10 ms·
Harvard is fairly cheap to attend, less than a state school for most, and free if your parents make under $65K. They were forced to do that a few years ago so
by jedberg 6y ago
Harvard is fairly cheap to attend, less than a state school for most, and free if your parents make under $65K. They were forced to do that a few years ago so the government wouldn't start taxing their endowment.
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/123014/what-harvard-actually-costs.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/12301...
- vmception 6y ago"but fuck you if your parents had good jobs but not enough for a trust fund at no fault of your own"
- MiroF 6y agoNot fuck you, just pay what you can? Harvard is extremely affordable - like among the most affordable of any school.
- vmception 6y agoBy the time I was applying for colleges, my parents made around $250,000 combined, which went to mortgages and other expenses, including retirement plans. I was therefore not eligible for any FAFSA loans, as they do not factor in zip code, cost of living, the kinds of assets or liabilities anyone has, nor inflation. Affordable, to me, was in-state tuition at $3,000 per semester at a state school, with a few community college classes. This was mixed with scholarships, and my parents subsidizing books and on campus living some semesters as that could more than double the cost of tuition. Are you saying that Harvard could have arbitrarily and unilaterally spit out a number close to that? And routinely does for people whose parents make more than $65,000? My comp sci degree has the same utility as anyone else that didn't go to Ivy League / Stanford.
- MiroF 6y agoYour household income would be more than 96% of all Americans today and likely more than that when you were applying for college. I'm not arguing that Harvard isn't expensive for affluent families, but even with an income like that you would still probably get financial aid. Harvard doesn't charge anything like full tuition to families under $200k a year, the point is just that they charge nothing at all if you make under $65k. I fail to see how that is unfair.
- vmception 6y agoMy whole post was about how "income" doesn't factor in the liabilities and obligations or cost of living of anyone. Why would you respond with that reductionist answer? Why would a university penalize a student whose parents won't shift their budget, and that's assuming it is so simple? I also asked a specific question, which you completely skipped, while doubling down on a fairness argument that this thread wasn't even about. You act knowledgeable in the matter and then aren't able to dive in, only defend your position. Its fine to say "I don't know", but right now what are you doing? Were you saying that Harvard's "affordability" was anywhere close to the $3,000 tuition / semester I ended up paying? And that's because Harvard routinely makes up any number based on a variety of financial variables (which aren't as simple as "income") and ultimately feelings?
- GlennS 6y agoIt's a price-segmentation system. It's not about fair. They have to target limited grants without much information to get the best set of students they can (plus probably keep some politicians happy about their demographics). Household income of parents is obviously a bit of weird proxy for an almost-adult child. But, I bet it works quite well at finding academically inclined people who assumed they couldn't afford X University and persuading them that they can. The alternative would probably be something like requiring all parents to buy "education insurance" for their children, which turns into a lump sum at 18, and then giving people with lower incomes a discount on that insurance. (This is a terrible idea, don't do it. Make education cheap or free instead.)
- kortilla 6y agoAgain, it’s just a “fuck you” to students who grew up in an upper middle class household in a high CoL area. Harvard’s assumption that the parents can shill out tens of thousands for their kid is just dumb. They don’t realistically take into account parents that don’t care much about education, large families, parents with lots of debt, etc.
- MiroF 6y agoThey take into account COL, they definitely take existing debt obligations into account, as well as size of family. That said, yes, if you have more money left over per child than someone else, you are expected to pay more.
- sagarm 6y ago> My comp sci degree has the same utility as anyone else that didn't go to Ivy League / Stanford. Based on my experience going from one state school to another, there can be a night and day difference in access between even state schools. I would be shocked if going to any Ivy League school didn't open up many, many doors that are closed to us plebs.
- ascar 6y agoThe irony that you can study abroad for about $12,000-$20,000 a year (including rent and other cost of living) in some countries (notably Germany) that do provide equal or better education than the state school and most importantly also provide life experience local education would not. I wonder why not many Americans go study abroad, if studying in their own country is so incredibly expensive and studying abroad can be cheaper and a richer experience. Especially comp sci is taught in English in many non-english speaking countries. Did you consider going abroad when you were evaluating costs back then?
- owenmarshall 6y agoWhile the education is likely equal or better, college is also about starting your network, especially for those of us not going to traditionally elite schools. Thinking about my personal career trajectory, my first job came from an internship set up by my university. A coworker from that job left and pulled me to my second, and when I left there it was because an old classmate referred me to a third. Had I studied abroad and returned home I would have lacked that network, and that feels like a risk.
- vmception 6y agoYou would have a different network if you had studied abroad. Nothing you did in your university was guaranteed and was just as much of a risk. I don't think non-elite schools offer a noteworthy network, especially for computer science or IT. There is elite, and then there is everywhere else that's accredited where you just need a sheet of paper with the correct degree name on it.
- vmception 6y agoNo, I didn't consider studying abroad back then and ultimately I was able to graduate without any student debt, much like my European peers do without thinking about it. But yes I've become a fan of what Germany and some other countries offer. I've seen something that made me even more envious: a friend in neighboring Austria was in University there (for free) and it turned out the school was like a sister school to NYU and she wanted to go there and was able to go to NYU for free. We are really getting the short end of the stick in America right now, amongst developed nations.
- stdbrouw 6y agoMortgages and pension plans are not strictly speaking an expense, you're paying towards an asset. It would be incredibly unfair if wealthy parents could camouflage their wealth just by taking out a big loan on a big house.
