7 ms·
Not sure how much you know about the SF market. We only get glimpses, but it gives you an idea of how much wealth these landlords capture. The building at the
by jeffbee 6y ago
Not sure how much you know about the SF market. We only get glimpses, but it gives you an idea of how much wealth these landlords capture.
The building at the corner of Fillmore and Waller was bought for $1.05 million, 20 years ago. It has 6 retail storefronts and 18 apartments upstairs. Just one of the retail doors rent for $10000/month, or it did before this rent strangled the tenant:
https://hoodline.com/2020/04/cafe-du-soleil-shutters-after-15-years-in-the-lower-haight https://hoodline.com/2020/04/cafe-du-soleil-shutters-after-1...
The building is assessed for $1.4m, so the taxes are around $15000/year (which the tenants pay under NNN terms) but the gross is probably well over $50000/month. And there's no landscaping, obviously.
These people are absolutely stacking cash. They are just parasites.
- titanomachy 6y agoHow could the building you describe be assessed at only 1.4 million? In my city, a single condo that rents for $4k/mo would be assessed higher than that.
- jeffbee 6y agoI'm so glad you asked. In 1978 Californians passes Proposition 13, written for and sponsored by the Los Angeles Apartment Owners' Association, which says that property assessments may not increase by more than 2% per year or CPI, whichever is less. Property tax rates may not exceed 1% of assessed value. So the max theoretical assessment of a building bought for 1.05 million twenty years ago is 1.56 million.
- titanomachy 6y agoAh, right. I've heard reference to this before. Very unfortunate.
- tverbeure 6y agoProp 13?
- tartoran 6y agoThere are parasites everywhere there’s some cash flow. We need laws to tame these
- refurb 6y agoMaybe rent control? That seems to have worked really well!
- austhrow743 6y agoLaws created the problem. We need less laws not more.
- tartoran 6y agoIt could be fewer laws, sure, whatever solves the problem, but something that doesn’t have legal loopholes
- imtringued 6y agoYou eliminate parasitic behavior by increasing competition in an industry.
- tomcam 6y agoIf you make anywhere near an average IT salary in the USA there are a billion or so people in the world who would feel that you were absolutely stacking cash, and are a parasite.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neilparikh 6y agoIn the case of the salaried employee, you're earning as a direct result of you doing productive work. You can argue that the pay is too high, the but the fact you have to put in work to earn it means it is at least not parasitic. In the case of a landowner, they need to put in no such work. They didn't create the land. All of the rent comes from the fact that they have a monopoly on a scarce good that cannot be produced further, and one that everyone needs. See Adam Smith [0] and David Ricardo analysis on rent for more on this (the Ricardo's law of rent is a really neat concept). Now the fact that land and buildings are rented together complicates this a little bit, but this definitively applies to the rent that comes from the land. Simply claiming two actions are equivalent because they both lead to lots of money is not a useful mental model. How you earn your money matters. [0] - "The rent of land, therefore, considered as the price paid for the use of the land, is naturally a monopoly price. It is not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land, or to what he can afford to take; but to what the farmer can afford to give." — Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter XI
- mapgrep 6y agoAwfully convenient reasoning for engineers. Making half a million dollars a year optimizing the invasion of people’s privacy, for a company that dodges taxes, after four years of government subsidized education is real work and if you get rich in a liquidity event you earned it; assembling $1 million twenty years ago when people were fleeing SF, spending two decades maintaining marketing renting servicing paying taxes on and chasing rents on the property in the meantime, keeping up with and complying with city and state regulations — that’s always just parasitism and if the city you chose turns into a boomtown it’s good luck you have not earned. Not a fan of landlords as a rule but you are slicing your analyses of privilege way too thin.
- apta 6y agoWhat do you propose? Take away their property?
- proverbialbunny 6y agoMaybe do what Singapore does. I'm sure there are other good models too.
- apta 6y agoWhat do they do?
