16 ms·
I assume Microsoft never allowed, say, swastikas. There's no reasonable expectation that you are able to spread racist propaganda in a car racing game (or for t
by rsynnott 6y ago
I assume Microsoft never allowed, say, swastikas. There's no reasonable expectation that you are able to spread racist propaganda in a car racing game (or for that matter in an actual car race; I think those tend to have very strict rules around decoration).
I can see an _argument_ that Twitter, say, should be forced to pander to racists. I don't buy that argument, mind you, but I can at least see the thought process. I can't see any reason that imaginary car livery should have to, though.
- sukilot 6y agoThat's an argument for banning swastikas, not banning anyone who displays a swastika. And before you say "come on, swastikas are pretty extreme", remember the moral panic we just went through when 4chan trolls convinced people that the OK hand sign was a "one-sided version ofna White Power" sign and got people fired from their jobs for making the sign.
- arcticfox 6y ago> That's an argument for banning swastikas, not banning anyone who displays a swastika. This seems semantic. For example, cheating is banned in many games, and if you cheat, you get banned. Banning cheating and cheaters is effectively the same thing.
- octocop 6y agoChoice is still present, is a person who is paralyzed and unable to speak by default non-racist?
- gamblor956 6y agoThere is a huge difference between thinking bad thoughts and expressing or acting on them. You can be as racist as you want in your own head. No one is stopping that. You can express those racist thoughts all you want on your own property. But you have absolutely no right to express or act on those racist thoughts on someone else's property.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pmiller2 6y agoIt's not like they can say or do anything racist, so the net effect is the same as if they were not racist.
- bastawhiz 6y agoPeople who are paralyzed and unable to speak aren't spreading hate in video games, so it's pretty pointless to hold them up as a counterexample. I know my grandparents probably have a lot of racist thoughts but unless they're unloading them at the Thanksgiving dinner table I'm not telling my grandmother to shut her mouth.
- strombofulous 6y agoThis is not the same thing at all. Banning swastikas would mean resetting the decals of a car with swastikas, not preventing the account from using the game license they paid for. Banning cheating means you ban the account of the person who cheated.
- arcticfox 6y ago"Banning cheating would mean preventing the cheat, not preventing the account from using the get license they paid for." They're two different responses to bad behavior, both totally fair.
- FireBeyond 6y agoIt may have been made up, but I'm willing to bet that a not insignificant portion of people who are _now_ making it aren't doing so to make a point of saying "everything is just fine". My town had an issue with a cop posing out with a bunch of 3%ers at their gun store. This is in the PNW, and the owner of the store, born and raised in the PNW, has a Confederate flag neck tattoo. This was during some street protests. People can't credulously claim that the half dozen or so people there were all making an "OK" sign then, completely naively, "hey, all good, we're safe, just guarding our gun store". Or maybe they were just making an in joke based on the SCUBA store next door?
- norswap 6y agoBut you see the issue with that thought process right? You can imbue political meaning on anything that way, and ban arbitrary things. What if there is a (perhaps bogus) polemic, and your favorite singer is singled out as a racist/misogynist/communist/whatever, and the Bad People start blasting his songs at rallies? Are you supposed to stop listening to your favourite songs. Come to your own conclusions, but mine is: fuck that - I'll be the judge of what is acceptable and what isn't, not some kind of thought mob.
- FireBeyond 6y agoYour conclusion here is that these people were all making this sign for non-nefarious meanings. On the contrary, it is contextually highly/entirely likely that they were _actively_ choosing to use it in a political manner. They _themselves_ were choosing to imbue political meaning on it, as much as anyone was choosing to _take_ meaning from it.
- Aerroon 6y ago>On the contrary, it is contextually highly/entirely likely that they were _actively_ choosing to use it in a political manner. Based on what? If you go looking for things with a specific interpretation in mind you're going to find a lot of it even in places that it wasn't meant that way. The adage about malice and incompetence comes to mind.