- skrtskrt 6y agoYeah I had a friend attend for like $800 a year. My understanding at the time was that some other prestige schools were similar, like Stanford. Others have followed suit - Northwestern recently announced that they would just grant financial aid recipients whatever part previously would have been loans. When I was applying to college in early 2010s as someone who received financial aid (parents made ~$100k total), I could attend: * [top 20 school - private] for ~18k a year * [top 50 school - private] for ~18k a year * [sub 200-rank school - the main in-state school] for ~$9k a year * [top 20 to top 40 schools - state - out of state] for $30k-$40k... These big state schools were the most surprising to me because everyone always says "if you're smart they'll have so many scholarships for you it'll nearly be free!" But when it came down to it the good state schools weren't even in the running. I took the more prestigious school name for half the price.
- akhilcacharya 6y agoYup, and the reality becomes winners take all. Really starts to suck for us that ended up going to a ~200 ranked institution because we couldn’t get in to the prestigious ones (which, in all honesty, is much harder than finding a way to pay for an expensive school).
- blaser-waffle 6y agoSounds like an r/K selection thing. If you can't afford an Ivy and aren't elegable for assistance, then it may be more worthwhile to do community college and laterally-transfer into a different school. I knew a dude who did community college in Northern VA (NVCC) and transferred to Cornell. Shaved off a lot of costs, got a scholarship, and walked out with an Ivy League diplo. All of those hills were good for his leg strength, too.
- akhilcacharya 6y agoTransferring into Ivies is nearly universally more difficult than getting in normally, the only exception is Cornell. Unfortunately, I'm still paying for being mediocre in my high school years!
- kbenson 6y ago> free if your parents make under $65K Which means that in the city I live in, if both parents work full time minimum wage jobs, their child might be able to go for free, since the minimum wage here is $15. It would even be slightly harder if the parents worked in San Francisco, since minimum wage is a few cents more there. I doubt anyone in that situation feels like that minimum wage is making it easy to live in the area. Programs meant to accept people from across the nation that peg goals/limits to specific income amounts don't seem to make all that much sense to me. :/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- skrtskrt 6y agoI worked in a financial aid office for some time. There are thresholds and guidelines, but in my experience financial aid officers have a lot of flexibility and discretion. They look at the complete picture, including assets, number of other siblings that are dependents/in college, etc. You can also appeal the financial aid decision, and just going to that trouble will often get you a bit more aid if you have a decent reason. The depressing part was how many people obviously lie and misrepresent their financial situation to try to cheapen their student's aid cost. Not that I can really blame them, even if you make enough money that your kids don't qualify for aid, $70,000+ per year per child is just out of hand. And there's basically no risk to trying, the aid officers just look at it and are like "obvious lie, rejected" or "possible lie, ask for supporting evidence/documents".
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI feel like very obvious lies on financial aid applications should be grounds for the school to rescind their admission.
- ericlewis 6y agonot necessarily the kids fault, so I am not sure I would agree.
- prepend 6y agoIt’s great that Harvard started their free tuition program, but for most students it costs $60-70k/year. Harvard is not “fairly cheap” and likely has something to do with their students largely coming from wealthy families.
- whymauri 6y ago>It’s great that Harvard started their free tuition program, but for most students it costs $60-70k/year. I think that's not quite right? "About 55% of Harvard students receive need-based scholarship aid with average grant totals around $53,000."
- prepend 6y agoTuition is $60k/year or 240 total. If the average grant is 53k, then that means the average cost is 187k. I went to a school with this weasel language all over their content. My kid was offered $3k/year in financial aid because the school said I should pay 65% of my annual gross to cover tuition. It’s nice that they have some token poor and working class, but Harvard is for the rich... “ According to The New York Times, the median family income of a student from Harvard is $168,800, and 67% of students come from the highest-earning 20% of American households. About 15% come from families in the top 1% of American wealth distribution.” [0] [0] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/05/it-costs-78200-to-go-to-harvardheres-what-students-actually-pay.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/05/it-costs-78200-to-go-to-harv...
- extra88 6y agoLiving with and going to class with classmates from wealthy families is part of the value-add of going to Harvard for all the students. > I should pay 65% of my annual gross to cover tuition Harvard's financial aid is very clear cut and no one would be expected to pay 65% of their gross income. > 67% of students come from the highest-earning 20% of American households A household income about about $130,000 is enough to be in the top 20%; how well off you are with that income depends on where you live. Some high-income families (top 5% of households), with an expensive mortgage and other bills, may have difficulty with paying the full amount, or close to it. Good luck finding sympathy for how those rich people chose to spend their money instead of saving for their child's education.
- scorecard 6y agoIt is not the case that Harvard is free for students whose parents make less than $65K. Read the small print.
- MiroF 6y agoIf they make less than $65k and don't have significant college savings/assets, then yes it is free. If you're a hedge fund manager who just retired and is now making $0/yr, sure it's not free.
- gammarator 6y agoHarvard has been extremely heavily discounted for low-income families for more than 20 years.
- extra88 6y ago> They were forced to do that a few years ago so the government wouldn't start taxing their endowment. Harvard College was not forced by federal policy to dramatically increase their financial aid back when they did. The 2017 tax bill did include a new tax on university endowments tailored to only apply to the wealthiest universities, including Harvard (it has the largest endowment but I'm not sure it's the largest per student).