7 ms·
U.S. Population Growth Has Been Driven Exclusively by Minorities
- someusername99 6y agoThe referenced report is much more informative https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-census-data-shows-the-nation-is-diversifying-even-faster-than-predicted/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-census-data-shows-the...
- H8crilA 6y agoImmigration is the ultimate get-out-of-jail-free card when it comes to deflation. Just ask the Europeans or even more so - the immigration hostile Japanese (yes, I know Abe is turning things around, this is an oversimplification). It's amazing how it is basically impossible to influence birth rates, one way or the other, up or down. I am yet to find a convincing example of a concerted effort at increasing or suppressing birth rates by a centralised authority. Please share one if you know it, I find birth rates to be far more mysterious than any other commonly talked about "macro" rates, such as riskfree rates or various risk premiums.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> I am yet to find a convincing example of a concerted effort at increasing or suppressing birth rates by a centralised authority. China suppressed its birth rate with its one child policy.
- H8crilA 6y agoNo it didn't, have you ever looked at the charts? They had the "Chinese Boomers" which were naturally followed by "Chinese Millennials". And then in 2015 the policy was abandoned but the birth rate has not bulged at all.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoHere is an article comparing China with India population growth. http://m.statisticstimes.com/demographics/china-vs-india-population.php http://m.statisticstimes.com/demographics/china-vs-india-pop... You can see that China bends the curve compared to India.
- whycombagator 6y ago> No it didn't, have you ever looked at the charts? What charts?
- H8crilA 6y agoFertility/birth rates. A reminder - one child policy was introduced in 1979 and repelled in 2015, neither of those dates had any visible effect: Fertility rate: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNTFRTINCHN https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNTFRTINCHN Birth rate: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNCBRTINCHN https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNCBRTINCHN And it is not like the Chinese govt didn't try, they were serious about it. It's just that birth rates are mysterious. People will have kids when they want to, and will stop having kids when they want to, and they will listen to nobody. No authority.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoThe policy existed but, after talking with some Chinese friends about this very topic, they said the system was corrupt. Anyone who want to get around the system just had to bribe a local official, and there were zero consequences. Take this as anecdotal, of course.
- bilbo0s 6y agoIt wasn't even a bribe, It was worse than that. It was literally, "You can only have one child unless you pay for each extra child you want." I mean, getting around the policy, was actually written into the policy. Which is kind of insane if the purpose was to control birth rates.
- booleandilemma 6y agoBut wouldn't even require paying for extra children discourage people from having children?
- astronautjones 6y agoaren't you doing that by having children anywhere?
- orwin 6y agoWait, it's not that simple. Depending on where you were working and living, the policy was different. National-level, f you worked for the government (military, healthcare, PCC) you weren't allowed to have more than one child without loosing your job (if you were grunt-level) or paying and having your career path stilled (if you were CO-level). For other workers, it was more or less a "state-level" implementation with governors deciding how to enforce the rule. In most places, farmers had the right to have two children and could ask to have one more. City workers only one and had to pay different amount depending on the city and the governor for the second. Some governors were really, really hard on enforcement (forced abortion...) while other were more lax and made people pay acceptable amount for the second child. Still, even without hard enforcement, the illegal child have no paper, cannot join legal school and isn't present on the family register (and can't work/live anywhere legally). This is one of the 3 internal problem the Chinese government will have with the generation.
- Leary 6y agohttps://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/12063/production/_104772837_china_birthrate-nc.png https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/12063/production... China's birthrate did decline with the one child policy (1979). But it declined way more in the decade prior to the introduction of the one child policy. "晚、稀、少" : “late marriage, longer spacing, and fewer children” was a little known policy introduced in 1970 that encouraged late marriage and fewer births, and which had way bigger effects than the compulsory one child policy.
- kiba 6y agoWe could increase population growth if we increase longevity and health of the population to compensate for lower birthrate, while saving money on medical expenses.
