9 ms·
Silicon Valley Elite Discuss Journalists Having Too Much Power in Private App
- pl0x 6y agoPaul Graham, Ben Horowitz, Balaji Srinivasan, and Jason Calacanis have proven to the world how sexist and misogynistic they all are and many others(Naval, Marc Andressen) like them with in Silicon Valley. We will never refer to them any of our portfolio companies.
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoCare to back any of that up with evidence?
- pl0x 6y agoCare to do your own research?
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoThe onus is on the accuser.
- thundergolfer 6y agoSimilarly would appreciate links. The only bad stuff I’ve personally seen is really stupid arguments for Capitalism from Graham and Calacanis. Why Calacanis still has that embarrassing “reasons people are not rich” tweet pinned is beyond me.
- pl0x 6y agohttps://twitter.com/AnandWrites/status/1278746917590220805 https://twitter.com/AnandWrites/status/1278746917590220805
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoSo these VCs are sexist because they blocked someone I’ve never heard of for an unknown reason? Maybe they are just fragile snowflakes like he implies, but that’s orthogonal to your accusation. Also, blocking anonymous trolls online is wonderful for your sanity. I wish HN had the ability.
- pl0x 6y agoToo bad you won't get funded with your biz op scheme for the cis white males you are defending.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoSomeone should sew your anus shut and feed you until you explode.
- kwistzhaderach 6y agoSir, this is not a reddit left wing sub.
- lliamander 6y agoAnand did a great thing with tech journalism, but the notion that he, or any journalist, is in any position to gatekeep on who qualifies as a "thinker" is laughably vain. I do not deny that VCs have a bias (an agenda, even) that leads them to predict a future which furthers their own wealth. But corporate media holds considerable cultural power, and to assume members of the corporate media only tell the truth and never act to protect or extend that cultural power is naive (or mendacious). Whatever we may say about capitalists insulating themselves from failure, at some point they still have to put some skin in the game. Your average corporate journalist is arguably more insulated from the consequences of their failure than a typical VC. Edit: I seem to have mistaken this person for Anand formerly of Anandtech. An unforced error on my part. My point about vanity still
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoI remember reading something by Calacanis 15 years ago or so and being baffled how his superficial drivel was considered insightful. These people all got status through one lucky project at the right time. After that, their popularity became self-reinforcing. It's about as far from meritocracy as can be.
- ericzawo 6y agoYes. Some of the most "real deal" successful people I've been lucky enough to meet, themselves are totally upfront about how absurdly lucky they were to be at the right place and right time in the past to now be considered "successful" or prominent.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Balaji Srinivasan... I'd like to see the evidence of him as well, I was very suspicious of him during 21 as he was simply acting as middleman for traditional VC money (Horowitz?) to buy up Bitcoin via a very lofty mining operation. With a raised eyebrow I continued to remain cautiously optimistic, but then when they exited 21inc with a pointless thing like VC email after being a significant miner in the Bitmain days and then eventually got bought out by COiNbase I felt this was the same SV guys having its way again burning money to hide their gains. To this day I still cannot understand why they didn't just buy bitcoin over the counter over time, would it have shifted the price so much that it would spook the Market and spike? I mean Draper has been pumping millions into it since at least 2013 and his DCA holding's ROI up until 2017 would have probably beat anything on Horowitz's portfolio. But the truth is Horowitz has been in the Bitcoin space for sometime as well, I want to say 2014. Hell, when Jack Dorsey went all into Bitcoin and essentially pivoted Square towards that end, not long after selling Caviar and going to Africa and stating that he would move there to build Bitcoin usecases, it didn't do anything noticeable and he is still CEO of both Twitter and Square/CASH. I guess I just don't get the machinations of these tech billionaires who think they can fool people into thinking they're not into a certain tech, and use absurd ways to prove otherwise.
- amadeuspagel 6y ago>To this day I still cannot understand why they didn't just buy bitcoin over the counter over time VCs aren't allowed to invest in currencies.
- Melting_Harps 6y agoBitcoin isn't a currency according FinCen [1], and back then not according the IRS [2], either. Maybe they were just trying to stay under the radar, but that's a lucky guess and again they've been active in the space regardless since '14. Who knows, but still I wanted to believe Blaji could actually live up to his 'Buidl' Speech, and I'm actually surprised he isn't around here on HN somewhere. 1: https://klasing-associates.com/fincen-update-bitcoin-cryptocurrency-not-subject-foreign-bank-account-reporting-fbar/ https://klasing-associates.com/fincen-update-bitcoin-cryptoc... 2: https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/03/25/irs-says-bitcoin-is-property/6873569/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/03/25/irs...
- tpmx 6y agoWho cares about what any of these self-important pricks think of themselves? (I'm thinking about both parts of the elite that's a part of this story - both the VCs and the hacks.)
