5 ms·
In a startup, you choose to work with people you think are talented. At a big company, you're stuck working with whoever else they've hired. What a great obser
by edw519 18y ago
In a startup, you choose to work with people you think are talented. At a big company, you're stuck working with whoever else they've hired.
What a great observation. So obvious, yet hardly ever mentioned.
I'd add...
In a startup, you choose to work on what you want, how you want. At a big company, you're stuck working on whatever they want, however they want it.
- crescendo 18y agoIn a startup, you choose to work on what you want, how you want. This depends on what kind of startup and also what stage it's in. In our case, my partner and I are still in the mode of trying to break away from consulting work to develop our own products.
- tx 18y agoWith all due respect, I am growing a bit tired of deliberate avoiding startup pitfalls, when we talk about them here on HN. Yes, I much prefer working in a small company for all these glorified (and popular here) reasons but it doesn't mean startups are good for everybody. In fact I believe startups do not appeal to real hackers, guys who we quote and admire. My limited personal experience confirms this too: smart people I know work at IBM, Motorola, Google and Microsoft and they're HAPPY. And this is why: Let's face it: in a startup, most often than not you're working on something trivial, technically simple, something that can be "released often, released early". Some minor "incremental improvement", and you've got PG books saying "it's OK". At a startup you (most probably) will be working on something that most of your friends will call "stupid shit" behind your back. Let's not pretend this elephant isn't there. There are exceptions to every rule, but it's a rule nevertheless. And this is something I miss the most: an opportunity to work on hard problems, not necessarily even succeeding: this is why startups almost never try. And this is why my ideal "exit strategy" is to cash out (some day) and spend my days in academia. Wow... This was very sudden (even for me) and perhaps misplaced rant.
- pg 18y agoThere seems a bit of a contradiction here. You say that real hackers wouldn't work on startups-- that the really smart people are in academia. And yet a large percentage of the CS faculty at MIT and Stanford have done or are doing startups. There's a joke that you can't get tenure at Stanford without having done a startup. You're also confusing exploratory programming with doing trivial work. Making a quick version 1 and then iterating works for both big and small problems. It just depends how long you keep iterating. It's true that a lot of the work you do in startups is crap work, and that a lot of startups only take on trivial problems. But this is also true in research.
- tx 18y agoPerhaps I haven't framed my confusion into a proper verbal frame, but there were quite a few books in my life screaming "try this!", and I was unable to find time/application for them in this crazy-fast pace of startup life. Startups I worked in were all hungry, fast and aggressive predators, consuming other people's code (open source), other people's research, algorithms and even ideas for products. I haven't been inside of something genuinely new, let alone doing my own, truly mine, thing. What I've done, and companies I was a part of, was just that - a bunch of incremental improvements based on 4-6 months release cycle. How can I be not sad about that?
- timr 18y agoNearly every scientist I know is doing "a bunch of incremental improvements based on a 4-6 month release cycle". They just call the results of the releases "publications".
- dbrush 18y ago"I haven't been inside of something genuinely new, let alone doing my own, truly mine, thing." That is why what you're saying here and in the above is a rant rather than advice. "You've gotta try, because if you haven't tried then you haven't lived."
- gruseom 18y agoI haven't been inside of something genuinely new, let alone doing my own, truly mine, thing. Sounds like that's what you're really sad about, and with reason. Doing something you don't want isn't any more fun at a startup than elsewhere. It might even be less fun since startups are more intense. You're right that startups don't solve this problem, but they don't cause it either. We cause it ourselves by not doing what we really want to do. I struggle with this myself. "Make something people want" isn't the axiom to invoke here. "Do something you want" is more like it. Gruntwork is inevitable, but when you're doing something that is truly your own thing, it doesn't feel so bad; the connection to what you care about is much closer at hand.
- ivankirigin 18y agoI've been exposed to the robotics academic world in depth. Even academics I know are growing tired of the academic mode of work. There is a persistent and growing respect for making real and complete systems. This it often antithetical to the unit of academic progress: published results. A great test for whether you have a real system is whether you can sell it. That's why iRobot is so awesome. They make robots that people actually use. Make something people want :)
- pg 18y agoTrevor's a case in point. As far as I can tell, he's ahead of pretty much everyone on walking algorithms.