- neilparikh 6y agoSingapore owns all the land, and then they lease it out at 99-year terms. So an individual can own property for their whole lifetime (and then a little bit more, perhaps to pass onto their children), but the can't pass it forever. The problem they recognized was if they had indefinite landownership, and they could pass it onto their descendants, given that they're a small island nation, within a few years, all the land would be owned. After that, future generations would have no more land to buy, and those who are lucky enough to be born to landed family would be able to charge rent those who didn't have the privilege to be born to a family with property.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoPoor reasoning, if the land has value, some would sell and convert to cash for other investments. Tax policy can fix this.
- neilparikh 6y agoSome would, yes. But the land value would be high enough that most people trying to enter the market wouldn't be able to afford the costs of buying property. Under this approach, the government can sell property at a subsidized rate to new buyers once it reverts back to them. I think the government also wants to allow property owners to be able to profit somewhat from the growth of the value of their property, since 80% of the population owns property in Singapore. Now, I agree that these 2 goals are in conflict, and tax policy would be the better fix. But I guess their approach does at least fix the problem somewhat.
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoRule of thumb estimate for operating expenses for multi family is 50% (doesn’t include mortgage), and that doesn’t differ much just because rents are high. That means almost everything on your expenses column is more expensive as well. Don’t get me wrong, real estate is a great investment, just not quite that great.
- jedberg 6y ago> They are just parasites. They are providing a service. You arrive in a new city with no money. Where will you live? The landlord is assuming the risk of owning and maintaining the building and all you have to do it put in a deposit. The main reason they are "parasites" is prop 13. Without that, their building would be assessed at a reasonable level, and most of their profits would be property tax payments. If you live in California, make sure to vote yes on the two partial repeals of Prop 13 this November: https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers_and_Exemptions_Initiative_(2020) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers_an... https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers,_Exemptions,_and_Revenue_for_Wildfire_Agencies_and_Counties_Amendment_(2020) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers,_E...
- oa335 6y agoLandlords may provide services, but they primarily extract economic rent, essentially profiting from their their monopoly on that particular piece of land. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent
- perl4ever 6y agoHow can they profit from the unproduced value of the land when they had to buy it? It seems to me that you're assuming landlords owned the land since before high property values in SF or wherever were a thing. It seems unlikely this situation accounts for much of the real estate.
- imtringued 6y agoThat monopoly is guaranteed by your local government. Go talk to them if you don't like this.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIs anyone going to put up a building when they don't have a monopoly on the piece of land on which it sits?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- refurb 6y agoSure, they might be raking in now, after 20 years. And that $1.05M invested 20 yeas ago in the stock market? They would have doubled their money with none of the headache.
- bradlys 6y agoI'm pretty sure the building is worth much more than $2m. With 18 apartments, it has to be at least $5m. Heck, the crappy apartment complex I lived in in the peninsula that was built in the 1960s was worth close to $9m and it only had like 8 small apartments.
- refurb 6y agoI'm pretty sure the building is worth much more than $2m. Assuming all the units are under rent control, it might not be worth much more than $2M. A good example is my place in SF. 3 unit building in a very desirable neighborhood. If the place was empty? It would likely fetch $5M based on square footage. With 3 tenants who have been there 10 years and have rent control? My realtor tells me they base it on cap rate and with only $7000 in rent being collected, the landlord would be lucky to $1.5M for it.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's a pretty dumb example. With those figures they could pay each tenant half a million to GTFO and still clear two million.
- refurb 6y agoRent control saved me $300,000 over 7 years. If I wanted to stay in SF for the rest of my life, you think I’d move out for $500,000? The lifetime value of rent control is more than $500,000.
- imtringued 6y agoI don't understand how you can call providing dense housing being a parasite. The parasites are people with frozen property taxes who refuse to sell their land so that it can be used to build denser housing. After all the problem with the housing market is that there are not enough units for everyone so only the highest bidders can successfully rent an apartment.