3 ms·
> It seems like downloads from Sci-Hub and citations could have a common cause, for example, being interesting to scientists. If Sci-Hub downloads are a good pr
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> It seems like downloads from Sci-Hub and citations could have a common cause, for example, being interesting to scientists. If Sci-Hub downloads are a good proxy for interest and they happen first, then they could usefully be used to predict citations
So far so good.
> , without necessarily being a cause.
The logic has fallen apart. In order for the downloads not to be a cause, the same citations would have to occur in their counterfactual absence. You're claiming that anyone who downloads a paper from Sci-Hub would, in the absence of Sci-Hub, obtain that paper by other means.
Compare the currently higher-positioned thread ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23710896 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23710896 ), where this paper is getting slammed for concluding that limiting the availability of a paper may prevent the research described in that paper from "achieving its full impact". On your analysis, where Sci-Hub downloads are driven by interest from scientists and that explains the entire more-downloads-means-more-citations effect, that conclusion is 100% correct.
- kgwgk 6y ago> The logic has fallen apart. Note the words used in the argument: "could have a common cause", "without necessarily being a cause". The logic that fails is the one that depends on a common cause being impossible and concludes that one thing is necessarily causing the other. (It plausably may do so to some extent, but that paper doesn't prove that nor gives a good estimate of the effect.)
- thaumasiotes 6y agoNo, I specifically agree that they have a common cause. Nobody's depending on a common cause being impossible. But they cannot be coincidentally related by a common cause! This is clearly a causality chain: 1. interest in the paper -> reading the paper 2. reading the paper -> citing the paper It is not: 1. interest in the paper -> reading the paper 2. interest in the paper -> citing the paper You can't seriously believe that interest in the paper can lead to citations of the paper without being intermediated through reading the paper! And that intermediary position of Sci-Hub means that, in the model described, it cannot possibly fail to be a cause of citations. That would be the same argument as "one game downloaded through piracy equals one lost sale". If you don't believe that one illegal download = one lost sale, you've immediately admitted that piracy is a cause of additional gameplay.
- kgwgk 6y agoThe point is that the paper does not (and can not) distinguish one situation from the other. Edit: your diagrams are too simplistic anyway. Papers can be read elsewhere. Citations have more causes than readership and its incremental effect will be heterogeneous.
- oefrha 6y agoOP of higher-positioned thread "slamming" the paper. > And that intermediary position of Sci-Hub means that, in the model described, it cannot possibly fail to be a cause of citations. No, downloads don't automatically lead to citations. The possible scenario where every single citation came from another channel (arXiv, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, JSTOR, what have you) is entirely consistent with the paper's findings. I for one happen to be a scientist, I don't think I ever cited a paper I downloaded from Sci-Hub, but I've certainly grabbed a few papers from other fields on Sci-Hub; those downloads did not contribute to citation stats at all. In addition, the paper is trying to conclude "limited access to publications may limit some scientific research from achieving its full impact" by comparing papers available on Sci-Hub to, guess what, papers available on Sci-Hub (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23710992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23710992). I really need some solid convincing to accept this leap in logic. I don't necessarily disagree with the conclusion, in fact I think it's in a way kinda obvious (there should be an effect, however small it is), but the paper's analysis adds nothing to support it. I'm just not a fan of shoddy analysis, whether I like the conclusion or not (otherwise I'd better be a politician or lawyer).
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I don't necessarily disagree with the conclusion, in fact I think it's in a way kinda obvious (there should be an effect, however small it is) Agreed. > but the paper's analysis adds nothing to support it. I don't quite agree with this. The paper demonstrates that more realized access is related to more citations. I think you can make a solid argument that more potential access is related to more realized access. That connection is enough to count the analysis as "supporting" the conclusion ("more potential access ~ more citations") at a level which is greater than zero. Support isn't proof.