8 ms·
>So then why so much effort into deciding if it works or not? FUD around masks and their effectiveness is being deliberately spread by people and groups with a
by krapp 6y ago
>So then why so much effort into deciding if it works or not?
FUD around masks and their effectiveness is being deliberately spread by people and groups with a political agenda, primarily through disinformation campaigns on social media. This isn't an entirely organic phenomenon.
- standardUser 6y agoEven the CDC was against mask use by the general public at first, so while much of the naysaying is now political, there was also seemingly legitimate information being pushed by prominent organizations that encouraged people to ignore masks. Also, there's no character limit here, you can write the entire phrase instead of using obscure acronyms.
- krapp 6y ago>Also, there's no character limit here, you can write the entire phrase instead of using obscure acronyms. FUD is no more an obscure acronym than CDC. FFS this is a programming and tech forum, people throw acronyms around all the time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 6y ago...the CDC was against mask use by the general public at first And they too admitted to spreading FUD about masks, in the misguided belief that stopping average people from using masks would leave more masks for the health care providers. That should reinforce the important point that we're dealing with unqualified, clown-show/amateur-hour political appointees in multiple levels of government, making critical decisions, at this point, a point in time, unlike most points, where leadership or it's lack matters. And I know that FUD is just a long-standing acronym for "fear, uncertainty and doubt" and I too could just write that. But being so long-standing, the term not is only convenient but has come mean a particular kind of fear, uncertainty and doubt, that spread through a particular of public relations system.
- jariel 6y agoIt's not clownish, just the opposite. There was a severe shortage of N95's at the time, and if the public thought masks were important, there would have been an unprecedented run on PPE and the medical community would have had squat. Given that masks, particularly N95s are actually effective in a Healthcare environment ... it was the exactly the right call to make. Get the masks to those who it will actually help, not the public for whom it will make a smaller difference. Once production is ramped, or we have enough PPE, then it makes sense to have a pro-mask policy for the public. From a communications perspective, it's obviously problematic, but in terms of equipment triage, it's highly rational and we actually want our leaders making these kinds of tough decisions. The WHO and various governments should have been more efficient in their messaging however.
- KeepFlying 6y agoYeah this is the part of the issue that my social media feed seems to attach to. They post comments from politicians and public figures (and medial professionals) saying early on that we shouldn't wear masks. I'm sad that the original messages didn't come across as the nuanced issue that it is. Hospitals need the N95 stuff because they are exposed at high rates for a long time. Hospitals also educate their staff on proper protocol when wearing a mask so that people don't negate the effectiveness by wearing it wrong or touching their face after removing it. The public isn't educated on proper mask wearing procedure. We don't know how to test that a mask fits properly. We don't have the same training to avoid cross contamination and poor mask hygiene. We don't understand the marginal benefits of masks and how it creates a false sense of security causing us to take more risks and spread the disease more quickly. So at first, it makes perfect sense to funnel the best masks to the highest risk people and encourage "stay at home" (instead of "go outside with a mask") because it limits disease spread the most and protects the community. I'm sad that it has turned in to "but they said masks did nothing" as an excuse to not wear them. It was never that they did nothing, it's that masks ALONE is not enough. Masks and proper behavior are necessary together.
- DanBC 6y ago
- newacct583 6y ago> Even the CDC was against mask use by the general public at first, It. Was. Not. The WHO and CDC both issued guidance that public use of personal protective equipment was a bad idea, for fundamental scarcity reasons. And in both cases the messaging was done poorly in a few spots and could have been interpreted as statement that masks don't work against covid. They were heavily criticized for this at the time, and the criticism was carried by the media. No expert ever told people that masks don't work, or that the public shouldn't wear them. They were telling people to save them for the health care workers! And getting to the point upthread: that bit of misinformation is, again, something being deliberately propagated by people with a political agenda.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dpeck 6y agoPerhaps I’m just dense, but that’s exactly how I would read this tweet from late February: https://mobile.twitter.com/cdcgov/status/1233134710638825473?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/cdcgov/status/1233134710638825473... “ CDC does not currently recommend the use of facemasks to help prevent novel #coronavirus. Take everyday preventive actions, like staying home when you are sick and washing hands with soap and water, to help slow the spread of respiratory illness. ”
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe US Surgeon General, in late February: > Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus... https://twitter.com/surgeon_general/status/1233725785283932160 https://twitter.com/surgeon_general/status/12337257852839321... It's not surprising people got "masks don't work" from that messaging.
