3 ms·
The article is making it sound like some kind of backfire, and I'm not really sure why. It's gotta be good in the long run for US auto workers if their competit
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
The article is making it sound like some kind of backfire, and I'm not really sure why. It's gotta be good in the long run for US auto workers if their competitors' wages triple.
- gwern 6y agoWhat are these 'wages' of which you speak? Robots do not have hourly wages: "Auto component maker Piolax, will also raise the hourly wage at its Mexican plant to $16 within the year. The company is also installing robots to mitigate rising labor costs, President Yukihiko Shimazu said."
- awakeasleep 6y agoAnyone else a 'robotic automation takeover of all jobs' skeptic? There are obviously places where it makes sense, but a $15/hr human is preeeetty cheap compared to the price, programming, and maintenance of a robot. Seeing the quote from Yukihiko, I feel it reads like PR or a soothing word to stockholders who hate to hear about employees and wages
- wolfgke 6y ago> There are obviously places where it makes sense, but a $15/hr human is preeeetty cheap compared to the price, programming, and maintenance of a robot. But such a robot is a good insurance against further increases of minimum wages.
- throw_away 6y agoCynically: you don't even need a real, working robot in-hand in order to threaten minimum wages. Even cheaper.
- gwern 6y agoIt also is great if the tariffs get dropped, since you were going to invest in robots anyway and this just moves your R&D forward in time. Which is better, relocating your entire factory & supply chain permanently only for the tariffs to disappear and render the entire exercise moot, or prioritize robots (even more than you were before, given coronavirus) and then regardless of what happens, you still enjoy the benefits of the robots? This and coronavirus and the recession are playing their usual role of shocking entities out of local optima... in this case, towards more automation & remote working. It is deeply ironic that Trump is essentially gouging Americans' welfare by forcing jacked-up prices which will subsidize the very automation & trade dynamics the Rust Belt blames their woes on.
- mbrodersen 6y agoToyota and Tesla (among many companies) found out the hard way that robots are still very dumb and not a substitute for all jobs.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut then somebody has to make and maintain the robots. If this is only the equivalent in cost to the existing jobs, it's still going to labor. If it's less then prices decline unless the manufacturer is a monopolist, and lower prices are about as good as higher wages. (If the manufacturer is a monopolist we've got trouble, but that's always the case.)
- Barrin92 6y agoBecause the US now gets no new jobs but the price for the cars will go up as the labour cost increases, proving the very trivial point that tariffs function as a tax on domestic consumers. If the goal of the policy was to redistribute money from Japanese carmakers and American consumers to Mexican factory workers they've done a great job, very altruistic. Also it's quite hilarious how quickly the reputation of the US has deterioated. The US is now being treated like an unreliable country. "We don't want to be whipped around by a policy that we don't know how long it will last," said an executive at a Japanese automaker."
- colechristensen 6y agoRaising your neighbor's income means they will import more from you, it's not backfiring, it's working as intended.
- valuearb 6y agoBut it’s not. It’s funding more robots for the Mexican plants, which means fewer jobs for Mexican auto workers. So some workers will do better, others worse. And American consumers pay higher prices, so they are worse off.
- colechristensen 6y agoAre the robots cheaper or more expensive than human workers? There is some broken thinking that high wages will increase consumer cost but replacing humans with cheaper robots won't, cherry-picking armchair cause-and-effect thinking to fit a "this is bad" narrative. Reducing trade frictions forces economic equality, especially when that reduction is tied towards some equality metric, like wages. Products being cheap because of economic disparity in trading partners isn't something to celebrate or bemoan the loss of. What is good for our neighbors is good for us. So many people are arguing from both sides at the same time.
- valuearb 6y agoThe more you are forced to pay workers, the more attractive robots become. The jaw of comparative advantage tells us that unrestrained trade benefits both parties. It means we get to deploy our workforce into higher value and higher paying jobs, while they get to increase their standard of living as well.