10 ms·
Coronavirus Brings American Decline Out in the Open
- ikeyany 6y agoI always enjoy Noah Smith's articles. Great read. > With its high housing costs, poor infrastructure and transit, endemic gun violence, police brutality and bitter political and racial divisions, the U.S. will be a less appealing place for high-skilled workers to live The above is a "concern" but it's not quite an "urgent issue" within the tech world. Cries to bring our public transportation into the 21st century go unheard (we can all afford to drive a nice car to work, so no need for urgent change), along with cries to improve educational standards for those who aren't upper-middle class (just pay for better schooling or simply move to a nicer neighborhood, no need for urgent change). Racial disparities and police brutality generally go ignored until there is overwhelming proof (well it looks like the only ones getting it bad are people who seem to deserve it, no need for urgent change). And then there's health care, which is tied to your employment (but if you have a nice gig compared to the masses, why would you want anything to upset the status quo?). Perhaps the threat of industry moving away for good will be an incentive to take notice. "The US is a 3rd world country with a Gucci belt."
- swyx 6y agothe professional opinion columnist is a rare breed. I am torn on their practical utility but I also admire them and secretly wish I could be one.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI think we always have to be a bit skeptical of articles in this genre. A decline narrative ought to imply different or at least refocused policies, where some important things aren't relevant to the decline and other less important things are. When an author ties every problem in the country to the decline, and their proposed solution is enacting all their preferred policies, it really comes across as more of a manifesto. Will investors really "abandon the U.S. and the dollar in large amounts" because gun violence is high or the subways are poor quality?
- nine_zeros 6y agoNo they won't. But only because there is no alternative. The vast majority of global economic activity now happens in Asia. Tech was one sweet area dominated by the US but even that seems to be sliding (happily being enabled by the administration). Once these economic activity participants figure out a way to avoid the dollar, they will (there is no goodwill with the dollar). When this happens, its done. We are busted. That said, nobody is moving away from the dollar soon. However, we need to elect representatives who don't jeopardize this. Being the global reserve means moving in lock step with the world. It doesn't mean reneging or bullying.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI can certainly see why maintaining the dollar's position requires cultivating a reputation as a country that doesn't bully others or renege on its agreements. But again, what does that have to do with gun violence?
- nine_zeros 6y agoIt projects the US as an uncivilized country, on par with mismanaged democracies where kids are routinely shot in schools.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoSure, but you could make that argument about any problem in the US. Is there a reason to believe gun violence is particularly problematic to foreign investors? If not it's pretty strange to bring up foreign investment as a reason we should prevent gun violence.
- nine_zeros 6y agoIn isolation, it's just another problem. As part of a bigger picture, it's a reflection of society. There is real fear that the US government is just incompetent and gun violence is part of that jigsaw puzzle of deciphering if the US is actually going to grow in the future.
- mikestew 6y agoCould the U. S. collapse “like Venezuela”, as the article suggests? Mmm, I think that has very low odds. But the fact that I’m willing to lay odds at all is a huge shift from if you had asked me 20 years ago when I might have laughed at the mere suggestion.
- dzonga 6y agopeople, who have lived elsewhere, especially in the usual 3rd world countries and have also experienced some 1st world ones. will know the US is a rich 3rd world country, and has been since Reagan. the pain isn't felt yet much by the middle class due to them swallowing the america is great, propaganda. but step outside the us, and see a proper 1st world country, with fast transit, clean cities, less police presence. and then you realize you've been living a lie. hell, Westworld, had to shoot scenes in Singapore for a futuristic city
- rayiner 6y ago> With its high housing costs, poor infrastructure and transit, endemic gun violence, police brutality and bitter political and racial divisions, the U.S. At least the first five of these seem to mostly be a problem in New York, where the author is based, and similar cities, not “America” writ large. For example, the author complains about the housing costs, but the national home ownership rate in the US is about the same as the UK or France, and substantially higher than Germany. (And the median American home is twice as big as in those countries.) The author complains about the lack of transit, but the median American commute is among the shortest in the OECD. The homicide rate in my Maryland county isn’t great (about 2 per 100,000) but it’s closer to say Canada or Belgium (1.7-1.8 per 100,000) than those countries are to Sweden (1.1 per 100,000). Racial divisions are a challenge throughout America, of course, but that’s true all over the world. France’s Macron is talking about a government takeover of Islam: https://www.ft.com/content/88c1e898-5269-11ea-90ad-25e377c0ee1f https://www.ft.com/content/88c1e898-5269-11ea-90ad-25e377c0e.... And Macron is the liberal! Le Pen, a far right candidate, is polling dangerously close to him at 45-55. As a brown person, I’d much rather be in America right now even with Trump than in France. What the recent situations are bringing out is not that “America” is in decline, but that “American cities” are in decline. The mayor of Chicago, Lori Lightfoot, recently said that cutting police funding was impossible, because given the union contracts the city would have to lay off mostly black and Hispanic officers! This is a police force that was running Abu Ghraib-style interrogation centers. For what New York is spending extending one subway line a few miles, cities like Copenhagen have built entire new, fully automated, lines. New York City spends $25,000 per student, or about 44% of the city’s median income. London spends just 15% of the city’s median household per student. You can’t fix a problem unless you can properly identify the problem. Articles like this are willfully blind to the problem.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoSo what is the problem exactly? You don’t really say.
