6 ms·
> Arguments like these try to shift away the spotlight from big companies who collectively make up a large chunk of the greenhouse gas emissions to individuals.
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> Arguments like these try to shift away the spotlight from big companies who collectively make up a large chunk of the greenhouse gas emissions to individuals.
This is the key problem, with “eat local” and all similar initiatives.
Yes, reducing emissions by tiny percentages is still a good thing. But too often, by focusing the conversation on these small individual actions, we miss the forest for the trees.
- tdeck 6y agoAgreed. I don't know what year that tweet is from, but I can't believe we're still being told by the UN that we can beat climate change by "unplugging unused appliances" when what we really need is a major shift from industry/ It's the same kind of blame-shifting propaganda that we've seen for decades about single-use packaging: https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-perspec-indian-crying-environment-ads-pollution-1123-20171113-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-perspec...
- ebg13 6y ago> I don't know what year that tweet is from Oct 27, 2019. So not long ago.
- rvense 6y agoThe electronics shop across the street has its display windows lit all night, with two or three giant TV screens telling the (very few) passers-by to buy a Google Home so they can talk to their smart light bulbs, or whatever. Maybe, just maybe, we could stop that before telling me to unplug my phone charger or switch off my router at night.
- Brian_K_White 6y agoYou know tv's aren't lit by incandescent bulbs right? Find some other punching bag to help you excuse yourself from whatever little things might otherwise be your part, if not "phone chargers", that one was a flop.
- gen220 6y agoDuring the California drought, my mom put an hourglass in her shower, to help save water for the state. But in the Central Valley, they didn’t stop watering almond trees. She stopped watering her shrubs, while farms were purchasing secondhand oil drilling equipment in a race to the bottom of the water table. It’s like our federal budget: when times our tough, we “tighten our belts” by cutting basic research or education funding from 5% to 2%, but won’t flinch at spending >50% of discretionary budget on “defense”.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoAlmond trees last 20-25 years and take 4 years to bear fruit. Saving almond trees during a drought would be an excellent use of the Central Valley's water supplies. Short-lived water-intensive crops like rice and alfalfa, on the other hand, we could have done without. You would think that this would mean that the almond farmers would simply buy water from any rice farmers who had seniority in their water rights. Hahahahahahhahahaha, you fool! That would make sense, so it's illegal. Also, if an alfalfa farmer who did get water didn't use it all (in the name of conservation, perhaps) they'd lose access to that water forever.
- tdeck 6y agoAlmond farmers are sucking water out of the Central Valley aquifers faster than it can be replaced, even in a rainy year. The problem is there's no limit on drilling and pumping. IIUC riparian rights are handled differently in the western US than they have been traditionally elsewhere, leading to a race to deplete the shared resource before it's all gone.
- gen220 6y agoThere’s a nice planet money episode about this: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/425392169 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/425392169
- gen220 6y agoIt’s a good point, about almond trees. I’m not doubting that it made the “most” sense in the moment. I guess I’m more distressed by how we ended up specializing in such water intensive crops, in a valley with a severe and worsening, decades-long water shortage! Within a few decades, there won’t be water left to grow anything... I’m not generally interventionist, but I think the markets have failed us here (unless I’m severely misunderstanding things, please correct me). I‘m all for almonds and rice, but we really should be taxing the externalities. I’m pessimistic we’ll ever get to that equilibrium. But yeah. All this focusing on consumer water use is a distraction. We need to have an honest discussion about how the agriculture water system should be architected, so the state can continue to be productive for generations to come.
- BurningFrog 6y agoTo me, this idea that I personally can change global problems with my individual decisions seems like a form of Delusion of Grandeur. On another level, I think we all want to feel like we're doing something to address the major problems of our time. And these things are something.
- frabbit 6y agoWhile I agree that a single person reducing their meat and gasoline consumption means nothing, a single person not reducing said consumption probably makes things worse. Why? Because it can become a personal spur towards getting something meaningful done: which means collective political action to completely upend the out of control machine we are refusing to fix. By all means, deprecate gesture politics, but only if you are doing something else more meaningful. Otherwise it comes close to being triple-layered hypocrisy.
- jakear 6y agoI think it’s about the network effects. Your not eating meat won’t make a difference, but if you tell people about it and why and the idea spreads, collectively you all might make a difference. This is why these sorts of people tend to be known as liking to talk about their lifestyle choices. They know they don’t mean much, but if they convince 5 people and they all convince 5 more, etc, it will spread faster than some viruses we might be familiar with.
- shafyy 6y agoI agree. But in the end, we need to make products that are better overall than their "polluting" counterparts. For example, for many a Tesla is a better car, regardless if it's better for the environment. We need to get there with food, too. E.g., can producers like Impossible and Beyond make burgers that are tastier, healthier and cheaper than their meat counterparts? I think they can, and in the end the masses will only change their behavior with products and services like this. Of course, we still need action on a political and economic level such as a carbon tax.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beloch 6y agoMissing the forest for the trees is a very human thing to do. The real problem is that we stubbornly ignore the forest even when we know its there. e.g. Many environmentalists think that, if we can just stop building pipelines, fuel will become more expensive and people (usually other, poorer people) will drive less. This attitude helped prevent a key pipeline in Canada (Energy East) from being built. This pipeline would have sent oil from Western Canada to Eastern Canada, which currently imports a significant portion of it's oil by tanker from foreign countries. Now Alberta oil is being shipped West, put on panamax tankers in Vancouver, sailed through the Panama Canal, and then up to the East coast of Canada. There it is bought for the same prices as foreign oil by Canadian refineries. All that's happened is some oil companies are making less money per barrel because of transport expenses. This wasteful route hasn't impacted fuel prices in Eastern Canada at all. The forest in this case, is that people need to buy smaller, more efficient vehicles or EV's, and build communities that require less driving. However, I have no doubt that I will get an earful from someone for daring to suggest that an oil pipeline could be a good thing for the environment. To be clear, I am specifically saying that the Energy East pipeline would have been more environmentally friendly than shipping oil from Western to Eastern Canada via the Panama canal. Too much of popular environmentalism is utterly unscientific and harmful to the environment. It's not just the "eat local" fad.
- graeme 6y ago> All that's happened is some oil companies are making less money per barrel because of transport expenses. This reduces fuel supply, shifting the supply curve left. Ceteris paribus, this increases the world price for fuel.
- beloch 6y agoThe slight change in world oil prices is entirely due to the cost of burning fuel to transport oil around a continent. There is literally no upside here.
- graeme 6y agoFuel costs are well under 100% of transport costs. Well, well under. This says 20-40%, and ship costs are not the only costs associated with transport, so it’s an even smaller fraction of total cost. https://www.morethanshipping.com/imo-2020-and-oil-prices-in-shipping/ https://www.morethanshipping.com/imo-2020-and-oil-prices-in-... Moreover, the total energy being transported is surely much higher than the oil burned. That’s the key feature of oil....it is energy dense!