11 ms·
> Telling people which causes they must publicly support or else be assumed an enemy? Does that ring any bells? Are you talking about Kapernick being cancelled
by cma 6y ago
> Telling people which causes they must publicly support or else be assumed an enemy? Does that ring any bells?
Are you talking about Kapernick being cancelled from the NFL by conservative cancel culture and the Vice President's staged NFL walkout to support conservative cancel culture?
- waheoo 6y agoCherry picked whataboutism is really boring.
- dang 6y agoPlease read and follow the site guidelines when commenting here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- waheoo 6y agoK fixed.
- dang 6y agoReplacing the word "fucking" with "really" has nothing to do with it. There's no guideline against profanity on HN. Please read the guidelines and take the spirit of the site more to heart.
- waheoo 6y ago> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. The post I was replying to was shallow. Asking if people have rtfa is also against the guidelines. So its a bit rich to assume I havent read the guidelines. And no, there isnt a guideline agaisnt profanity but its what bought you to my comment isn't it?
- dang 6y agoNot really. I was reacting to "cherry picked whataboutism" and the putdown aspect. Both of those remain. In fact that's all the comment consists of. It doesn't matter what you were replying to.
- cumcastsucks 6y agothat's not cancel culture, friend. keep trying.
- Thorentis 6y agoNo, I was making a point with a bit more depth to it than that. If the point you're trying to make is that both sides are guilty of mob cancel culture, then you don't need to. Nobody here is pretending or claiming otherwise. Your comment is just another example of jumping into partisan politics for absolutely no reason.
- buboard 6y agosorry i would claim otherwise. Nobody has been cancelled for expressing leftwing-or extreme leftwing- ideas it may detract from your central point, but it also explanis why one side of the spectrum won't be willing to contribute to an armistice
- Thorentis 6y agoWell yes, if you did some analysis of which opinions people have lost their jobs over, and which causes must you support openly if you don't want to be seen as backwards, or which things have people apologised for saying after posting a Tweet, then I'm sure it would be clear that one side dominates societal discourse far more than the other.
- MagnumOpus 6y agoIt is super obvious that far more people have been fired for championing leftist opinions and causes (living wages, workers' safety, unions) than for being republican/racist/islamophobic. (Though I am not sure that the right wing dominates societal discourse like you say.)
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoSure they have. There was a story making the rounds just today about a girl losing a Deloitte offer for a pro-BLM post, and FIRE can tell you that even on campus left-wing cancellations aren't unheard of.
- gguevaraa 6y agoNot sure if this fits the bill but here's a story[0]. [0]: https://nypost.com/2020/07/02/harvard-grad-claira-janover-fired-over-tiktok-stab-threat-raises-money-online/ https://nypost.com/2020/07/02/harvard-grad-claira-janover-fi...
- bargl 6y agoThis is a valid point. Cancel culture cuts both ways, and I find it unacceptable in either direction. The one claim I'll give conservatives is that they did not say they fired him over this it was a lack of performance. I don't buy that story, but there are nuances that show the different tactics conservatives use for canceling things. I do not support what happened to Kapernick, I don't think cancel culture is any better when disguised as something else. But the scale at which things are happening now is insane.
- jlos 6y agoKapernick made a political statement as his place of work. He made a calculated risk to his career for the sake of his convictions. Choosing to take a stand strikes me as different than being pressured and judged for not taking one. As a non-fan of football, I read the distate for Kapernick's statement as foisting another political binary on fans (mostly by the media, not so much by kapernick). Should you kneel or not kneel? Now you have to have an opinion. I think the progression is: 1. Make a political statement against an injustice (hashtags, kneeling, etc) 2. Making a lack of support a form of complicity with injustice. 3. Narrowly define what support looks like. Exact quote from #ShutDownStem website: >> Unless you engage directly with eliminating racism, you are perpetuating it. [0] https://www.shutdownstem.com/ https://www.shutdownstem.com/
- Thorentis 6y ago> Choosing to take a stand strikes me as different than being pressured and judged for not taking one Fantastic point. And I would hope those in favor of democracy can accept it. If you choose to support a political party publicly, you can reasonably expect people to engage with you about it. But nobody should be able to coerce you to support any particular party or candidate. What we are seeing now, is not the freedom to choose a particular stance or cause. We are seeing the mob react with force to a lack of opinion. You must have an opinion. And it must be the right one.
- Barrin92 6y ago>But nobody should be able to coerce you to support any particular party or candidate. well, nobody is able to coerce you for not doing anything, but people can still judge you for it, and that may be perfectly reasonable. Inaction can be as devastating as action. Withdrawing in the face of some injustice is as much of a choice as participating on either front. It's an overused quote but really all that is necessary for evil to triumph is good people doing nothing. Of course today sometimes the causes are hyperbolic, but nothing is wrong with the principle. If someone is the victim of racism say, and people look away rather than stepping up, that's a failure.
- 6y ago
- donw 6y agoI don't know the full details on Kapernick, so I'm going to speak in generalizations. He does not deserve to be fired for making a political statement. Full stop. At the same time, he did leverage his employer's platform (the NFL) to make a political statement. Some sort of disciplinary action in response to that behavior is a legitimate course of action for an employer. Imagine Kapernick as an engineer working for, say, Instagram. Imagine that he Tweeted a bunch of pro-Biden memes on his personal Twitter. That seems fine to me. Now imagine that he wrote, without consulting management, a feature which put a Biden banner at the top of the Instagram website. That'd be a huge problem, and would merit disciplinary action. Not because he supported Biden, but because he leveraged the company brand and resources to do so, without the support of management. I think this is where we draw the line, but am also open to other ideas.
- cma 6y agoIsn't standing for the national anthem or playing it at games also an, obvious to anyone, literal political statement?
- donw 6y agoThe issue is not about making a political statement. As an individual, you should always have that right. Both the New York Times and Breitbart are purveyors of propaganda for their respective political parties. They literally do nothing but make massively biased political statements, all day long. Imagine you work there, and you disagree. You can totally try to change that from within. Fight the system. Work your way up. And once you have sufficient stature within the organization, you can run, say, an article praising George Washington on the front of the NYT, or a piece condemning him on Breitbart. But, you, as a journalist, are a public face for your respective brand, and as such, you will likely face disciplinary action for going against the brand image. It doesn't mean you can't make a statement. But when you leverage your employer's platform to do so, there are going to be consequences. Now, if you use your own megaphone, you absolutely deserve protection from being fired! Build your Twitter/Instagram/Facebook following, and preach as much as you'd like. You built it. It's yours. That's the reality of being a public figure. You are paid to be part of a brand image. Tell me where I'm wrong on this. Or where you think we should draw the line. I'm happy to hear other opinions.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoI'm not a football expert, but the fact his throwing accuracy was poor and getting worse seems relevant here: https://www.espn.com/blog/nflnation/post/_/id/234081/colin-kaepernicks-biggest-problem-performance-not-politics https://www.espn.com/blog/nflnation/post/_/id/234081/colin-k...