- pcurve 6y agoYou can't cheat the math though. 2 people need to give birth to 2 kids to break even. (2.1 actually).
- gpm 6y agoYou can't, to be charitable I would assume that they are doing their math in kids/(person years) instead of kids/person.
- sir_bearington 6y agoThis actually exacerbates the problem of lower birth rates. Longer life expectancy mean an even greater portion of the population is non-working and dependent on the shrinking share of working-age people. If people worked a greater portion of their lifespan that could compensate for lower birthrates but increasing retirement ages is extremely unpopular.
- gpm 6y agoI would interpret "longevity and health" not just to mean increased life expectancy but to also mean increased time until you are infirm. This expands the percentage of your life that you produce more than you consume (i.e. 20 to when you become infirm for the average person), and decreases the percentage of your productivity that goes towards raising children (since you have more overall productivity but roughly the same amount goes to raising kids).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fairenough42 6y agoTangential question: why is deflation "jail"? As a follow on, is deflation caused by a declining population different from deflation caused by a sudden recession?
- vkou 6y agoDeflation is terrible for the economic system that we live in. In a deflationary economy, the value of money goes up, as time passes. This means that people with money have zero incentive to spend, or invest it. Hypothetically, you could adopt an economic system that would not be affected by deflation, but until you do, it's best to avoid tangling with it.
- fairenough42 6y agoFrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Effects, it sounds like it would _increase_ the incentive to lend, but would decrease the incentive to _borrow_. Inflation, conversely, seems to decrease the incentive to lend (the inflation-adjusted return is less than the nominal rate). Naively, it's not clear to me why the latter is better for the economic system we live in (would that be free-market captialism? or something else?). Can you elaborate? Either way, both of these seem different from eliminating the incentive to loan or borrow. People know how to consider inflation-adjusted rates of return and invest accordingly. Soon these same lessons will be applied in negative interest rate scenarios, which I guess counts as deflation.
- unishark 6y agoWell if the value of money is going down then the price of everything else goes up (land, stocks, precious metals). The incentive is to convert cash into these alternatives. Seems to me the same is true for borrowers. Borrowing money to buy land/stocks/etc is still a smart move as long as they keep trending upwards faster than the loan rates. Of course this requires sufficiently low interest rates be available, which is where the reference "our system" comes in I suppose, with a federal reserve maintaining artificially-low rates to drive this wealth transfer from savings to borrowers. This is just the sideshow of wealth moving around, of course. I don't really buy that that if this game ended it means the death of the entire economy. It's just the part that can be subjected to manipulation. Obviously the point of earning money in the first place is to spend it, not just save or transfer it from one medium to another. Money is just an exchange itself. In deflation, things get cheaper and supply-and-demand curves says more people will buy things.
- 47r7ruur 6y agoThis would seem more credible for evaluating the US if most states with high minority populations didn't give a disproportionate amount of support to minorities. If you make minimal effort to prevent immigration and you give most family support to minorities then of course minorities will be your main high growth population. Non-racially targeted support is made increasingly difficult by the environmentalist doom cult that believes growth is bad but which can't attack support for minorities because race trumps environmentalism in US politics. It's about as mysterious as a company with more investors growing faster than its competitors, sometimes the underdog wins but capital is usually king.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 6y agoHungary has managed to significantly move birth rates with incentives: https://ifstudies.org/blog/is-hungary-experiencing-a-policy-induced-baby-boom https://ifstudies.org/blog/is-hungary-experiencing-a-policy-....
- yread 6y agoThere is some signal but I wouldn't call it significant and it's not sure whether it was caused by the incentives. Surely, if it was that clear cut they wouldn't have to write a 2000+ words article
- amiga_500 6y agoIt quickly becomes a pyramid scheme based on ever looser credit to ramp ever scarcer housing, if no additional action is taken to address the need for ever more youth to prop up pension obligations. Which then further suppresses family formation.
