8 ms·
In 2020, Words Are 'Violence,' Arson Is Not
- mdszy 6y agoI don't see how this is on-topic in the slightest, nor how this could lead to any form of useful discussion on this site. Regardless, if you agree with the article wholeheartedly, maybe stop to consider why you're getting more worked up over destruction of some property than over the decades-long oppression of black, hispanic and other minority communities by the police.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI think there's a discussion worth having on the increasing trend towards argument by analogy, where we judge things as good or bad based not on a concrete analysis of their effects but whether we can attach a label like "violence" to them. It's obviously prone to dragging people into political slapfights (which I see you're excited to engage in yourself!), but I don't know if that should be a disqualifier; a lot of important topics have that quality.
- mdszy 6y ago> which I see you're excited to engage in yourself! There is nothing in my comment that indicates that I'm looking to engage in a "political slapfight" - that's entirely your deal.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI have no interest in engaging myself, but I encourage you to reread the last line of your comment and consider how it comes across to people who don't agree with your perspective.
- mdszy 6y agoSo you're saying that you think that some property is more important than murders of innocent people by police that have been going on for decades? If that's not what you're saying, you should make yourself clear. Because you imply that you don't agree with my perspective, which I think is pretty straightforward and clear - people are more important than property.
- blotter_paper 6y agoI, for one, both agree with your perspective and see how the last sentence of your original comment could be taken as engaging in a "political slapfight" (a pretty vague term) when viewed from the other side. I think being able to view the world from the eyes of the other is a useful skill, even when the other is a literal fascist -- I'm not even arguing that you should necessarily come across differently, just that you should understand how you may come across to people with different perspectives.
- diffrinse 6y agoOr, put another way, you can't say one side's behavior is historically determined but not the other's.
- blotter_paper 6y agoWhile I don't disagree with my reading of your statement (which may differ greatly from your intent -- I'm not sure), I also don't see it as another way of putting my last comment; I was attempting to make another point entirely.
- diffrinse 6y agoYikes, that's embarrassing, could you possibly clarify your meaning? My point was that communicative strategy changes significantly depending on whether you account for the other person also having a perspective which is also a product of history
- shadowphex 6y agoWhy are we posting things that come from explicitly biased political websites that have nothing to do with tech? I can understand it if is breaking news, but this is an opinion piece. I have noticed more political opinion pieces posted here recently. Did the scope of this website change in the past few months?
- lollerka 6y agoDo you post this under every NYT article too? If NYT is allowed then so should be this
- shadowphex 6y agoNo, but my comment is in reference to those posts. But what makes this one especially egregious is that Reason has not pretenses about being an objective new source. The first line of their about page is: "Founded in 1968, Reason is the nation's leading libertarian magazine."
- swalsh 6y agoOP has a point. The NY Times recently began a process of shedding their ideals of objectivity too. They claim the views and inclinations of whiteness are accepted as the objective neutral. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/23/opinion/objectivity-black-journalists-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/23/opinion/objectivity-black...
- shadowphex 6y agoI agree that NYT has a bias. But they at least _try_ to appear objective (or at least objective with a left leaning slant). The article you linked is an opinion piece by a NYT writer and not the official stance of NYT (as far as I know). Also, I am not fighting for NYT articles here. I wish that there would be no opinion pieces that are not tech related. This post just seemed particularly egregious because it is an opinion piece from a new outlet that is openly and explicitly biased.
- deleuze 6y agowow, it's almost like people are more important than property.
- mdszy 6y agoExactly. When I read, "two main arguments: damaging a person is morally more serious than damaging an object, and psychologically damaging a person is worse than physically damaging an object." I couldn't help but think "Yes? That's exactly correct. Who would ever think otherwise?"
- naasking 6y agoSo giving someone a paper cut is worse than burning down someone's store in which their life savings were invested? Come on, these issues aren't covered by such trivial sound bites.
- happytoexplain 6y agoYou should try harder to give people the benefit of the doubt - you can't expect people to list every single possible caveat for every opinion they express. The article, and the parent post, both do not equate such a contrived minor injury to destroying an entire business, and you absolutely know this.
- naasking 6y ago> You should try harder to give people the benefit of the doubt - you can't expect people to list every single possible caveat for every opinion they express. The position, as stated, is literally false which my argument by absurdity demonstrates. So what I expect, is that people attempt to make true statements, and where the truth value is contextual, then their phrasing also ought to reflect that nuance, ie. damaging a person is typically morally more serious than damaging an object, and psychologically damaging a person is typically worse than physically damaging an object. There are no qualifiers in the original claim to reflect this nuance, and like it or not, people absolutely do believe unqalified claims until they are challenged on it. Why do you think slogans and propaganda are so effective.
