6 ms·
Facebook Does Not Benefit from Hate
- untilHellbanned 6y agoMichael Jordan does not benefit from basketball.
- lostgame 6y agoBetter example: ‘Google does not benefit from stealing user data.’ :P Jordan doesn’t even play ball anymore. :3
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoFacebook owns a website. Jordan owns a basketball team.
- lostgame 6y agoDid not know he owned a team, hehe! Just knew he wasn’t playing anymore. Shows you how much I know about basketball. :P
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tzvsi 6y ago"This piece originally ran in AdAge." So, this article is meant for advertisers. Profits over people.
- paxys 6y agoAdvertisers are people too, my friend.
- jfengel 6y agoNo, advertisers are the only people. Everybody else is the product.
- ghostbrainalpha 6y agoYou are on fire with the analogies today!
- virgil_disgr4ce 6y agoCorporations are not people
- mic47 6y agoBut corporations are illiterate. People in corporations don't.
- starpilot 6y agoTech is the new advertising industry, and we're all complicit. So this is aimed at us.
- jlarocco 6y agoSpeak for yourself. Web development is more or less part of the advertising industry now, but huge parts of "tech" aren't working on the web or with advertising.
- mrkramer 6y agoFacebook's userbase is a mirror of human society if you want to fix Facebook fix society first.
- hairofadog 6y agoOne step toward fixing society might be to place limits on platforms that profit from propagating divisive, misleading, and hateful content.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI disagree with the use of a vague phrase like 'hateful content' in a context like limiting platforms that support societal discourse. That term has more clear meaning to me when it is used to describe content that explicitly suggests violence (as in physical violence). But when it comes to 'placing limits' on platforms (AKA censoring), it is often used in expansive and arbitrary ways. For instance, Reddit recently banned a subreddit called "Gender Critical", whose premise was disagreement with progressive gender ideology, and it had over 60K members. While I did not follow this subreddit, I personally feel that's a fine discussion to have. After all, gender identity is a controversial topic that is far from settled, and it is still very new in its current incarnation (meaning the ideology surrounding it in progressive America as opposed to historical views or views in other geographies). Society is still very divided on this topic (https://www.prri.org/spotlight/gender-identity-significant-partisan-and-gender-divides-remain/ https://www.prri.org/spotlight/gender-identity-significant-p...), and that debate needs to happen and will continue to happen for years. But Reddit instead chose to ban this subreddit outright, with no warning, under the guide of removing 'hateful content'. I feel that is inappropriate, and yet censorship of this form is being normalized on all the major big tech platforms (Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, YouTube). Instead of limiting platforms in a way that is content-specific, how about just limiting platforms in more neutral ways? Platforms beyond some size (maybe based on number of users) should be held to standards of neutrality that are grounded in our laws, or split up on anti-trust grounds. It's not good for us to have duopolies (Visa/Mastercard) or oligopolies (big tech) that have degrees of reach/power/influence that are comparable to governments but operate without Constitutional constraints (freedom of speech in particular).
- empath75 6y ago> We’re a pioneer in artificial intelligence technology to remove hateful content at scale. This is everything wrong with social media in a nutshell. This isn't a problem that can be solved with artificial intelligence. You need human beings enforcing human standards of decency. Keep in mind, that Facebook's 'artifical intelligence' algorithms automatically created lots of white supremacy groups and promote white supremacy content, and allowed advertising targetted at white supremacists. Throwing more AI at a problem created and exacerbated by ai isn't going to solve it.
- zpeti 6y agoAnd you think humans will do a good job at correctly assessing pieces of content on the sliding scale of “hate”? When one moment it’s fine debating gender issues and a moment later it’s hate speech? For 35,000 people? This is an impossible problem, both for AI and humans. Any suggestion that this will be solved is pandering bullshit to the NYT crowd.
- commandlinefan 6y agoIt's becoming increasingly clear that "hate" is a dog-whistle for "not explicitly left-wing". Which is unfortunate, because yet another useful word is being stripped of meaning.
- sharkmerry 6y agoPerhaps I am naive. It seems they do benefit from hate, in that negative emotions drive more engagement. IF they truly didnt want to benefit from hate, they would find a way to not always rate negative engagement (arguing) as "engaging".
- foobiekr 6y agoOfficial denials are actually confirmations.
- mrweasel 6y agoThe question to Facebook really should be: Can't you, or won't you remove hate speech? It's really hard to tell, because nudity or illegal items for sale is removed within minutes of posting. Sometimes Facebook clearly overreacts in these cases, but it seems they're not reacting to hate speech or racism at all. At least they should be able to flag and hide posts by simple keyword searches and then sent them of to human moderators, who can then unhide false positives and delete offending posts. Honestly I think the truth is that Facebook simply isn't able to moderate their platform, the volume of data is to high and their A.I/filters/keywords search technology isn't nearly as good as customers, media, politicians and investors believe, but Facebook won't admit it.
