3 ms·
This will change when we can spin up whole human bodies for experimentation and discard them at will. We need to clone decephalized humans. Turn off neural pla
by echelon 6y ago
This will change when we can spin up whole human bodies for experimentation and discard them at will.
We need to clone decephalized humans. Turn off neural plate development. Downregulate genes that cause brain development. Before we get this right we can supplement it with surgical techniques to ensure the clones never have brains and never become sentient. Hook the embryos up to artificial life support that innervate heart, lungs, and replace hormonal signalling.
We could have a facility full of live, brainless monoclonal humans. We could perform research that wasn't previously possible due to ethics and invasiveness.
As a side benefit, we now have a limitless blood and organ supply for transplantation. Ideally without any antigens that react with transplant patients, guaranteeing transplant recipients never need to take quality of life-altering immunosuppressants.
If we can treat real human bodies like lab rats, we'll conquer every cancer and have a real chance of doubling human healthspan.
We have to get out of "punch card" phase biology. Unfortunately, it'll require wading out into uncomfortable new frontiers that many won't be happy to broach. This requires that you accept that there is no soul, that humans are code, and that we are now the authors.
If I ever get Elon Musk money, I'm doing this.
- d_silin 6y agoBioethiticists will have a field day with you. Also multiple angry mobs from left, right and center.
- heisbsissi 6y agoThat's why that company when it exists will happen in China. God help us all.
- echelon 6y agoThere's absolutely nothing wrong with what I've proposed. Typically only people that believe in a soul or that humans "should die" take issue. Neither of these is correct in my world view. I can understand the religious perspective, but the romantic idea that limited live spans are good is incredibly twisted. I think people should be immortal, but that's just not feasible. The next best thing is using all of the tools around us to extend our lives as much as possible. I'm tired of biology being so punch-card slow while the compiler is literally staring us in the face. The human is the perfect model organism for everything we want to accomplish, and I've shown that we can ethically build upon it as a platform without harming anyone. Moreover, we can farm it. Never deal with blood or organ shortages, end immunosuppressants for many people, and potentially perform purely regenerative surgeries. A human grown in a lab without a brain is a plant. Dogs, apes, and octopuses are more human than that. Before you fight me, go take on the many acts of animal cruelty in the world. The people that would hold this back are Luddites. This is a faster path to curing cancer. All fifty thousand types of it. edit: Down voters, why not argue your point instead? Because from my perspective your views are a dated death wish.
- dekhn 6y agoTHere definitely are a number of things "wrong" with what you've proposed. The first is that society simply wouldn't accept it; by the time people learned what you were doing, the government would make laws against it. People really are averse to growing brainless humans in vats for medical experimention and spare parts. I'm not interested in "fighting" you,but the reality is that you're starting from a non-starter position that would never fly in the larger general public. It's not worth debating, because you're absolutely, totally convinced that you're right. Most of us here agree that in principle it would be great to be able to run experiments that truly address human medical problems without ethical concern, but I think "decephalized humans" don't really qualify.
- TomMarius 6y agoWhere is the line? Is it okay to use human stem cells for experimentation? Is it okay to grow whole organs for replacement? Is it okay to grow muscles, ears, skin, eyes, bones...? Why is not okay to grow them all at once? I don't see any difference. All of this literally is "decephalized humans", just with more modification/specialization and a simpler process. We're even growing brain tissue that exhibits actual human-like brain waves for experimentation - how is that okay with you!?
- echelon 6y ago> non-starter position that would never fly in the larger general public At one point in time the majority of the general public was against gay marriage. Two hundred years ago many were pro slavery. Everyone used to be against cutting up dead bodies so we could learn how they worked, so it was conducted in secrecy. Most people are illiterate about the science behind this. The benefits are real and substantial. This isn't a money grab or vanity project - it pushes humanity forward a notch, and it should be done. Anti-vax, anti-GMO, anti-scientific thought shouldn't prevent us from developing a tool that saves countless lives.
- TomMarius 6y agoWell, many people disagree, so I'd like to voice my support. Maybe more of us should team up in a chat room.
- shoyer 6y agoWhat makes you think that (1) that it’s even possible to create such beings, (2) that these would even be good disease models or (3) a lack of model organisms is the main factor holding back medical breakthroughs? None of these is at all obvious...
- echelon 6y ago1. It'll be an incredibly difficult engineering task with many large hurdles. But it's possible, because life found its solution in us. We culture human cells all the time, just like bacteria or plants - this is just a higher structure. In fact, you can think of this entire process like growing humans as plants. 2. We spend a lot of time "humanizing" model organisms by creating chimeras. But even then the results are frequently not portable. How many animal studies fail to make the jump to advanced clinical trials? 3. A human is the system you want to study. It has the same genome, the same transcriptome, the same proteome, the same metabolome, and the same kinetics and thermodynamics. Animal models are 17th century dentistry in comparison.
- strogonoff 6y agoPlacebo research and documented cases of physiological diseases treated via mental health therapy puts in question the viability of using theoretical human-like creatures that possess no consciousness, and therefore no mental state to speak of. To draw an analogy, this would introduce such a huge gap between “staging” and “prod” environments that the effort and the ethical risk of ending up with “staging” entities possessing any degree of human consciousness cannot even remotely be worth it. (I’m somewhat alarmed that I feel the need to spell that out.)
- echelon 6y ago> Placebo research and documented cases of physiological diseases treated via mental health therapy How is cancer something you can fix with mental health therapy? Tell them to go home and feel better, that it'll all be over soon? What about a host of other genetic and immune disorders, many of which can be fatal? I don't mean to come across as harsh or mocking, but there are a host of diseases where your solution does not work. > I’m somewhat alarmed that I feel the need to spell that out I understand your argument, but I reject it because I don't think we're seeing the same picture of where things now stand or could be. I'll counter with an analogy of my own. Right now we're attempting to fix issues in prod by looking at another company's software, decompiling it, bit fiddling a bit, then trying to hot patch it into our own production instance. We run some smoke tests before releasing things, but these can't always identify long-term effects. I want to have an actual honest to god dev and staging environment. Not just that, but a system that looks remarkably like prod that we can burn down and spin up on demand for each investigator trying to solve novel problems. We can actually test at scale (and duration!) and pick apart the system to see that no part of it goes into failure mode or disease state. Development goes much faster when you have an actual dev kit to run your code on or tear apart. We don't have anything like that right now. I get that the notion that human beings being equated to fungible software or disposable hunks of meat is uncomfortable. But the special ingredient in both you and me is consciousness, and this design ensures we never bring new consciousness to life. We turn off the gene expression that causes the brain to develop, and we can double down with mechanical amputation. It sounds macabre, but so too did dissecting cadavers a century ago.