2 ms·
I have to say that the web in its early days never had this level of politically correct moderation or witch-hunting acts until YouTube, Facebook and Twitter ro
by rvz 6y ago
I have to say that the web in its early days never had this level of politically correct moderation or witch-hunting acts until YouTube, Facebook and Twitter rose in popularity and were used beyond their intended purpose; as tools used to dox and cancel opponents. Fast-forward to 2020, it has gotten too far and out of control.
One could say that social media has definitely accelerated this nonsense to new heights, taking everyone who disagrees with the PC-crowd underground.
- Thorentis 6y agoSocial media empowered the mob, and gave them an inflated sense of worth for their own opinions. Because your opinion can instantly be broadcast to millions of people, it must have value. But along with this came the mob mentality, where this new power will be used to silence opposition. The fault really lies in the companies, politicians, and media outlets who have given credence to what "the mob" on social media has to say. Example: a comedian/author makes a tweet that is mildly offensive to some small minority, but they didn't mean anything by it, or it was just a joke. Somebody sees the potential to kick up a stink, and retweet it with "can't believe they just said this. apologise now". It gets maybe 10% the "likes" of the original tweet. A media outlet sees this tweet (some intern is browsing "latest tweets") and writes an article saying "Internet in an outrage: is x a racist?". Author immediately issues an apology, resigns from their job, and goes into hiding, their career destroyed forever. What could have been done differently? The company they worked for could've stood by them. The author/whoever could have just ignored it. The media outlet could have had higher quality standards of publication. And almost nobody would even know what was said in the first place! Our society thrives on conflict, and any small hint of a conflict is blown up beyond all proportion.
- throw0101a 6y ago> I have to say that the web in its early days never had this level of politically correct moderation or witch-hunting acts until […] Let me tell you about Usenet, especially pre-Eternal September …
- adventured 6y agoNot everybody should have a bullhorn and social media has given everyone the ability to weaponize de facto threats & intimidation so as to destroy lives. The social terrorist behavior that has become routine on Twitter et al., needs to be extinguished by giving the behavior a financial cost to the corporations in charge of enabling or stopping it from being broadcast on their services. Twitter as a prominent example needs to be made financially liable for what happens on their service. They're a biased broadcast platform that censors and restricts based on their own subjective rules, they stopped being a mostly non-biased utility ~8-10 years ago. Since they're the opposite of neutral, they're properly entirely responsible for everything broadcast on their platform. You can watch hordes of malevolent actors on Twitter emotionally masturbate in the open to the notion of harming people, wildly lusting for who they're going to hurt next. Cancel some person next, destroy this person next. It's all over Twitter. The entire service has become a platform for social terrorists to organize and attack with. The first step is to make it prohibitively expensive for Twitter to continue to abet the social terrorists (they're terrorists - and yes the definition fits - because they intentionally, specifically seek to terrorize other people) and to force the social platforms to apply their terms of service equally for all users. The fines should be large enough that Twitter should be bankrupted if they fail to comply. And if someone can come up with a better term for the criminals on services like Twitter that use it to terrorize, threaten, intimidate, and destroy, that'd be great, given the obvious problems with the terrorist label. This is a new class of criminal cooperation that has never existed before, as these types of open, massive broadcast platforms have ever existed before. It used to be extremely difficult to organize thousands of people together to try to destroy someone's life, it was a mostly impractical concept previously. That type of weapon (it's a weapon because eg intimidation & threatening people with harm to their life is an act of violence; intimidation at the scale of Twitter is a machine gun version) should not only be illegal, it should cost the corporations to an epic degree if they abet it. Fortunately politicians have begun to figure out how to neuter the socials using these approaches. The only problem now, is that they're not going big enough yet. The fines have to be crushing to be effective.
- awb 6y agoThis reminds me of story about someone questioning "why ban nuclear weapons when we haven't shed the desire to kill?" Similarly, "why blame social media when we haven't shed the desire to witch hunt?" The red scare (and other witch hunts throughout history) worked pretty well without social media. Hard to compare and say that this time is worse. The other witch hunts though history seem pretty bad too.