- chanmad29 6y agoIIRC there was an article shared recently that explicitly depicted the senior leadership wanting such engagement at the cost of negativity.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoI was hoping to see some kind of commitment to return any profits from ads which are later decided to be hate speech, or close to hate speech, to worthy causes. In fact it doesn't really address the "Facebook profits from hate" point other than perhaps implying that they spend more money on preventing it than they gain from it.
- diego 6y agoThey benefit from engagement. Turns out hate is a large part of engagement. Writing an article to say it isn't so does not make it true.
- consumer451 6y ago> Turns out hate is a large part of engagement. My personal experience makes me agree with you. I would even take it further. Hate, or "punching down" is the easiest way to drive engagement. Is anyone aware of any research that may confirm or deny this? My search skills have failed me.
- floatingatoll 6y agoTech social media confuses "free expression" with "amplified expression". If you're going to leave hate-filled posts by a world leader up on your platform, but it's also okay to restrict amplification of those posts. Twitter understands this and has begun restricting amplification in various ways. Will Facebook next do the same? This post suggests that they will not.
- mic47 6y ago> Twitter understands this and has begun restricting amplification in various ways. What twitter did?
- joosters 6y agoTwitter understands this and has begun restricting amplification In what way, exactly? All they seem to have achieved so far is to make Trump's posts more reported on, that's the opposite of restricting amplification.
- ricardo81 6y agoI think social media typically 'amplifies' the worst facets of people in general, and Facebook have built a business model around it. At least the public posts, widely shared or large groups. I'm sure most people in their small groups behave better.
- cbron 6y ago> Importantly, Facebook helped people to get accurate, authoritative health information. Surely the author experienced some form of cognitive dissonance while typing this out.
- madaxe_again 6y agoThe Author is Nick Clegg, ex-leader of the Liberal Democrats in the U.K. - he’s a career politician, so this is kinda second nature.
- paulgb 6y agoThere's been a number of stories of companies putting FB ad buys on hold on the front page recently[1], and a recurring HN response has invariably been "this will accomplish nothing". I'd like to point out that this is a 180 from Zuckerberg's "arbiter of truth" position from before the advertiser boycotts: > they don’t want to see hateful content, our advertisers don’t want to see it, and we don’t want to see it. There is no incentive for us to do anything but remove it. [1] e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23646852 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23646852
- mic47 6y ago> I'd like to point out that this is a 180 from Zuckerberg's "arbiter of truth" position from before the advertiser boycotts Not necessarily. You can hold both views and be consistent. Lot of people accuse Facebook that it's keeping Trump's content for money (i.e. it increases engagement). In that context, sentence "There is no incentive for us to do anything but remove it." is trying to refute. And that would be consistent with FB not wanting to be "arbiter of truth", and keeping "newsworthy" content.
- multiplegeorges 6y agoNot really, a few sentences later he reiterates their commitment to leave hateful (but not hateful enough!) stuff up.
- fred_is_fred 6y agoYes it does. People love to post rage and hate inducing posts because they get replies and likes, and Facebook serves more ads.
- mattmiller 6y agoFacebook benefits from outrage. Outrage leads to engagement and virality. Hate correlates to outrage.
- burkaman 6y agoFacebook doesn't even remove groups that people use to encourage and coordinate actual real-life murder: https://popular.info/p/murder-exposes-facebooks-boogaloo https://popular.info/p/murder-exposes-facebooks-boogaloo
- throwawaysea 6y agoBy my understanding, the boogaloo thing is mostly a meme used as a joke about prepping, like for "SHTF" (https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=SHTF https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=SHTF). For example, "I need [some flashy firearm] for the boog". There are some people/groups who have co-opted that branding and are actually intending violence, but those are in the minority. That's why the Facebook announcement specifically takes a nuanced approach in identifying only a subset of those groups as problematic. From https://about.fb.com/news/2020/06/banning-a-violent-network-in-the-us/ https://about.fb.com/news/2020/06/banning-a-violent-network-...: > This network uses the term boogaloo but is distinct from the broader and loosely-affiliated boogaloo movement because it actively seeks to commit violence. This is also why a lot of the articles attacking Facebook for hosting boogaloo content are plain wrong. To many they come off as unhinged fake news simply because they don't see that the most common use of 'boogaloo' is as a joke.
- burkaman 6y ago> There are some people/groups who have co-opted that branding and are actually intending violence, but those are in the minority. All violent people are in the minority. Even among those who spread literal Nazi propaganda (swastikas, Mein Kampf quotes, etc.), only a small percentage are willing to physically attack Jews. If this isn't a problem, then what's the point of removing any hateful content at all? Only a small minority of people posting it are really violent.
- gadders 6y agoYes, but they are likely Trump voters, so any vague accusation of "hate speech" (like intentionally not realising what is satire) will be one further step in preventing his re-election in November. Let's be clear that this is the end goal.
- asdff 6y agoIf hate keeps people using the site, they benefit from hate.
- bryan_w 6y agoBut why would people use a site makes them mad?