- aka1234 6y ago> "That's an argument for banning swastikas, not banning anyone who displays a swastika." If you don't ban the person displaying the swastika, how can you possibly enforce banning swastikas? There must be a consequence for displaying the offending symbol, otherwise the rule is toothless. You remove the swastika, and the person just replaces it. What then? Just keep removing it and hoping the Nazi/edgelord/'troll' will get tired of replacing the swastika? Trying to win a battle of attrition with a bad-faith actor is not an effective way to enforce rules. > "remember the moral panic we just went through when 4chan trolls convinced people that the OK hand sign was a "one-sided version ofna White Power" sign and got people fired from their jobs for making the sign." "Remember when 4chan 'trolls' said the OK hand sign was a white power sign and then white supremacists started using the OK hand sign as a white power sign?" --- There, I fixed it for you.
- toast0 6y agoBan the car --- either don't let them use it online, or don't show it to others. If an account gets a threshold number of cars banned, don't let them use customized cars online. If they're spouting hate on chat, ban them from chat too.
- aka1234 6y agoThat seems like a lot of effort to address the symptoms, not the disease. The root issue is the user. Get rid of the user and you don't have to worry about all these half-measures.
- loopz 6y agoWhat was the problem needing solving?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoDepends who you ask. Some might say toxic expressions. Others might say people who declaim toxic expressions. Clearly MS has the latter goal in mind. I can imagine a very reasonable argument for this. Someone who puts a Confederate flag on their car seems highly likely to engage in other toxic behaviors. Just like someone who calls someone a nigger once is likely to do it again. So we use the behaviors as a signal of underlying tendency. We don't want people who have this tendency on the platform because they will tend to make life worse for other users, and the loss of their business hurts us less than we gain from other people feeling more comfortable. Therefore we ban them.
- jacobolus 6y agoHere’s a NY Times summary: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/15/us/ok-sign-white-power.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/15/us/ok-sign-white-power.ht... > The 4chan hoax succeeded all too well, and ceased being a hoax: Neo-Nazis, Ku Klux Klansmen and other white nationalists began using the gesture in public to signal their presence and to spot potential sympathizers and recruits. For them, the letters formed by the hand were not O and K, but W and P, for “white power.”
- DevKoala 6y agoIt also weaponized the outrage and ruined the lives of innocent people. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/06/stop-firing-innocent/613615/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/06/stop-firin... I don’t understand how people can justify the collateral damage; it is going too far.
- jacobolus 6y agoThis case seems to involve a white supremacist jerk experiencing road rage, then tricking a Latino guy into making the hand gesture, taking a photo, and then publicly lobbying his employer to fire him. Both the white supremacists and the intolerant and incurious (exclusively white) investigators/managers at the man’s company end up looking horrible. But this doesn’t seem too relevant to the confederate flags in video games case. Not everyone knows that white supremacist internet trolls have appropriated the OK hand gesture, but everyone living in the US understands that the confederate battle flag and other confederate symbols represent slavery, white supremacism, and treason.
- pmiller2 6y agoYeah, it's terrible that people can be fired for literally no reason in this country. This wouldn't have happened in a country that has any semblance of workers' rights.
- Smoosh 6y ago"Literally no reason" ?? He was recorded flashing a white power symbol while driving a (presumably liveried) company truck. Now I think, after hearing his story, that a public apology and explanation would have been enough. But he brought the company into disrepute. Firing him seems to be a valid option they could take. I personally think that raising awareness with a public apology and a statement from the company would have been better for everyone, but so often, a company's first response is to cover their ass. Or maybe they didn't believe him, while the reporter did? I wasn't there and can never know.
- undersuit 6y agoI don't think there was a moral panic. Just a reaction. Slurs come from somewhere. The N-word didn't just spontaneously appear in every one's dictionary the night after it was first used. What if we could have stopped the N-word when the 4chans of 1400 started using it?
- fwip 6y agoYour metaphor would be better if white nationalists hadn't actually adopted it as a sign to identify each other. Yes, it started as a joke/hoax. Then they started doing it sincerely.
- jhanschoo 6y agoThis is assuming that the internal policy is "we ban any symbol thought to be racist", vs. ""we ban symbols clearly established over years to be racist". That is, swastikas and the confederate flag have an established history of their meaning, whereas the 4chan sign does not.
- stevekemp 6y agoToday there was a news story about Finland dropping the swastika from their air-force logo: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53249645 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53249645
- KozmoNau7 6y agoWhich is something I think deserves a bit of context. It had been the Finnish air force's official insignia since 1918, so it was unrelated to the German Nazi Party, although of course that association was inevitable once they seized power. Similarly, the stone elephant holding the gate building to the old Carlsberg grounds in Copenhagen bear huge swastikas on their sides, since they were erected in 1901: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elephant_Tower,_Carlsberg#/media/File:Elefantporten_-_detail_1.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elephant_Tower,_Carlsberg#/med... There are a lot of swastikas still present in old sculptures and designs with no relation to nazism.