- msarvar 6y agoChina currently doing birth suppression on their Muslim minorities. https://apnews.com/269b3de1af34e17c1941a514f78d764c https://apnews.com/269b3de1af34e17c1941a514f78d764c I don't know if this will be successful long term, but they're definitely trying and it seems to be working.
- jobigoud 6y agoWhat I've read about this news is that they are now applying to Uighurs the same birth restrictions policies that were already in place for every other group including Hans. Previously the minorities actually had exemptions. Not to condone any other behavior of the CCP but this news is being misrepresented a lot in headlines.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoUsually when a government attempts to change birth rates in the way you are imagining it is pro-natalist because more people magnifies the power of a state and increases the revenue for a government. The big exception to this is China's one child policy. That had an ultimately minor effect as birth rates were already dropping and stayed low when the policy was lifted. One of the most infamous pro-natalist examples was Romania under Ceausescu. https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/ceausescus-forgotten-children-closing-last-romanias-communist-era-orphanages-1581371 https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/ceausescus-forgotten-children-clos... Another oppressive pro-natalist policy was pursued by the Islamic government of Iran in the 1980s. It ended in tears though as Iranian women did not see the sense in birthing children to be cannon fodder in the Iran-Iraq war. What followed was the steepest drop in birthrates ever recorded. So the government did influence the birthrate, but not in the intended direction. France and Hungary have had limited success with more humane pro-natalist policies. However, there is a proven and highly effective way for governments to reduce birthrates. Educate women. That is actually the main driver of falling birthrates worldwide.
- mech422 6y agoThe most famous one I'm aware of is the 'one child policy'[0] Though there seems to be debate on how effective it was. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy
- alecco 6y ago> It's amazing how it is basically impossible to influence birth rates, one way or the other, up or down. What are you talking about? Look at the differences in those countries/cultures and you'll find it. It's just that it's verboten for us in this contemporary Western culture. But perhaps the artificial womb will change things.
- fatcatdogfat 6y agoI dont have any reference to support this, I think Thomas Sowell or someone else on one of the Hoover Institutes youtube videos, said this, Israel is the only first world country that does not rely on immigration to support population growth, so i would assume all other first world countries population growth is due to minority immigration
- mc32 6y ago? I guess it depends on what you classify as immigration. Israel has depended on a far flung diaspora returning, but I don’t know the numbers, so I’d prefer to see native born growth versus “returnees”.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoIsrael’s Jewish fertility rate and Arab fertility rate are in a dead heat at 3.05.
- mc32 6y agoI had no idea -that's quite amazing in an advanced economy (as most are aware). I'm sure Singapore is jealous. They've been trying for ages to get their pop to grow internally but always fall short.
- javaIsGreat 6y agoI was surprised to see that many of the eastern European/Russian immigrants moving to Israel over the last 40 years don't supply any evidence of Jewish heritage (i know USSR and other European countries discriminated against Jews so it would make sense that there are a lot of Jews who don't really have the papers to prove it for a few generations). An article I read said many French jews immigrated to Israel (due to rather recent French anti-semitism sentiment) but immigrated back to Europe once economic advancement for them wasn't attained. Looks like Israeli society has had kind of an open door policy to Europeans who are able to attain employment (i assume in the tech scene there).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoOne thing to keep in mind is that “white” many times absorbs the other populations. In the past, for example, Italians and other Southern Europes were not considered “white”. Now they are. Add to that intermarriages, and likely the proportion of people who identify as “white” will be likely be constant or grow in the future.
- sir_bearington 6y agoThis is an important point, especially with respect to the Hispanic population. It's often referred to as a race, when it's more like a cultural category - individual Hispanic people often identify as white, indigenous, or black though racial identity tends to be more fluid due to greater historic rates of intermarriage. I come from a Hispanic family, my grandparents more or less exclusively speak Spanish. My parents who were born a couple years after my grandparents immigrated would only be recognized as Hispanic if they made that part of their identity known. If I were asked to identify myself racially I'd say white, not Hispanic. I see myself as Cuban-Americans not as a racial identity buy as an ancestry - the same way people are Irish-American or German-American. 65% of Hispanics in the US identify as white: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispanic_and_Latino_Americans#Race https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispanic_and_Latino_Americans#...