- throughaweigh 6y agoThe rich and powerful attack those who attack their interests, but now they are more unified. Notice that there is actually very little concrete criticism of the media, instead you get abstract assertions ("hit piece", "fake news"), ad hominems and so on. When pressed the elites say that the reporting isn't wrong but that they should still be portrayed in a positive light. Obviously journalism can't work if they got their way.
- jlawson 6y ago>When pressed the elites say that the reporting isn't wrong but that they should still be portrayed in a positive light. God I would love to see what you'd come up with as an example of this. Media does terrible things on a constant basis. They're smart about rarely writing since sentences that are out-and-out lies, but their portrayal of people, companies, and grand social narrative is highly motivated at every level. The reason is because every major journalistic organization is completely dominated by activists, which means that all their reporting is motivated to specific ends. Their goals isn't to tell the truth, their goal is to remake the world according to their ideology. A perception of trustworthiness is just a resource to them - to be built up in service and spent in betrayal. It's not an end in itself. This story is a great example, since it's so incredibly motivated to do damage to these people. Every quote is pulled out and placed in the most damaging light possible. It's entirely a hit piece with a single purpose and that purpose is not to give readers a rounded understanding of all sides of the situation, but to gain power. It's not a story. There is no news here. Nothing happened. It's a private conversation between friends and the only content is thought. The story is an accusation of thoughtcrime. The fact that we're hearing about it at all is an indictment of the media.
- throughaweigh 6y ago> God I would love to see what you'd come up with as an example of this. @jason on Twitter said so explicitly in the last 24 hours, pg said so on Twitter some time ago. The rest of your comment just illustrates my initial point: abstract statements, ad-hominems and proof-by-assertions. That isn't to say that the media doesn't have biases or get stories wrong. The problem is that the elites try to use those facts to discredit all accurate reporting that is harmful to their interests. The honest and convincing way to discredit an inaccurate story is to point out concretely how it is wrong, doing anything else suggests that the story is accurate.
- untog 6y agoEye opening but certainly not surprising. It’s kind of incredible to think of these people, with all the power, fortune and access they have, spending their time attacking journalists. It feels like there’s a limitless number of more productive things to do. But the reality is that their press coverage is one of very few things they don’t have total control over and it drives them nuts.
- Barrin92 6y agoPlenty of things to talk about in that piece. For one the idea of this app seems entirely bizzare. A membership only app on which extremely wealthy people chat? I had to seriously laugh seeing Horowitz invest millions after his "time to build" piece. We wanted flying cars and we got 140 characters, and now we wanted skyscrapers and spaceships and we get a digital nightclub for nerds. Secondly I think it shows very clearly how much the superficially liberal, tolerant, woke entrepeneurs of this generation resemble old business tycoons. As soon as journalists shine a light on their behaviour, the masks come off. I remember a piece I read last year on class dynamics[1]. The author characterises today's class war not as the working class vs the rich, but as the rich against the professional and managerial class. The 0.1% vs the top 10%. I think this was a pretty good observation and it's becoming more and more apparent. Journalists, public representatives, Engineers with a sense of ethics and so on are coming in increasing tension with the actual owners of the companies they work for. It is on display at Facebook but also in this article. [1]https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2019/11/the-real-class-war/ https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2019/11/the-real-class-wa...
- lliamander 6y ago> The author characterises today's class war not as the working class vs the rich, but as the rich against the professional and managerial class. That's an interesting perspective, but not the only lens I would view this issue through. John Mackey (founder of whole foods) makes a point about the intellectual vs. the commercial class that seems relevant: > Intellectuals have always disdained commerce. That is something that tradesmen did—people that were in a lower class. Minorities oftentimes did it, like you had the Jews in the West. And when they became wealthy and successful and rose, then they were envied, they were persecuted and their wealth confiscated, and many times they were run out of country after country. Same thing happened with the Chinese in the East. They were great businesspeople as well. > So the intellectuals have always sided with the aristocrats to maintain a society where the businesspeople were kept down. You might say that capitalism was the first time that businesspeople caught a break. Because of Adam Smith and the philosophy that came along with that, the industrial revolution began this huge upward surge of prosperity.
- NotSammyHagar 6y ago
- zozbot234 6y agoSome further tidbits in this Quora Q&A: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-July-2020-Twitter-spat-between-Taylor-Lorenz-and-Balaji-S-Srinivasan-really-about https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-July-2020-Twitter-spat-bet... It looks to me like we might be about to see a pretty big kerfuffle between "tech" and traditional elite journalism, with non-trivial political overtones as well. This is kinda impressive to me since everyone kinda expects them to be politically aligned, but these sorts of alliances can also shift quite suddenly and unexpectedly. Both sides might then try to appeal to their more "grassroots" audiences, claiming that the other party is insincere and lacking in ethics. It won't be an outright call for "canceling", but the subtext will be similar.