- ivankirigin 18y agoHe is definitely very far advanced, but academics still make very good walking robots. http://www.msl.ri.cmu.edu/projects/actuator/ http://www.msl.ri.cmu.edu/projects/actuator/ http://www.rhex.net/ http://www.rhex.net/ Some other efforts that come to mind help illustrate the territory. Honda made a horribly unscalable walking mechanism in the ASIMO. It will never be more than PR. The best work from CMU & MIT's Leg Lab got spun out into Boston Dynamics. You've probably seen their "big dog" video. http://www.bostondynamics.com/content/sec.php?section=BigDog http://www.bostondynamics.com/content/sec.php?section=BigDog Boston Dynamics is part boutique research firm and part startup. They'll probably be the first to sell a walking robot. Honda makes a clunker, and the hungry, small companies make something that will actually work.
- dbrush 18y agoI read a recent Popular Science article where it says Trevor helped with the unicycle motorcycle. This article here is essentially what it said in the Popular Science article; so it seems Trevor is quite the go-to guy when it comes to these types of things. http://www.motorcyclemojo.com/articles/the-uno/ http://www.motorcyclemojo.com/articles/the-uno/ * Not disagreeing, just supplementing
- SwellJoe 18y agoMy limited personal experience confirms this too: smart people I know work at IBM, Motorola, Google and Microsoft and they're HAPPY. Selection bias is funny that way. But, I do know several famously good hackers (four, to be precise), and while three of them work with no equity for a mid-stage startup and the fourth works for Canonical, which seems sort of startup-y, none have ever started startups independently.
- edw519 18y agoNice rant, tx. Now let me tell you why is does NOT resonate at all with me. I do not think that what we read about here at hn is a random sample of "hackerdom" in the world today. I think that my background is probably much closer to that. I have done work for over 80 companies, only a few were in the software business. Most did something else and needed some form of IT to do it. I have sat in the worst of cubicles, attended the most lame meetings, and worked on mind-numbingly boring "projects". Just last week I rewrote a 16 year old batch program that was taking 25 minutes to run. I found 12 unresolved bugs; the program has 25% LOC and runs in 3 minutes. My experience may not be the norm for everyone here, but this project has been the norm for me. The only time I have ever worked on something interesting was either as a contractor with the clout to change the agenda or as an independent software producer providing a solution I already knew they needed. In my experience, the state of application software in small, midsize, and enterprise businesses is stunningly deplorable. These people desperately need good software and don't know where to find it and have no clue how to produce it themselves. Maybe you don't think that call center apps that get the agent off the phone in 2 minutes, accounting apps that deliver exactly the info that management needs, or an inventory app that actually allows you to change a SKU are "big problems", but I do. While so many are working on a realistic robot, a social network, or a rocket to Saturn, somebody has to stick around and grab the low hanging fruit that's everywhere. Then I come to a forum like this where the thinking is "Just Do It" (sorry Nike) and it puts me in the perfect mindset to do what I've always wanted. hn is the antecdote to corporate malaise. jl said, "I want to give other people a better opportunity than I had in my professional career." I say, "I want to give myself a better opportunity than I have had in my professional career." None of this was available as recently as 10 years ago. But now, thanks to modern technology and hn style thinking, I can turn all the little wrongs I've seen over the years into my "big problems" to work on. I'm doing a startup in order to work on what I want. </rantResponse>
- gruseom 18y agoBravo.
- hello_moto 18y agoI don't want to sound negative, but that sentence can also be reversed: "I can't work well with other people. Therefore, I must choose wisely whom I should work with..." For sure, most of the time you're the only person you can work well with. At a big company, you learn how to work with other people whether they're considered "match" or "not-match" with you. It's a life-lesson how to treat people regardless their attitude. I'm currently working at a startup that is owned by someone else. I'm still stuck working on whatever my boss asked me to do, and however my boss wants it.
- culley 18y agopsst... I work at a large corporation. I choose who I work with. I choose my own projects. I work 40 hours a week for a good salary. I have good health care (in America). I do have to describe my projects in terms that matter to my corporation, but how is that any different than pitching to VCs?