3 ms·
So what, people don't get freedom of association unless they file for a court order?
by monocasa 6y ago
So what, people don't get freedom of association unless they file for a court order?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoPeople should absolutely be free to stop associating with others for bad reasons. That doesn't mean we can't encourage people not to, or talk about the badness of the reasons.
- monocasa 6y agoBut there's tons of reasons why someone might find their behavior abhorrent that don't and shouldn't pass the bar for illegality, and want to inform their employer that the employee's behavior reflects negatively enough on the employer that they would stop doing business with them. There's all sorts of acts that are never going to be proven guilty, because they're not illegal in the first place. Generally because making it illegal would conflict with the first amendment.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI disagree. I think there are very few actions so abhorrent that you should be fired for doing them in your personal life, and the vast majority of Twitter firings I've seen aren't over the line. Society isn't going to work under a standard where people who do bad things can't have jobs anymore.
- monocasa 6y ago> I disagree. I think there are very few actions so abhorrent that you should be fired for doing them in your personal life, and the vast majority of Twitter firings I've seen aren't over the line. That's cool for you, but others obviously disagree with you. > Society isn't going to work under a standard where people who do bad things can't have jobs anymore. Or people will change their actions since they want to keep being members of society.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI don't understand why you keep returning to people disagreeing with me as though it's a counterpoint. I know people disagree! That's why I'm posting; I hope to convince them that they're wrong. Society is double not going to work under a standard where we don't consider bad people members of society anymore.
- monocasa 6y ago> I don't understand why you keep returning to people disagreeing with me as though it's a counterpoint. I know people disagree! Because you're trying to enforce your standard of conduct. That's cool that only technically illegal actions are the standard for you, but it's totally valid for that not to be other's standards. > Society is double not going to work under a standard where we don't consider bad people members of society anymore. That's an argument against freedom of association. Why do people get to be free from consequences of not to the point of being illegal actions? Like that's the nonviolent method of enacting change. If you don't allow it you end up with far worse.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI'm not sure where I'm failing to communicate here. I'm not trying to enforce anything! As I mentioned earlier, I agree people have every right to shun others for any reason. I just hope to convince people that they shouldn't.
- salawat 6y agoForget it Zest. You're talking to a wall. Your message was quite clear and succinctly put. Anyone here to engage in honest rhetorical exchange will have already gotten what they need. You're absolutely right. The true measure of a civilization takes into account the treatment of its least desirable, and given the practices the above poster endorses it is quite clear his concept of a society is one where it is acceptable to violently eject anyone who becomes undesirable at any time, with no consideration or room for forgiveness. They are the one's demanding you acknowledge their right to engage in social warfare. You've clearly stated your position and rationale behind it. Just move on.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoThat would only apply to America and other countries with weak workers rights where firing people is cheap PR.
- bitwize 6y agoIt used to be that people were taught: there is the law, and there is the moral principle underlying the law. So while freedom of speech is a thing protected by the Constitution, it exists outside the Constitution as a principle that instructs us that it is not legitimate to attempt to silence people for expressing an opinion you dislike, with whatever means you have at your disposal (shunning, character assassination, etc.), simply because you dislike it. You are still free to shun people with opinions you dislike, it just may not be the right thing to do. Today, people are taught that laws are arbitrary and are made and used by the oppressor class to oppress the oppressed classes, and it is the moral mission of the oppressed classes to rise up and seize power so that the laws won't oppress then anymore. Which means that the moral principles are lost, and any weapon that finds its way in the hands of the immiserated proletariat can be legitimately used in the struggle to determine which class writes the laws.