- stevekemp 6y agoI think that was explained quite well in the article, and while the symbol has had a long history I think it is fair to say that these days the majority of people would see the symbol and think "Nazi". Removing it feels like a reasonable thing to do, though I'd probably draw the line at chisel it off old-buildings, etc.
- grawprog 6y agoI thought it was a better meme personally when Malcolm in the middle made it so everyone would do the ok sign below their waist and if you looked, you got a punch in the shoulder. That definitely went on for a couple years when I was a kid, to the point where everyone got really sick of those few people that didn't get when it stopped being funny. That's the thing though, all it takes is one meme to take off to change the meaning of a symbol and you can't really predict what or how.
- js2 6y ago> do the ok sign below their waist and if you looked, you got a punch in the shoulder This was going around my college friends in the early 90s, predating Malcom in the Middle (2000-2006). I have no idea where it originated.
- grawprog 6y agoI never knew, I know that's what popularized it for kids around my school around grade 5 or 6. Now I'm curious where that actually came from.
- egberts 6y agoIt was popularized in 1976 in Ste. Saint Marie, Michigan as we started doing that in our high school, this circle game. That is, until someone can chime in an earlier date.
- pelliphant 6y agoIsn't "banning anyone who displays a swastika" a method of enforcing "banning swastikas" ?
- egberts 6y agoThe entire Deaf community also has a beef with those who may object to certain signs. We're about inclusivity without any connotations associated with each sign because they are a communication tools. (Same for SCUBA divers and SEAL teams). The faux outrage can step aside while we sign to each other in relative peace and comfort. But what happens if hearing people started seeing our signs and get offended and (gasp) started shooting at us; oh wait, that has happened already and all too often. For that, get off of us. Signs are a communication tool, even the offensive FUCK YOU ones.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoThe Nazi flag is inarguably racist propaganda. The Confederate flag, however, has for decades been a symbol of southern pride for many people. I read somewhere recently that over 40% see it as a symbol of heritage more than racism.
- user982 6y agoPride in what? Heritage of what? The South has hundreds of years of history. Why are the 4 years of the Confederacy so celebrated?
- caymanjim 6y agoIt's also not the flag of the Confederacy (as in the nation). No one uses that. What everyone uses is the Confederate Battle Flag, which is specifically the flag of the army of secessionists. There's no rational argument that it represents Southern culture.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoInteresting, I didn't know that there were multiple flags for the CSA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flags_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flags_of_the_Confederate_State.... It seems that the second and third did incorporate the battle flag as part of the design. Wouldn't surprise me to see these people switch to one of the other, lesser-known variants to work around the ban.
- user982 6y ago> Wouldn't surprise me to see these people switch to one of the other, lesser-known variants to work around the ban. That's exactly what Georgia did. In 1956 they added the Confederate Battle Flag to their state flag in support of white supremacy and segregation, and in 2003 switched it for the Confederate Stars and Bars: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Georgia_(U.S._state) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Georgia_(U.S._state)
- 6y ago
- jeegsy 6y agoI'm assuming that swastikas have much more universal unpopularity than the confederacy flag. Heck, in 2020, MS just voted to remove confederate symbol from the state flag. SO I dont think the comparison is all there. My concern with these sort of deplatforming moves while understandable, is they tend to drive these bigoted ideas underground. So maybe they cant express it publicly but boy, do they find other ways to do it as certain church members' families can attest. I don't have a definite solution but there is something to be said for using informal social pressure (i.e confederate decal dude all of a sudden not finding anyone to play with, because people quit the game as soon as they see the flag) rather than deplatforming.
- tedunangst 6y agoIs the reverse even remotely close to true? If MS allowed confederate flags on cars, would the bigoted idea underground disappear?
- norswap 6y agoI don't think "taking underground" is the right metaphor, but it intensifies polarization, and makes these people feel persecuted. It's not that they care about the flag that much for most of them. It's that suddenly, it's not even allowed anymore and they don't agree with that. Frankly, I couldn't care less about the confederate flag, but the thought process here is very relatable. And then these people vote. People who feel (rightly or wrongly) persecuted tend to lash out, whether it's by breaking statues or electing far-sides candidates.