- rayiner 6y agoI don’t know! But we have a pretty good idea where the problem is. Most of the stuff that the author complains about: housing, infrastructure, education, policing, etc., are local issues. They’re not local just in the US, with our federal system, they’re local in many other developed countries too: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/reg_glance-2016-32-en.pdf?expires=1593538711&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=F3ABDD087D941489FFF762F71784C4CE https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/reg_glance-2016-32-e... (table 3.1). In the US state and local governments are responsible for about half of all spending. That’s on the more “federal” side, but in line with say Germany or Spain. Canada, Denmark, and Sweden delegate even more spending authority to state and local governments, with a remarkable 80% of total government spending being controlled at the provincial level in Canada. So if New York can’t build transit because it costs ten times as much per mile as in Germany, or New York can’t properly educate its kids even though it spends twice as much per student as other developed nations, or New York has high housing prices—is that a problem with “America” as the article claims? Or is it a problem with New York?
- 236dev 6y agoIf people think that America is a 3rd world country, or anywhere near a 3rd world country, then they haven't been to a 3rd world country. The US has major problems, undoubtedly, but we have a long way to fall till we hit the position of 3rd world. We are even leagues better than developing nations. I can say this as I have spent a long time living in both.
- Answerawake 6y agoCan you provide some hard examples to compare the two?
- pinkfoot 6y agoPavements. You can learn everything you want to know about a country from its pavements.
- 236dev 6y agoSure: Healthcare: - In the US it is expensive but you get decent care. If you are not making enough you get medicaid or subsidized healthcare that actually works (even in most rural areas). - In for example Ukraine, technically there is socialized healthcare, but you still have to pay due to corruption. For the average Ukrainian, it's not an unsubstantial amount. They don't have the newest drugs, technology, or that sorts. I'm using Ukraine as an example but also applies to other developing countries generally. Infrastructure: - US has bad infrastructure compared to Japan. But the roads are generally paved (even in most rural areas), there is normally some sort of government that fixes the infrastructure. Sure there are cases of the dam breaking, but there are many, many examples of the government building parks, dams, paving new roads, fixing things, etc. - In developing or even worse in an ldc, the rural roads are not normally paved except for 'main' roads. Outside major cities the road quality, building construction rapidly deteriorates. China is an exception to this, but I could talk a bit about China and how it is unique. Water: - In the US water is generally safe. You are able to point to Flint, Michigan which has a population of less than 100k, and a few others. - In developing countries the water is bad. For instance when I first went to Moldova I got a very itchy and weird rash. When I started drinking bottled water, it went away. In other countries you can get parasites or diarrhea from drinking the water. This is not normally an issue in the US. Corruption: - In the US you can go to the government and not worry about bribing or corruption in general. The police will not stop you and ask for money. The opposite is true in many developing nations. Internet: - In the US, even in rural America, you can get Internet that is somewhat acceptable. Most Americans can visit Google and watch YouTube without major connection issues or that sort. Many places in rural areas of developing countries have bad connections at best. Banking: - In the US you have FDIC, many banking regulations, solid legal framework, trusted institutions. It's a bit sketchy in other countries, though might be because I'm a foreigner. Banking fees are much higher from what I have seen, especially in Argentina+Chile. I was blown away when I was there. These are just some of the things I could think of from the top of my head. There are many more things and experience I could talk about, but this is a good start. There is a reason why millions of people try and immigrate to the US each year, that's not just random. I'm sure you could point of exceptions to what I laid out, but those are just exceptions.
- fallingfrog 6y agoGonna be honest, I’m taking my family out of the country as soon as we are able to leave. I don’t want my children to grow up here, what are they going to do in 20 years when everything is so much worse than it is now? Anybody can see which way the wind is blowing. Good job baby boomers, you win. You used the whole country as an atm machine and ran it into the ground. Hope that 5% tax cut was worth it.
- tanzbaer 6y agoWhere will you go?
- fallingfrog 6y agoCanada
- hyperman1 6y agoWhile I believe the USA and most of the western world is indeed declining, there is another side to this: Corona might be a wake up call. Could anyone believe an article like this would be published in a major news org before Corona? It was unthinkable. But now we all see the governements blundering from one incompetent stupidity to the next. All western governements, not only the USA. Before Corona, people knew but didn't care much. Apathy and cynicism everywhere. But now, reaction is building. Slowly, but at last something is moving. I think we need a rude wake up call. I just hope this is rude enough.
- jobigoud 6y ago> Could anyone believe an article like this would be published in a major news org before Corona? It was unthinkable. Yes it could. It wasn't unthinkable at all. In fact the entire campaign of the current president was based on the fact that the USA is not as great as it once was, that it is in need to be made great again. So yes, this sentiment was very much spread all around before the pandemic, with widely different ideas on how to correct the trajectory but that's beside the point.
- hyperman1 6y agoYes and no. The current US president has a completely different communication style than the 'serious'-tone mainstream media. You're correct that he's become president because of it. And people were aware and complaining, but not doing much themselves. That's what changing now.