- Shivetya 6y agoHeckler's Veto[0] in another form but the results are the same, silence differing opinion but now you have an excuse to commit violence against those who hold it or have others act on your behalf; this can include using government or employers. A very dangerous period we are entering when honest open debate is framed as anything such. We are walking right into it and worse many are find excuses for specific discussion points as warranting this behavior not fully understanding that once that genie is out of the bottle it may take a generation or more to put it back. The worst of it is that it is happening in newsrooms where groups want stories written specific ways and certain opinions must be silenced at all cost. This "moral majority" will go far beyond what many fear mongers thought a "religious right" could ever do because they do not inherent limits to the exercise of their authority or violence needed to administer it. You pretty much are bound for an authoritarian regime because democracy does not survive in silence. Will we have our own Reichstag fire[1], what form would it take? Pretty sure you can find quite a few examples [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler%27s_veto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heckler%27s_veto [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_fire
- msandford 6y ago> insisting that both parties honor legally binding contracts is violence; I'm generally a pretty big believer in upholding the law and contracts but a lot of people have been put out of work through no fault of their own, and rather unwillingly. The government did that and I think it makes sense for the government to enforce at least a temporary moratorium on evictions so that things can be done in an orderly fashion.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI'm worried about this 'silence is violence' meme. Its seems a thinly disguised 'if you aren't for us, you're against us' which is fairly infantile thinking. I know its intended to incite action, which is certainly overdue. But it has its downside too, mainly that it alienates folks.
- vanderZwan 6y agoNot really. It's not about being "against" anyone, it's about pretending to not have any responsibility while taking part in a structurally racist system. A lot of white people claim to be anti-racists but are unwilling to actually act on it, including the most basic step of speaking up when they see it happen, or acknowledging the existence of structural racism. In other words, their claim is more performative and about convincing themselves and others that they are Good People, than actually being interested in challenging a status quo that obviously wrongs a lot of people. This is also known as being an "enabler" - that is, allowing others to do wrong by looking the other way. "Silence is violence" merely calls this out. It reminds us that we are enablers of this violence if we remain silent. The vast majority of defensiveness I see in response to this pretty much just boils down to worrying about one's own position of being seen as a Good Person (by themselves and by others), instead of worrying about what is actually the right thing to do.
- zozbot234 6y agoIf the actual issue is that the system is "structurally" racist, why do we even care about blaming people for their silence, or lack thereof? Isn't it a basic starting point of performing a proper "structural" or "root-cause" based analysis of a problematic system, that one should avoid preemptively assigning blame? You really can't have it both ways, this whole way of thinking makes zero sense.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yoav 6y agoIt’s a system of people. So obviously the “root-cause analysis” would only happen if the problem wasn’t an accepted part of society. Why would anyone seek to solve a problem that no one cares about. If half of the population (the people with power) directly benefits from an unjust system, but says nothing about it, it will never be addressed. There is a conflict of interest. How can you benefit from an injustice, stay silent, and still just passively hope it will get fixed? Hundreds of years in isn’t proof enough that sitting around hoping someone else fixes it doesn’t work?
- raziel2p 6y agoIs it stupid to equate a replacing the word "sex" with "gender identity" with being punched in the face? Yes. Is it stupid to equate police brutality with riots destroying corporate property? Also yes, though maybe arguably less so. I don't think this is anything new though, I remember being in debates with libertarians 10-15 years ago who argued that tax is violence. If you want to get philosophical about it, anything that carries any intent or threat to harm if there's non-compliance can be violence, but at that point it becomes kind of a useless word.
- blotter_paper 6y agoWithout conceding that this topic should be our main focus right now I feel like we should draw a clear distinction between, say, local businesses on one extreme and police precinct buildings on the other. I see voices on the right, such as this article, invoking the destruction black-owned businesses as their examples of property damage and I can't help but feel like they tactically know this is more likely to draw a reaction than the destruction of buildings that belong to racist government institutions -- the American right wasn't too concerned when the KKK (a precursor to many southern police departments) burned down black businesses, churches, and homes. I can totally agree that the destruction of local businesses is a shame, but I'm not really worried about the big boxerinos and I'm downright ecstatic about police stations going up in flames.
- mdszy 6y agoI've also never seen a source for the claim of black-owned businesses being destroyed during these riots, I've begun to believe it's just intentional misinformation.
- blotter_paper 6y agoI'm disappointed by how much sympathy for cops was expressed in the video I'm about to link, but when Killer Mike tells me that the destruction of black-owned businesses is a problem in his community while wearing a "kill your masters" shirt[0], I sort of tentatively take his word that this is a real issue. I just think that some people are using it as a substitute for the issue they really want to raise, and it feels very disingenuous to me. Let's talk about precinct buildings. [0]: https://youtu.be/kSWasOhArfM https://youtu.be/kSWasOhArfM
- derision 6y agoIs it that far-fetched to you that with the number of black-owned businesses there are and the number of businesses that were destroyed, that at least one of them would have been destroyed in the riots? I personally know of a black-owned business in Cleveland that had to shut down after being looted. Either you're underestimating the number of black-owned businesses, the number of destroyed businesses, both, or are simply being disingenuous
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoWhy is this post flagged? The article discusses a very real problem that is creeping into all aspects of our lives, inlcuding software development. Why can't we have a civilized discussion about it?
- trabant00 6y agoI find it weird the article didn't mention the violence - violence during the protests. I mean several people got killed, I imagine quite a lot got beaten up.