5 ms·
I would think the DNA companies would support this. Right now, I have no plans to ever get a test. My curiosity as to whether I descended from Dr. Zaius or Cor
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I would think the DNA companies would support this.
Right now, I have no plans to ever get a test. My curiosity as to whether I descended from Dr. Zaius or Cornelius is not strong enough for me to risk having my information available for things like insurance companies dinging me.
On another note, I heard that the jury is still out on the lingering aftereffects of COVID-19, and there's a better than even chance that testing positive means that we can be discriminated against for a pre-existing condition for the rest of our lives.
- mattmanser 6y agoDoesn't actually matter if you do it, matters if any of your sister, cousins, grandma, dad, mum, aunty, etc. do. Depending on the size of your family, could be hundreds of people, some of whom might be criminals and forced to surrender their DNA.
- Taek 6y agoAt least for some genes there will be uncertainty whether you got it.
- mattmanser 6y agoStill will effect your insurance if you have a 25% chance of a particular genetic disease.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoIt almost seems like for-profit health insurance is a bad idea.
- alliao 6y agoprivatisation is useful if a problem is too hard... just let the market decide. less so if every aspect of the issue is well known I think...
- arcticbull 6y agoPrivatization is useful if something isn't in the public interest. Once you accept that socializing police, fire, elementary schools, high schools, power, water, highways, the entire judicial system, and so on is in the public interest -- and medicine for the poor, the old, the imprisoned and in some cases the young -- the question of socializing medicine for everyone is just a question of where you draw the line. Currently 40% of America is already under socialized medicine. The argument at hand is 40% or 100%. That's all. Not nearly as big an existential question as the politicians may have you believe. The question is "do we double the number of people covered by socialized medicine or not"?
- nradov 6y agoThere's a huge difference between shifting the payment risk from private insurers to the government, and real socialized medicine. Under most socialized medicine schemes the majority of healthcare providers become government employees.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoMedicare does it differently. You qualify for it and then pick a company to administer benefits. Some companies have great benefits for elders, some have great benefits for young people and families with children.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dukeyukey 6y agoMany, but certainly not all. I imagine most people don't really care who the end-employer of medical staff are if they get guaranteed a certain baseline level of care that isn't "go to A&E and pray they fix you up".
- arcticbull 6y agoSocialized medicine does not require single payer, for instance look at how Australia manages their system. Single payer is the exception, not the rule.
- nradov 6y agoAs a practical matter there are very few mutations which indicate a 25% chance of a particular disease. Most of them have much more modest effects. Like I know I have a mutation which increases my lifetime risk of shoulder dislocation to 1.3% from a baseline average of 0.8%. So what. The big one is mostly the BRCA mutations which increase cancer risk for women to around 70%.
- Lineup 6y agoIt will have the effect of increasing premiums for all participants, so I'm inclined to agree. Particularly for insurance such as LTC, if you can determine (for yourself) definitive need for the insurance - you will absolutely buy it. But at that point you are not seeking insurance because you have certainty. Rather, you would be cheating everyone that has purchased "insurance". All other participants will soon cease opting for LTC insurance due to expense unless they too have knowledge of definitive need.... LTC companies pay operation costs, salaries, bonuses, become inslovent, file for bankruptcy, and no one else gets anything.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> Rather, you would be cheating everyone that has purchased "insurance". That is a very north american definition of insurance. But insurance companies are not collectives. They are for-profit corporations, probably with a PO box in Delaware. Buying an insurance plan isn't like moving into a commune. It is a risk-shifting arrangement with a corporation, a formalized financial hedge. When I buy insurance I don't much care about other customers. They aren't part of my transaction. Maybe I am the only customer for a product. That does happen. It doesn't impact the obligations of the parties.
- readams 6y agoThe point the parent is making is that if you know in advance that you, will need to use the insurance, and you decide to buy it on this basis, then the premium the insurance company charges will need to increase to account for this, or the insurance company will lose money. Since the premium has increased, the only people who will still pay the higher premium are those that know they will need to make a claim. The premium will therefore rise to the point where _only_ the ones with that extra information will pay. Insurance markets cannot survive with this kind of information asymmetry. This is not a North American definition. This is what insurance is.
- bonzini 6y agoThat's absolutely correct. It also exemplifies why the healthcare market cannot regulate itself.
- 6nf 6y agoI'm interested in getting sequenced but I have a few requirements: - I want the full (98% +) sequencing, not just the exome - I want to download the full sequence and keep it for own future use with no restrictions - I don't want my sequence to be used for data mining or sold to third parties without my permission. - I'm not willing to pay 5 digits for this but I don't expect it for 3 digits either.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt'd be nice if the government banned preexisting condition consideration. Extremely possible; it would take one law. It'd change the economics of the market, but would it actually change them enough to make a business model where people hand you money, for free, while they're still alive unprofitable or merely less profitable?
- giancarlostoro 6y agoReminds me of one of the reasons Obama brought up in a debate (I forget which one tbh, might of been the one with McCain) that he wanted affordable healthcare because his grandmother was denied care due to a preexisting condition or something to that effect. I guess banning preexisting conditions would of been a more interesting alternative. Not sure what negative effects that ban would have, maybe coverage will rise due to surgeries not going as hoped or other cases.
