5 ms·

I am sorry for your experience. Do you mind sharing what part of India you're from? It is really surprising to me that relatively better off Dalits would still

I am sorry for your experience. Do you mind sharing what part of India you're from? It is really surprising to me that relatively better off Dalits would still find the need to convert to a different religion to avoid discrimination. Even more surprising that this is happening at a wider scale. I respect your personal choice, of course, but curious why people choose to convert to a different religion instead of just shunning the Hindu identity, given Christianity also tends to have problematic beliefs. Is it because sharing religious beliefs makes it easier to share a common identity?

vijaybritto 6y ago
People simply need a way to be looked at as equals under God. They convert to christianity for this main reason. But the Brahmins will claim that they converted for 'rice bags'. Its still a widely used slur in India while referring to converted christians. A better off dalit is still a dalit. Thats the point. The society will discriminate against you in all ways possible. Right from job applications to finding a partner
- cma 6y ago
  > People simply need a way to be looked at as equals under God. Christianity doesn't seem like a great choice then since it teaches God will burn all non-Christians eternally in Hell.
  - disgruntledphd2 6y ago
    This is a belief that is associated with Christianity, but doesn't have a lot of support in the scriptures.
- naruvimama 6y ago
  The term "rice bags" is not from India but from the west where poor natives who are easily converted with small incentives are termed "rice bowl/bag" christians, meaning they are not true christians. There used to be some kind of exclusivity in being a christian in India. This might no longer true. I am from Chennai where Christianity has spread rapidly in recent years, a christian doctor who died of covid had to be cremated in a Hindu cemetery because of conflicts between the different christian denominations. This has been the case in the North-east of India for several years now, since they are more than 80% christian.
randomguy2379 6y ago
I'm from the northern part of India. Well it actually hits you harder once you are better off. You could drive a BMW, live in a big house and have all the luxuries of being an upper class person, but hindus would still see you as an inferior lower caste. In terms of social hierarchy, a poor brahmin who flips burgers at a burger store is higher caste than a dalit doctor. Converting is the only way to get rid of your caste. It's common amongst Hindus to ask each other's caste and the only way to say that you have none is to not be a Hindu. If you are a hindu then people will figure out your caste from your last name.
- deleted 6y ago
  [deleted]
- TulliusCicero 6y ago
  What about abandoning religion altogether as an agnostic or atheist? Does that not count?
  - devdas 6y ago
    You can be an atheist Hindu. Caste and religion have nothing to do with belief in a god, more than one god, or zero gods.
- kaybe 6y ago
  So what would happen if, say, an Australian or Haitian converted to Hinduism? Or is that not possible?
  - devdas 6y ago
    Traditionally, you couldn't convert to Hinduism (Hinduism is literlly the set of religions followed by people in South Asia). In modern times, you can convert to Hinduism. You would end up without a caste, but with higher or lower social status depending on your original country.
ashtonkem 6y ago
Not Indian, but I suspect that Christianity has a lot of bits and pieces that would be extremely attractive to Dalits. Early Christianity was the religion of slaves, soldiers, and other low status individuals in Roman society. Thus the scriptures are packed full of positive references towards the poor, the meek, and the downtrodden. But even more important, christian teachings emphasis a lot about moral equality in life and death; all people are inherently sinners, and all believers get the same treatment in death regardless of status or wealth. This is, I assume, an extremely attractive proposition if you feel burned by a religion that says that your low status is the fault of a past you, and that in death your best hope is a slightly higher status the next time around. I do find it fascinating how a converted Dalit is basically freed from the social burdens of their class. I would not have expected that, as most religious groups heap scorn or actual punishments on those who convert to another religion.
- paloaltokid 6y ago
  > I do find it fascinating how a converted Dalit is basically freed from the social burdens of their class. I would not have expected that, as most religious groups heap scorn or actual punishments on those who convert to another religion. Based on what I've read so far in people's responses to my question it makes a kind of sense. If you convert to a different religion, historically speaking, you are now "out of competition" in terms of marriages, allocation of dowry, so on. So since many people historically never married across religion, there's no problem being nice to people who aren't competing for your same economic resources. Please note that I don't mean to indicate approval for any of these things, just that historically that's how it has played out.
  - ashtonkem 6y ago
    Right, but often groups are extremely hostile to apostates because apostasy represents an existential threat towards the religion itself. This is why many religions require a formal shunning of apostates, if not explicit punishment. Talleyrand famously had a meal of ice wine and cold meat after being excommunicated in 1791 since good Christians were supposed to deny him “fire and water”; a cute anecdote at the time, but a potentially fatal prescription during medieval or ancient times. Hearing about a benefit of apostasy, from members of ones former religion no less, is quite surprising.
Lio 6y ago
What Christian beliefs do you think are problematic? I'm an atheist myself but I don't see many things in Christianity that are particularly bad (...I just don't believe in the supernatural).
- TeaDrunk 6y ago
  At least in America, evangelicalism and its voting bloc has been soundly contributing to the polarization of the country. Additionally, evangelicalism and its voting bloc are extremely politically active on matters such as abortion. (Catholicism has also been increasingly buying up hospitals and then denying women birth control and other reproductive-oriented resolutions like uterus and ovary removal to resolve healthcare conditions.)