- Balgair 6y agoI would not be surprised if by the 2060s (40 years, ~2 generations) that Asian Americans and Hispanic Americans get rolled up into being 'white'. Rates of intermarriage between groups seem to be on the rise [0] though Hispanic data is not well represented in my quick googling. More hopefully, people will simply not care and diversity will be celebrated, not denigrated as we've awoken to since George Floyd. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interracial_marriage_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interracial_marriage_in_the_Un...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I would not be surprised if by the 2060s (40 years, ~2 generations) that Asian Americans and Hispanic Americans get rolled up into being 'white'. Hispanics are predominantly White by the standards by which race has any meaning at all (though also several other races are represented), Hispanic is an ethnic rather than racial category. > Hispanic data is not well represented in my quick googling. It's not going to show up in data on race because it's not a race. > More hopefully, people will simply not care and diversity will be celebrated, not denigrated as we've awoken to since George Floyd. The people marching in parades with Confederate flags haven't awoken to anything. And each of America's periodic awakening on this issue has been accompanied by exactly that kind of reaction and a hardening of White supremacist ideology. It may be a shrinking minority each time, but it's also increasingly committed, or at least renewing it's commitment each time.
- bergstromm466 6y ago> Census data indicate White population has shrunk since 2010 Why is this the first bullet point? Why a focus on White people? Why do you care HN? The only other place I see stuff like this is when it’s used as an alt-right talking point, or by white-supremacist mass-shooters who write about ‘The Great Replacement’ [1] [1] https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/white-supremacist-great-replacement/ https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/white-supremacist-...
- crocodiletears 6y agoBack in high-school, I had a (white) history teacher that made it a whole unit in her class. Her thesis was that white people were the only thing in America holding back progress, and that when the US was majority minority we'd reach an inflection point where 'we' (progressives) would be able to implement policies that might absolve the country of its sins, and tied it all into the MLK arc of history quote. Looking back now, I can't help but wonder if it didn't drive a few of my classmates to some of the more reactionary and racist politics on the right.
- magicsmoke 6y agoReal or not, perceived persecution gives one hell of a dopamine rush.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI had two of those. One was particularly fixated on how the Japanese were going to bury us. They don't call it "the long march through the institutions" for nothing. The idea that one should get into a position of power to teach a select portion of children that, because of their ancestry, they have a sin for which they must work their whole lives to atone for does call for a reaction. At least with the religious, you can be saved by Jesus or whatever, but for this group, you are always guilty, by virtue of your skin color.