- SturgeonsLaw 6y agoYou left off the second half of that tweet in your quote: > but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk!
- karaterobot 6y agoThe guy from Slate Star Codex made a great point about this: Initially, the CDC refused to recommend wearing masks to inhibit virus transmission because there weren't rigorous studies supporting that usage. At the time they must have viewed it as irresponsible to recommend protective measures that weren't properly evidenced. But, the reason there weren't rigorous studies supporting mask usage was not because they don't work, but because nobody was willing to run a study where you exposed half the subjects to a virus without any protection just to prove that masks would help the other half. It's the same reason there aren't any double-blind studies proving that parachutes help you if you fall out of a plane.
- dinglejungle 6y agoArchive link to the referenced post: https://web.archive.org/web/20200415084132/https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/04/14/a-failure-but-not-of-prediction/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200415084132/https://slatestar...
- merpnderp 6y agoThat’s not the primary reason. They selfishly wanted to protect mask supplies for medical use and so spread FUD around public mask usage. It was criminal and people should be held accountable. Masks work for some value and whatever that value is, it accumulates as more people wear masks, and the idiots in charge gave up months of that reduction so that people wouldn’t buy up all the masks at Home Depot. Only they still bought all the masks, and then used the CDC’s own FUD as their own to not wear them and convince everyone else not to wear them.
- paulsutter 6y agoWhen I bought my N95 masks in mid february, every Home Depot has already been cleared out and the masks sent to China where they were valuable. I had to visit 5 stores to buy a few leftover. That was well before the CDC and surgeon general were telling people masks are bad for you don’t buy them. The masks were long gone by then.
- lsiebert 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thoraway3030 6y agoPolitical agenda, or something even more sinister, like an opportunistic foreign adversary? It seems like a lot of the FUD around Covid-19 is deliberately being spread to maximize casualties. The article points out that contrarians, often conservative, promoted mask wearing until the US government reversed its position and said that masks do work. Suddenly, anti-lockdown protests, conspiracy theories and mask objecting started happening, and mask wearing became politically polarizing. It would be interesting to see where these people get their information from...one suspects that the answer will be skewed heavily toward social media.
- standardUser 6y ago"Political agenda, or something even more sinister..." I think the simplest explanation is that the conservative right now views literally every issue as a them-versus-us issue, and as soon as it was clear that "they" thought we should wear masks, a very predictable conservative backlash occurred. I'm not sure if the president helped launch this particular battle in the "culture war" or was just a cheerleader as usual.
- thoraway3030 6y agoI'm not sure if the president helped launch this particular battle in the "culture war" or was just a cheerleader as usual The US government reversed itself on masks and recommended them before the rest of the English-speaking world. The WHO only endorsed masks a few weeks ago. I don't like Trump, but these are facts. It seems to have been politicized after Mike Pence visited the Mayo Clinic, and didn't wear a mask, and then Trump was then pushed on the issue, and reacted characteristically. If Pence had set a good example and worn a mask, or of there hadn't been a huge uproar about him not wearing a mask, would the issue have turned into a front in the culture war?
- newacct583 6y ago> The WHO only endorsed masks a few weeks ago. I don't like Trump, but these are facts. That's not facts, that's spin. From your phrasing, it sounds like you're saying that prior to a "few weeks ago" that the WHO policy was somehow anti-mask. It wasn't, even in January. Their policy was always that PPE should be reserved for health care workers due to scarcity, and in a few (A FEW) instances their wording of that recommendation was poor and might plausibly imply that masks don't work. No expert ever interpreted the WHO policy the way you people insist on doing. And at this point this insistence is just pathological.
- seesawtron 6y agoWhat is the political agenda behind it? care to elaborate?