- pl0x 6y agoPaul Graham, Ben Horowitz, Balaji Srinivasan, and Jason Calacanis have proven to the world how sexist and misogynistic they all are and many others(Naval, Marc Andressen) like them with in Silicon Valley.
- fossuser 6y agoThis article is missing some of the critical context that lead to this from Twitter. Summarized here: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-July-2020-Twitter-spat-between-Taylor-Lorenz-and-Balaji-S-Srinivasan-really-about https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-July-2020-Twitter-spat-bet... I think Taylor comes across extremely negatively here and the spin in this Vice article just makes it worse. Basically Taylor puts up a mean tweet about the Away CEO’s comments on the media (without actually engaging in the content of those comments). Balaji responds to the tweet with the same wording Taylor used, but directed at Taylor herself (to point out the meanness). Taylor tweets a cropped response image of only Balaji’s response and plays victim, rallying media people behind her (things escalate) - eventually they surreptitiously record this clubhouse conversation and write a hit piece without taking any responsibility for anything. It’s all very high school and the journalists come across extremely negatively to me. If anything this proves Balaji’s point. I should spend less time on Twitter.
- crocodiletears 6y agoThis whole whole affair seems as exhausting as it is childish and typical. Irrespective of these circumstances, journalists need to get off Twitter. Not even stop reading it, that's fine. They just need to stop tweeting if they're so constitutionally incapable of not getting into moralistic pissing matches and turning themselves into stories like they're trying to get on worldstar.
- fossuser 6y agoI don’t disagree, but I’m also glad I came across this and it was all out in the open. I wouldn’t have believed it was this bad without seeing it myself. This allows me to just dismiss most of it and distrust by default (I can also just ignore some writers entirely - Lorenz in this case, Kara Swisher earlier). There are obviously still great reporters (Steven Levy, Li Yuan for some examples), but there are a lot of terrible ones that misuse their power. In general I think people are better off not talking to the press and just writing for themselves on their own platform.
- NotSammyHagar 6y ago
- MiroF 6y ago> He proposed that the approaches to truth and accountability offered by GitHub, venture capital funding, and cryptocurrency all offer better models for journalism than "the East Coast model of 'Respect my authori-tay.'" When people talk about tech/engineer hubris, this is it. The idea that a "Github" model for journalism could offer the same level of a. resistance to external pressure and b. in-depth investigation as more institutional models is entirely without basis.
- manigandham 6y agoIt’s not hubris to think about better models. Questioning the status quo is how many revolutionary things got started. The institutional model clearly has major issues and there are countless examples of journalists afflicted with bad incentives and a clear narrative. Also the rise of social media has eroded the whole point of institutional organization since they just spend all day dueling on Twitter and writing about whatever unsourced hot take is found there.
- MiroF 6y agoJournalists do in-depth investigative reporting, they submit FOIA requests, they cultivate connections with other institutions in order to get stories of public interest to the public. I have never seen a "Github" non-professional style of journalism approach doing the same thing. > they just spend all day dueling on Twitter and writing about whatever unsourced hot take is found there. This is the hubris. Thinking that everyone else's job is way easier than what an engineer does - and journalists just spend all day on twitter without doing anything else. > Questioning the status quo is how many revolutionary things got started You can question the status quo and it's not hubris. You can also have instances where you question the status quo and it is hubris. I would say this is an instance of the latter.
- catalogia 6y ago> Journalists do in-depth investigative reporting, they submit FOIA requests, they cultivate connections with other institutions in order to get stories of public interest to the public. Some do. Others maliciously crop social media comments and provoke twitter flamewars to create content. I think the biggest problem with the tech industry is that it's insufficiently self-critical. But I think journalism has the same problem; I rarely see journalists writing articles about other journalists behaving badly. They have a tendency to protect their own, which mirrors my observations of how people in the tech industry generally respond to criticism of the tech industry.
- MiroF 6y agoI'll be honest, I would prefer to read pretty much any major news organizations reporting on this conversation other than Vice.
- Simulacra 6y agoThis is an extremely one sided article, and it seems to be missing a lot of critical information. That said, does anyone still trust the media?
- ardy42 6y ago> Some in the Silicon Valley set turned their sights on the Times after Scott Alexander, a psychiatrist who ran the philosophy blog SlateStarCodex, deleted the entire blog because he said the Times was going to "dox" him by publishing his real name in an upcoming story. (It is worth noting that Alexander has republished SlateStarCodex blogs in books using his full name.) This event resurfaced an ongoing and tedious discussion among venture capitalist types about journalism ethics, business models, and publishing incentives. I didn't know that. Is it true? What's the name of Alexander's book?