- rayiner 6y agoThis is the progressive “demographic destiny” fever dream. Non-whites aren’t that progressive. For example, non-whites are much more religious than whites. Just 35% of white people say that belief in God is “necessary to be moral” versus 55% of Hispanic people and 63% of black people. That’s particularly remarkable because the median white person is 42 the median black person is 30, and the median Hispanic person is just 28. Religious belief increases with age, so black and Hispanic people in the age groups that vote heavily are likely even more religious compared to whites. Hispanic people, meanwhile, are quite conservative on criminal justice issues. They are consistently more conservative than white people when it comes to ending things like mandatory minimums for drug crimes. Again, this is remarkable considering the age distributions. It’s very interesting to look at polls of Hispanic people’s’ opinions with respect to policing and the George Floyd protests: https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/7msyzunum9/tabs_HP_Police_Reform_20200608.pdf https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/7msyzunum9/tabs_HP_Police_Reform... 8% of both Hispanic and white people say the system needs “no improvements” compared to 3% of black people. Just 21 and 22% of Hispanic people and white people, respectively, say the police system is “not sound” and “needs significant changes” versus 45% of black people. On nearly every policing issue, Hispanic people are a bit more liberal than white people, but I’m not even sure that difference would remain if accounting for age differences. On the economic front, asians and Hispanics are close to white people in capitalism versus socialism, with just about a third of each group supporting socialism: https://www.cato.org/blog/59-americans-have-favorable-views-capitalism-59-have-unfavorable-views-socialism https://www.cato.org/blog/59-americans-have-favorable-views-.... Again, an interesting result given that support for socialism goes down significantly with age, and both Hispanics and Asians are significantly younger than whites. Right now, a lot of conservative people of color are forced into a coalition with increasingly radical white progressives due to real and perceived Republican racism. When that pressure disappears, I think you’ll see a reshuffling of the coalitions. I can already see the seeds of this happening. My parents are Bangladeshi immigrants. They’ve voted Democrat in every selection since they became naturalized citizens. They voted for Hilary Clinton not because she was the lesser of two evils, but because they liked her. They’re the people who overturned the Sanders/Warren applecart when they got around to tuning into the Democratic primary. My mom explained to me today what she thinks makes America great. “You can drive to an intersection at 1 am and if there is a red light, people will stop. Even if the streets are totally empty, people will stop and wait for the green light.” She is worried about the protests and said “if we aren’t going to have law and order in America why shouldn’t I go back to Bangladesh?” My dad is the more progressive of the two. He’s a Clinton Democrat who likes that Bill cherry picked the best parts of the Republican agenda. He is alarmed at the Warren/Sanders wing and was very nervous when everyone thought Biden was done. His take on the idea that billionaires shouldn’t exist: “that’s stupid.” He’s upset that people are lobbying to change the name of the high school I went to (Thomas Jefferson in Virginia). But he is convinced that the Clinton/Biden/Obama camp will hold, and says “America is an established country, you won’t see radical change.”
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- voisin 6y agoYou could increase population growth by not screwing millennials at every step of their life. If housing, school, food, cars didn’t cost substantially more in inflation adjusted dollars than it did for their parents, or if their incomes at least caught up to inflation.
- alecco 6y agoA culture of hedonism and postponing starting a family to your 30s is way more significant. I'm not against it, but an extended adolescence has its social consequences.
- voisin 6y agoAre you suggesting millennials are choosing to delay household and family formation in favour of hedonism?
- aaomidi 6y agoThe typical boomer view on life. While they made enough money to pay for school by delivering pizza. Warren Buffet made serious amount of cash as a high schooler delivering news papers.
- alecco 6y agoAd-hominem. And misdirected, I'm far from a boomer. How many women want to start a family on their early 20s? How many women start working on that only when getting close to 30?
- ajurna 6y agoso it's womens fault? maybe if pay and conditions were better and they had more stability they would want families earlier.
- danaris 6y agoIn general, taking long-term views toward priorities of incentives would help a great deal, as opposed to the "gotta-meet-next-quarter's-numbers" priorities we have now. I don't know how exactly to get there (I have a variety of ideas about things we should be doing differently as a society, but none that specifically address the level of short-term thinking we are plagued by), but we definitely need to do something about it.
- sys_64738 6y agoWe need immigrants of working age so they can pay taxes to support SSA and Medicare recipients. That's the group who are most conservative and anti-immigration.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/VOxD0 https://archive.is/VOxD0
- wpdev_63 6y agoOne would think with automation on the horizon the government would aggressively curb immigration. The people already here responsibly having children are having a hard enough of a time with the cost of everything.
- aaomidi 6y agoAnother one would think with automation doing most of our jobs. Why can't we share the spoils more?
- unsignedchar 6y agoIs minority a shorthand for not white or black? Why is that the dominant axis for parsing the population growth difference? Is the correlation with racial distribution more pronounced than with other axes, or is this article aimed at people too stupid to understand that people differ in more ways than race?