vijaybritto 6y ago

People simply need a way to be looked at as equals under God. They convert to christianity for this main reason. But the Brahmins will claim that they converted for 'rice bags'. Its still a widely used slur in India while referring to converted christians. A better off dalit is still a dalit. Thats the point. The society will discriminate against you in all ways possible. Right from job applications to finding a partner

cma 6y ago
> People simply need a way to be looked at as equals under God. Christianity doesn't seem like a great choice then since it teaches God will burn all non-Christians eternally in Hell.
- disgruntledphd2 6y ago
  This is a belief that is associated with Christianity, but doesn't have a lot of support in the scriptures.
naruvimama 6y ago
The term "rice bags" is not from India but from the west where poor natives who are easily converted with small incentives are termed "rice bowl/bag" christians, meaning they are not true christians. There used to be some kind of exclusivity in being a christian in India. This might no longer true. I am from Chennai where Christianity has spread rapidly in recent years, a christian doctor who died of covid had to be cremated in a Hindu cemetery because of conflicts between the different christian denominations. This has been the case in the North-east of India for several years now, since they are more than 80% christian.

randomguy2379 6y ago

I'm from the northern part of India. Well it actually hits you harder once you are better off. You could drive a BMW, live in a big house and have all the luxuries of being an upper class person, but hindus would still see you as an inferior lower caste. In terms of social hierarchy, a poor brahmin who flips burgers at a burger store is higher caste than a dalit doctor. Converting is the only way to get rid of your caste. It's common amongst Hindus to ask each other's caste and the only way to say that you have none is to not be a Hindu. If you are a hindu then people will figure out your caste from your last name.

deleted 6y ago
[deleted]
TulliusCicero 6y ago
What about abandoning religion altogether as an agnostic or atheist? Does that not count?
- devdas 6y ago
  You can be an atheist Hindu. Caste and religion have nothing to do with belief in a god, more than one god, or zero gods.
kaybe 6y ago
So what would happen if, say, an Australian or Haitian converted to Hinduism? Or is that not possible?
- devdas 6y ago
  Traditionally, you couldn't convert to Hinduism (Hinduism is literlly the set of religions followed by people in South Asia). In modern times, you can convert to Hinduism. You would end up without a caste, but with higher or lower social status depending on your original country.

ashtonkem 6y ago

Not Indian, but I suspect that Christianity has a lot of bits and pieces that would be extremely attractive to Dalits. Early Christianity was the religion of slaves, soldiers, and other low status individuals in Roman society. Thus the scriptures are packed full of positive references towards the poor, the meek, and the downtrodden. But even more important, christian teachings emphasis a lot about moral equality in life and death; all people are inherently sinners, and all believers get the same treatment in death regardless of status or wealth. This is, I assume, an extremely attractive proposition if you feel burned by a religion that says that your low status is the fault of a past you, and that in death your best hope is a slightly higher status the next time around. I do find it fascinating how a converted Dalit is basically freed from the social burdens of their class. I would not have expected that, as most religious groups heap scorn or actual punishments on those who convert to another religion.

paloaltokid 6y ago
> I do find it fascinating how a converted Dalit is basically freed from the social burdens of their class. I would not have expected that, as most religious groups heap scorn or actual punishments on those who convert to another religion. Based on what I've read so far in people's responses to my question it makes a kind of sense. If you convert to a different religion, historically speaking, you are now "out of competition" in terms of marriages, allocation of dowry, so on. So since many people historically never married across religion, there's no problem being nice to people who aren't competing for your same economic resources. Please note that I don't mean to indicate approval for any of these things, just that historically that's how it has played out.
- ashtonkem 6y ago
  Right, but often groups are extremely hostile to apostates because apostasy represents an existential threat towards the religion itself. This is why many religions require a formal shunning of apostates, if not explicit punishment. Talleyrand famously had a meal of ice wine and cold meat after being excommunicated in 1791 since good Christians were supposed to deny him “fire and water”; a cute anecdote at the time, but a potentially fatal prescription during medieval or ancient times. Hearing about a benefit of apostasy, from members of ones former religion no less, is quite surprising.

Lio 6y ago

What Christian beliefs do you think are problematic? I'm an atheist myself but I don't see many things in Christianity that are particularly bad (...I just don't believe in the supernatural).

TeaDrunk 6y ago
At least in America, evangelicalism and its voting bloc has been soundly contributing to the polarization of the country. Additionally, evangelicalism and its voting bloc are extremely politically active on matters such as abortion. (Catholicism has also been increasingly buying up hospitals and then denying women birth control and other reproductive-oriented resolutions like uterus and ovary removal to resolve healthcare conditions.)