systematically biased at worst against kids with educated parents.