5 ms·
> low-material energy (i.e. energy with high power density) like nuclear Nuclear is not particularly dense, kilogram for kilogram, compared to something like s
by epistasis 6y ago
> low-material energy (i.e. energy with high power density) like nuclear
Nuclear is not particularly dense, kilogram for kilogram, compared to something like solar. A reactor and containment and cooling require absolutely massive amounts of concrete and steel.
And check out the size of the new SMRs that are being proposed; 1-10MW of an SMR isn't that tiny. I haven't run the masses at all like I have with solar and 1GW plants, since I'm not very familiar with wind turbines, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if wind and SMRs were within an order of magnitude of mass per MW.
Nuclear gets tons of energy out of small masses of fuel, but the rest of the infrastructure isn't so small, especially compared to solar which has massless fuel.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoThey are indeed massive, but a gigawatt is a lot of power! In the balance, nuclear uses a vastly less raw material and land per energy than almost all other energy sources. The DOE 2015 quadrennial report shows data on things like this, and here is a plot of the data (with citation) [1]. Where are you getting your info? E=MC² from the fuel does indeed carry over into incredibly low land, raw material, and waste footprints in nuclear. That's what's so cool about it. [1] https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/56a45d683b0be33df885def6/1559929822962-FA47VAASFE2H053HDUQI/ke17ZwdGBToddI8pDm48kNvT88LknE-K9M4pGNO0Iqd7gQa3H78H3Y0txjaiv_0fDoOvxcdMmMKkDsyUqMSsMWxHk725yiiHCCLfrh8O1z5QPOohDIaIeljMHgDF5CVlOqpeNLcJ80NK65_fV7S1USOFn4xF8vTWDNAUBm5ducQhX-V3oVjSmr829Rco4W2Uo49ZdOtO_QXox0_W7i2zEA/The+Complete+Case+for+Nuclear+-+English.008.jpeg?format=1000w https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/56a45d683b0be3... Edit: actual citation is table 10.4 in [2] on pg 390 of the pdf. That cites ref 52 which points to [3] from Argonne National Lab. Would be nice to find a better reference. [2] https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2017/03/f34/quadrennial-technology-review-2015_1.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2017/03/f34/quadrenn... [3] https://greet.es.anl.gov/ https://greet.es.anl.gov/ More info in here [4] [4] http://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-for-Climate-Action-The-Mineral-Intensity-of-the-Clean-Energy-Transition.pdf http://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/961711588875536384/Minerals-...
- _jal 6y ago> nuclear uses a vastly less [...] land per energy It really depends on which particular installation we're talking about, doesn't it? https://medium.com/social-innovation-japan/fukushimas-nuclear-exclusion-zone-7-years-on-5b1998a1d560 https://medium.com/social-innovation-japan/fukushimas-nuclea... There are some other ones occupying rather a lot of land as well...
- acidburnNSA 6y agoThe people who study these kinds of things consider accidents as well. We've been running nuclear reactors for 70+ years and can still see that on average they use a truly tiny amount of land, very compatible with ecosystem conservation. That's why a lot of conservationists do like nuclear. Keep in mind that Colorado is naturally more radioactive (due to cosmic rays at elevation and uranium in the rocks) than almost all the area surrounding Fukushima today. Thus you can find people who say that nuclear accidents create permanently uninhabitable wastelands, but that is simply not true. Below 100 mSv/year of radiation, no one has proved that any harm is done (or not done). Antinuclear institutions have formally used the strategy of terrifying people into thinking that even levels of radiation close to the natural background (3-6 mSv/yr in most places) are deadly. It is unjustifiable. There are some interesting arguments to be made about Chernobyl as well. It is not really a wasteland, as you can see in the pictures and discussion here [1]. Wildlife has returned incredibly with the absence of humans. Climate change has pretty large potential land impacts so that should be factored into fossil like natural gas too. [1] https://thoughtscapism.com/2019/05/08/what-about-radioactive-wastelands-a-look-at-chernobyls-effects-on-nature/ https://thoughtscapism.com/2019/05/08/what-about-radioactive...
- _jal 6y ago> The people who study these kinds of things consider accidents as well "Consider" is a lovely word. I would certainly consider how they accounted for things like a ~220 sq/mi exclusion zone in Japan, if I had any idea what was being referenced. > Wildlife has returned incredibly with the absence of humans. It is true that many animals find radiation more tolerable than people. You can make similar claims about mountain top removal - thanks to devastated ecosystems, Kentucky is repopulating their elk. When you get around to looking at the costs of these wildlife havens, enthusiasm for diving down this line of inquiry in any serious fashion tends to evaporate on the nuclear-booster side, though. "Something can live in any hellhole humanity can create" isn't the best of bumper-stickers, I guess. > Climate change has pretty large potential land impacts Anything that encourages taking these externalities more seriously than now...