- Talanes 6y agoThey've been banned for a decade now, so...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It'd be nice if the government banned preexisting condition consideration. It...has: https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/pre-existing-conditions/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/pre-existing-co...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ncallaway 6y agoThe government has banned pre-existing condition consideration. That was made illegal by the Affordable Healthcare Act (ACA, also known as Obamacare). As I noted in another comment, that law is currently being challenged in the Supreme Court by the State of Texas, and the DOJ has field a brief arguing that the law should be found unconstitutional. (See my other comment here for a link to the DOJ brief: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23744702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23744702)
- ncallaway 6y ago> and there's a better than even chance that testing positive means that we can be discriminated against for a pre-existing condition for the rest of our lives In the United States it is currently against the law for insurance companies to prevent you from obtaining coverage for having a preexisting condition under the ACA. That law is being challenged now before the Supreme Court, and the DOJ* has filed a brief arguing that the law is unconstitutional. If the SCOTUS strikes down the ACA, then it would be absolutely legal for insurance companies to deny you treatment for having had COVID-19 in the past. There is no current legislative plan to replace the ACA if its struck down. * I personally find the argument in the DOJs brief to be manifestly absurd, but you can decide for yourself here: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/19/19-840/146406/20200625205555069_19-840bsUnitedStates.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/19/19-840/146406/2020...
- creato 6y agoIt sounds like the argument is that the individual mandate to have health insurance has been repealed, so therefore, the mandate for insurers to cover people with preexisting conditions should also be repealed. What is absurd about that? It seems reasonable to me. Covering preexisting conditions and the individual mandate to buy health insurance are two sides of the same coin. Personally, I'm on the side of "we should have both" rather than "we should have neither", but the argument that you can't have one without the other is sound.
- ncallaway 6y agoSo, here's the background: After the ACA was originally passed 2010, it was challenged on constitutional grounds. It went to SCOTUS in 2012 (National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, 2012). In that case the court ruled in a 5-4 opinion that the Individual Mandate was a constitutional and valid use of Congress' taxation powers. The law survived the constitutional challenge. In 2017 a subsequent (now GOP controlled congress) zeroed out the individual mandate penalty. The individual mandate is now being challenged on constitutional grounds. The logic goes that, since there is no penalty there is no taxation. If there is no taxation, the individual mandate cannot be a constitutional under Congress' taxation powers. I'm fine with all of that. Here's now the part that I find absurd: The argument that the individual mandate cannot be severed from the rest of the ACA based on the way it was amended by the 2017 Congress. Therefore, since the IM is no longer constitutional the entire ACA must fall. The reason I find it absurd is it relies on speech and debate from the original passage of the ACA which argued that the individual mandate was required for the law to function. However, a subsequent congress deliberately chose to zero out the individual mandate without eliminating the law. The subsequent congress' decision making overrides the decision that the congress that passed the ACA. The 2017 Congress very deliberately made the individual mandate completely nonfunctional, while leaving the rest of the law in place. TL;DR - 2010 Congress passes the ACA with the Individual Mandate - 2012 SCOTUS rules it constitutional - 2017 Congress zeroes out the Individual Mandate - The argument now is that the 2010 Congress thought the ACA required the IM to function, ignoring that the 2017 Congress very obviously decided that the ACA didn't require the IM to function. To me there's just no way to square that circle. The 2017 Congress' decision overrides the 2010 Congress' decision. ----- Finally, logically I agree with you and I agree with the 2010 Congress. The Individual Mandate is necessary for the ACA to function the way it was originally designed. The ACA is a better, more functional, law with the individual mandate in place. I disagreed with the 2017 Congress' decision to remove the mandate. But that's no longer relevant. The question now is, is the IM necessary for the ACA to function the way the 2017 Congress amended it to function. The answer—since they repealed the individual mandate—is clearly "no".
- ncallaway 6y agoWhile I agree with you, I would not be willing to get a test from these companies even given a law that banned insurance companies from using genomic information (which is a good law, and should be passed!) There's still the matter of law enforcement having future access to the database for a broad search which concerns me. I don't think I'd be willing to donate to a genomic database unless there was a very strong safeguard against the police making a broad search against the database.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> very strong safeguard against the police making a broad search against the database. Not likely. The whole point of the DB is to allow "broad searches." Here's where things get a bit wonky. LPRs (License Plate Readers), although "icky," are -more or less- legal. The whole purpose of a displayed license plate is to allow the authorities to rapidly match the vehicle with the registered entity. Driving a vehicle is a privilege and an obligation, so it can easily be argued that driving a vehicle comes with the obligation to display a "tracking" plate. In fact, this might even extend to adding RF trackers. We're almost there, with EZ-Pass (Eastern US). Phones get a bit dicier. Stingrays are still very much in a legal "gray area." Until they are explicitly banned, we'll probably be seeing lots of them. Just too damn juicy. But DNA is something else. We don't need to be licensed as "humans" (although I'm sure there's folks that would love to give it a go). Much as we'd wish folks would live in a manner that obliged them to follow social norms (which is a whole bucket of snakes, right there), that ain't happening. There's no "hook" to force people to submit to DNA tagging; nor (IMNSHO), should there be. There was some founding father -I don't remember who- that said something along the lines of "I would rather see 100 guilty men go, than one innocent man imprisoned."