- asdff 6y agoWhy do people go on /r/asktrumpsupporters and ask the same questions for the past 5 years? It's cathartic. You get an adrenaline rush from arguing, and satisfaction if you feel you've proved yourself right. It is the same primal emotions from our childhood schoolyard argument days creeping back into adult life. Very interesting psychologically how facebook is tuned to tap into these primal and tribalistic tendencies, but also very terrifying how wired we are for this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yalogin 6y agoWell if we were to believe they don't benefit from hate, we need proof. For that we need numbers. So unless they start implementing some filters for hate, we will not know the impact. In reality, we all know they do benefit from it. I would say its on them to prove they don't benefit, not using rhetoric but using numbers.
- burger_moon 6y agoIn a way they don't benefit from hate. How many people here quit fb because of politics and toxic communities?
- hangonhn 6y agoI had to Google it to confirm but Nick Clegg is the same guy who was the Deputy Prime Minister of the UK under David Cameron. I'm super curious about how that came to be -- what skillsets and talents a former Deputy Prime Minister of the UK provides to a company like Facebook.
- burkaman 6y agoHe's friends with a lot of people in the UK government and Facebook doesn't want to pay taxes there: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/oct/08/facebook-uk-tax-bill-sales-margaret-hodge https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/oct/08/facebook-...
- jasonv 6y agoBeen wondering if FB and other socials could move away from engagement volume-based advertising. Perhaps "low max # ads a day" kind of thing. It would hurt revenues, to be sure, but seems that Facebook already has outsized revenues per employee count. And certainly, Zuck's share valuation is a bit on the high (and possibly unsustainable) end.
- mrweasel 6y ago>Facebook does not profit from hate. Billions of people use Facebook and Instagram because they have good experiences I'm fairly sure that the racists, Nazis, conspiracy theorists and pedofiles are have a great experience communicating with like minded people on Facebooks platforms. More interestingly I very excited to see if companies like Coca Cola, Lego and Verizon will see any change in sales after boycotting Facebook for 30 days. If their sales remain largely unaffected it will change the whole premise for a large number of companies and challenge the existence many "online ad agencies", which do little more than manage social media accounts.
- Dwight-Schrute 6y ago> Facebook Does Not Benefit from Hate False. - Dwight Schrute
- throwawaysea 6y agoObviously, Facebook does not benefit much from "hate speech". The majority of content on Facebook and the associated advertising/revenues are from other types of content. The broad generalizations made by the Twitter mob and news media about Facebook being 'built' on hate or 'profiting' from hate is hyperbolic. That said, I think it is fair to say that Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, and YouTube all benefit from engagement. And engagement is often built on emotion, particularly negative emotions like outrage. Personally, I wish Facebook would simply not give credence to complaints about 'hate' and only censor content that breaks the law. If someone doesn't like a certain page or group or whatever, they can just choose not to follow them. It is very simple. Therefore, what the anti-Facebook crowd is asking for is not about their own experience. It's that they want no one else to be able to harbor certain views or opinions or even to discuss them. That's dangerous, and the vague and ever-expanding label of "hate speech" disallows conversations that need to take place on controversial topics. Given that there it is easy to curate one's own feed and experience on Facebook, the motivation of this activist mob is simply to stifle others' freedom of speech. The fact that they are doing it by pressuring a large private organization (instead of a public one) does not make it any better, even if it is legal. It is still unethical and immoral from my perspective, because freedom of speech is that fundamental to our society. Today in the US, there is a ubiquity to attempts from mobs stifling speech using labels like "hate speech". This must be met with fierce opposition in all situations, big and small. If not, it will eventually bleed into more and more of our society. We're already seeing it in absurd situations like Stephen Hsu's resignation (see https://www.thecollegefix.com/scholar-forced-to-resign-over-study-that-found-police-shootings-not-biased-against-blacks/ https://www.thecollegefix.com/scholar-forced-to-resign-over-... or https://quillette.com/2020/07/01/on-steve-hsu-and-the-campaign-to-thwart-free-inquiry/ https://quillette.com/2020/07/01/on-steve-hsu-and-the-campai...).
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoAnd the News websites are claiming sensational headlines don't get them more clicks. I would like Facebook to put the money where the mouth is and remove featured image, title from the shared URL and show an image of 'Summary' of the article from og:description tag i.e. forcing people at-least to read a bit about the content.
- sub7 6y agoNope, they benefit from the systemic robbery of your time and attention while giving you almost no value in return.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoUnpopular opinion: FB is just the scapegoat. First they claimed 100k$ worth of Russian ads made Trump win the election, when 1B$ from Bloomberg didn't move the needle. In the age before social media, left- and rightwing could pretend the other side doesn't exist. This has changed, and things have gotten more divisive as a consequence.
- ykevinator 6y agoRidiculous
- rp00 6y agoI’m not convinced hate speech is real and I’m certainly convinced that hate speech is not violence. I fucking hate Facebook.