- naasking 6y ago> There's no reasonable expectation that you are able to spread racist propaganda in a car racing game Merely displaying a flag seems like a pretty generous interpretation of "propaganda". It certainly doesn't fit any definition of which I'm aware. Perhaps there's an argument for banning such symbols, but don't use hyperbole to try and prove your point, you just undermine the legitimacy of this effort.
- 8note 6y agoFlags are very powerful symbols. Suppose trump took down all the American flags in the whitehouse and replaced them with Russian flag, or if Obama had taken them down and replaced them with the Isis flag. There's no world in which that would be taken lightly
- filleduchaos 6y agoIt's a perennial source of amazement that so many Americans don't realise that literal political symbols are actually, you know, political. Flags, anthems, pledges, coats of arms, etc - these are (benign) nationalist symbols and displaying/rendering them is inherently a political choice.
- naasking 6y agoAmazed or not, symbol or not, political or not, a person displaying a flag is quite literally not propaganda. Honestly, look it up: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/propaganda https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/propaganda And I'm not American in case you were referring to me.
- filleduchaos 6y agoI know people in the West are socialised to think that propaganda is something Other People do (preferably ones that can be thought of as Bad) but I'm afraid I have to inform you that displaying political symbols (such as flags) _is_ part of spreading propaganda. Why exactly do you think that there is an entire etiquette surrounding the proper display of a flag, or that flying particular flags has been variously criminalised around the world (such as flags associated with socialism/ At best you can say that one is simply being an unwitting vehicle of propaganda, but to claim that the public display of such a strong political symbol as a flag is not intended to spread and reinforce what it represents is just absurd.
- notyourday 6y ago> I assume Microsoft never allowed, say, swastikas. Let's replace Microsoft with Amazon. Should Amazon be able to produce "The Man in The High Castle?" Should "The Man In The High Castle" be available to watch? How about merchandise from the show? Would it be OK to have it?
- rsynnott 6y agoSure. Amazon should be allowed do that (and of course, there's a lot of context there; if they started putting swastikas, or confederate flags, on the cars in Top Gear there might be more eyebrows raised). It probably shouldn't be _compelled_ to carry all material containing swastikas, though.
- notyourday 6y agoAh, so they did it all over NYC subway a few years ago. To a point where I had to do a double take before I realized it was just an Amazon promo. There are quite a few Eastern Europeans and Jews in NYC. Why was that OK?
- tedunangst 6y agoAre there pictures of these subway swastikas? (no, of course not.)
- notyourday 6y agoYeah, it was even in Gothamist. So I'm sure it is also in NYPost and Daily News.
- Dylan16807 6y agohttps://cms.prod.nypr.digital/images/62499/fill-661x496/ https://cms.prod.nypr.digital/images/62499/fill-661x496/ Found this on Gothamist. Can you point to the swastika? Or is this a different NYC Subway campaign for The Man in The High Castle?
- swayvil 6y agoGiven that 99% of horrible deeds are done for money, maybe we should allow no mention of money either. Would that work? No, don't just censor me away with your little "downvotes". Discuss!
- mkbkn 6y agoSwastika is used as a symbol of divinity and spirituality in Indian religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism. I wonder why it'still considered "taboo" in the Western society in the information-age.
- fomine3 6y ago卍 is often used here in Japan for figure in maps meaning temple. I hope western world doesn't kill irrelevant figure. I generally don't like the thought of cultural appropriation (IMO Anyone should be able to wear kimono) but I feel that forbidding something outside western country by western people is a bad cultural appropriation.
- ric2b 6y agoIsn't it oriented in the reverse, though? It's not the same symbol.
- soraminazuki 6y agoI'm not saying that we should "pander" to racists and let them spread racist propaganda without consequence. That's an extreme take of my expressed views. I'm arguing that having an easy way to censor speech can cut both ways. It's rarely the case that the system works the way we want it to, and there should be more independent oversight for these cases at the very least. It's about being careful about what we wish for. I also believe that we should be exploring more ways to fight racism other than censoring it outright. Censorship seems like an easy answer, but it's not going "cure" the racists and has unwanted side-effects on society. I think racism is a complex issue that needs more deeper solutions.